Here Today... Gone To Hell!

If you could put GnR together with any member ever in each spot (i.e. drums could be Steven, Matt, Brain) obviously the only mainstay being Axl.
Mine would be
Axl-Vocals
Duff-Bass
Slash-guitar
Izzy-guitar
Brain-drums
and if I was gonna go with 3 guitarists like Axl was for a little while Robin too

Axl, Duff, Slash, Izzy, Steven

 : ok:  As Bret Hart always said, "the best there is, the best there was, and the best there ever will be."

Good to see your bringing wrestling into this Dizzy  : ok: Anyway my perfect line-up would be the original plus Gilby Clarke, given the option to have him in i could not say no :no: he's just so cool :yes:

axl, slash, duff
then i aren't bothered about the drummer or rythem guitar- whoever
why did they have to go?  :crying: :crying: :crying: :crying: :crying:

Well considering all things whoever the rhytm player is in your lineup is important. Izzy did alot of songwriting, and gilby wrote alot of cool shit on his solo albums so I think it's a factor one should consider.

Every member is important. I don't see how you could only care about Slash Duff and Axl

My perfect line up?

It'll include no guitars ( why having  guitar player where you could have 3 keyboardists...) trompet, sax, and background vocals....

It'll include Tracy ( lead singer) + Dizzy + Teddy + Roberta ( back up singer) + The Horn sexy section and Chris Pittman

Izzy is an awesome song writer and Steven is a great drummer. I agree all five members are equally important. Take one of them away and it's not the same. No other version of Guns N Roses could compare

Axl, Izzy, Duff Slash, Steven

sorry- i liked izzy too!! i guess he wrote alot of stuff for the album.. SORRY!!   :smoking:

I'd mention Steven to Dizzy's like his fuckin' brother he sang on the same stage as him remember :hihi:

Axl, Slash, Duff, Izzy, Matt, Dizzy (if you want a 3rd guitarist I'd go with Gilby..but 2 is enough)

The original line up. No questions asked. : ok:

Axl, Izzy, Slash, Steven & Duff


The formation related with GUNS N' ROSES

The Original Line-up, Maybee with Joe Perry a permanent member as a second lead guitarist or somhing. Damn Slash and Joe sound good playing together.  : ok:

where did slash play with joe perry? and what did they play? and where can I get it?

durring the Aerosmith/GNR tour there was a segment when Joe n Steven did Mama kin with GNR. I found it on Kazza. Try that or search google or somthing. Then Aerosmith did a cover of Mama kin! GNr is 20 times better though.... Sry i couldnt help more man.

actully i found out i have the song still. hehe. if u want i can send it to u.

That was Paris, June 6, 1992.


How do you cover your own song?  "Mama Kin" was written by Steven Tyler and recorded/released by Aerosmith in 1972.

it was? i though GNR originally did. Fuck i hate being such a young GNR fan :S

Axl, Slash, Duff, Izzy, Steven, Dizzy and Gilby Clarke. I included Dizzy so that they could play the UYI songs and Gilby because he's just such a cool ass mutha fucka.  : ok: