Who should replace buckethead?

[Verse Chorus Verse]

Was Slash, Matt Duff, Steven, Adler, Izzy or Gilby a big name before joining Gn'R? Not really, so why does a new member have to be someone everyone knows?

[-Jack-]

I didn't realize it. No need to get an attitude over it...

I liked this place because it wasn't nearly as hostile as others. It seems that is changing recently. We are all here for the same reason, we should be able to get along.


On Topic: DJ is great, but im hoping for a bigger name for GNR>

Look.. I've been here awhile, and the reason I liked this forum was because it was organized, fun, and respectful. Now it just seems like noobs are ruining it. I rarely post here because of that. People make threads about the same things over and over again and its just annoying. I wasn't trying to diss or make you feel bad. Im not even calling you a noob. Im just saying try looking next time and respecting the rules.

  -jack

[BurningHills]

I've been here since 2002 if not longer..don't let the post count fool you.

[awolgnr]

Beautiful Creatures' first cd had stellar guitar playing.  Their second one, "Deuce" was recorded after Ashba left the group and is average.  I can't believe I forgot about that guy!  Hell yeah, he would be a great choice!

To the guy pissing and moaning about the topic: if the topic is such a waste of your time, why do you have time to post and complain about it? Just move on.

[italysfinest1985]

I don't really agree with Ashba in GnR...but I respect ur opinion.

I do think the hostility and the "rules" are starting to ruin alot of the fun here.

[GunnerOne 84]

I'm ok with the rules in place, with all the activity going on we need organization, and that's why mods merge topics, move topics, lock topics etc.

However, it is a mod's job to handle this kind of thing, not everyone screaming what the fuck is wrong with you, this topic is on page 3 damn noob shut up and go home. People make mistakes, people are going to break rules knowingly or not. And if someone wants to correct someone, there is a nicer way to do it than is currently being done by older members.

[killingvector]

It is also the job of the poster to check the board in order to avoid redundancy. Common sense really.


I am getting tired of these 'I have a thought about GnR, let me post a new thread about it" threads as well.

[GunnerOne 84]

I agree, i check the board a lot only to find very pointless topics on page one. I agree the mess needs to get cleaned up, i just think it could be done in a nicer way.

[Niko]

come on men chill out

don make this forum a horrible and hostile place to post like mygnr

i agrre with gunnerone 84

[-Jack-]

I've been here since 2002 if not longer..don't let the post count fool you.

Yeah I've seen you around BurningHills. Sorry bout the harshness. But you must have noticed a change in the people and topics here.. its just getting cluttered.

To the guy pissing and moaning about the topic: if the topic is such a waste of your time, why do you have time to post and complain about it? Just move on.

The topic IS a waste of my time AND board space. And im here cause its bs that people take up board space when theres ALREADY other threads for things like this. (im not trying to disrespect you burninghills)

I do think the hostility and the "rules" are starting to ruin alot of the fun here.

People are hostile cause the rules are being broken. Alot of the older posters don't bother posting here anymore cause its falling apart (no disrespect ment towards Jarmo and the mods.. you guys are doin what you can. i love HTGTH. thats why im pissed). Its just annoying to see my favorite forum get wreaked by a flood of new people. I love this place and im sorry if im being "rude"

I'm ok with the rules in place, with all the activity going on we need organization, and that's why mods merge topics, move topics, lock topics etc.

However, it is a mod's job to handle this kind of thing, not everyone screaming what the fuck is wrong with you, this topic is on page 3 damn noob shut up and go home. People make mistakes, people are going to break rules knowingly or not. And if someone wants to correct someone, there is a nicer way to do it than is currently being done by older members.

It seems like sometimes the mods aren't there.. so why not tell people off? I really dont know. I dont mean to be a jerk.. and I can understand I was one.. but its hard to balance being nice, and trying to get the rules through to people. Im sorry I came off how I did.

It is also the job of the poster to check the board in order to avoid redundancy. Common sense really.


I am getting tired of these 'I have a thought about GnR, let me post a new thread about it" threads as well.

Thank you Killingvector... you've been here a great deal longer than me, and I respect you.

I agree, i check the board a lot only to find very pointless topics on page one. I agree the mess needs to get cleaned up, i just think it could be done in a nicer way.

Yeah.. once again, sorry about being harsh. =/

come on men chill out

don make this forum a horrible and hostile place to post like mygnr

i agrre with gunnerone 84

And I dont want this forum to be a mess like MyGNR. But yeah agreed.. I'll try and watch myself next time.

[Ineverlearn000022]

Was Slash, Matt Duff, Steven, Adler, Izzy or Gilby a big name before joining Gn'R? Not really, so why does a new member have to be someone everyone knows?

...Neither was Axl.

[Carlos_f_Rose]

Was Slash, Matt Duff, Steven, Adler, Izzy or Gilby a big name before joining Gn'R? Not really, so why does a new member have to be someone everyone knows?

what???

What do you mean pal?

Was Axl a big name before joining Guns n Roses?

[circusboy666]

if they plan to keep a sound like bh they need john 5. if they have a long term plan for a different style guitarist, they could have pittman just sample bucket for now. so that justs open the doors from anyone literally from izzy to carlos santana. i personally think kim from soundgarden would fit in awesome. he rocks really hard and can solo awesome. he is really ugly though.

[smithandheston]

I totally think R Fink can handle the dutys himself, he impressed me last time i saw em (2002) But i guess on May 15 i get to see exactly what happened with the line up, SO EXCITED!!! 

[GNRkid]

Steve Vai


but i think 2 is enough anyway

[mesaboogie]

A guy related to aiken promotions owner here ireland says thats details have been received as regards stage set-up, stage hands, gear, times of arrival etc

Strange as it may seem he say its appears that "Dizzy's guitar tech" is listed as a member of the group working the stage.

So has Dizzy have replaced buckethead...not playing his parts but by taking on the rhythem guitar in songs that require it live and then back to piano on others.? This frees up space for richard fortus to take on many of the buckethead parts (with his own slant live).

So when the band walk out on stage next Friday it will be same but no buckethead.?

[nesquick]

May be the enigma. Good choice if it's him.

[Lucs]

Interesting, who gave you this idea ? lol

[busngabb]

Like who?

[nesquick]

You gave me this idea ?
It it's him, he is good.