Come and Gone?

[dontcry44]

Should any of the members who joined and then left GNR after it was reformed be credited with any work they may have contributed to Chinese Democracy? (ie. Buckethead)

[Saul]

why not? people like paul huge/tobias have been credited in the past.

[mikegiuliana]

As long as their stuff is on any of the albums regardless of how small the contribution was I say sure/.

[Chief]

of course, its only fair.

if you wrote a riff or a major part of a song, i think its just wrong not to get credit for that!!

[grog mug]

Yeah it just goes to show that the amazing guitar parts your going to hear on the album belong to the best guitarist around BUCKETHEAD.  Which will be credited on the album no matter what happens.

[sergejg]

Yeah it just goes to show that the amazing guitar parts your going to hear on the album belong to the best guitarist around BUCKETHEAD.? Which will be credited on the album no matter what happens.

Buckethead is in my opinion the worst guitar player the new GNR had.  But I guess that if the rumors and tommy are right, then he will definatley get credit for most of the new songs.

[Dr. Blutarsky]

Credit should be given where credit is due, no matter how screwed up the individual (Buckethead)

[sergejg]

Credit should be given where credit is due, no matter how screwed up the individual (Buckethead)

no matter if he is a zombie and not a human (Buckethead)

[shaun]

Sure they should recieve a credit, why not?

[MadmanDan]

And it's gonna be a loooooong list...

[AdZ]

Definetly, I mean Josh Freese wrote Chinese Democracy for instance.

[LionGoddess]

Anyone who had contributed anything should be given credit for it whether they are in the band anymore or not.

[Eeebs]

Yes, I think it would be proper for people who assisted in putting together the album to be credited.  Man, the cd is gonna need a separate booklet just for that