Since Axl?s voice is not that particular there, scott sings it well, and when it comes to the music, for some reason i feel? like VR plays it more solid, the solo sounds just right, like it is and and it sounds more full, the rhythm is also more heard, i like it better.
It only lacks the screaming of Axl in " I ain't got no money but it goes to show"
after that it?s definitely cooler.?
VR.
Vocally Axl is superior to Scott singing it, but then again Scott is singing a cover song and Axl is singing his own song, so it's difficult to compare.
Musically, Slash/Duff/Matt (and even Dave) do it far better then NuGnR. When VR does it it sounds like Rock N Roll, you can hear all the instruments clearly, it sounds rough and that is how it's ment to sound.
When GnR do it now it sounds too polish, too much noise and you can't identify any sound individually in it.
That's the basis, the music, VR plays it better, no doubt about it.
GNRs version anyday. Scott sounds better on this one than Mr Brownstone
But without Axl it just doesn't sound right and I like Robin's leads.
How can you like robin's leads? damn!!! i'm getting tired of robin fucking up the songs, really... he's not good enough for GN'R, not even this version of GN'R
I'm Sorry for any offense taken, just my opinion
Author