Who is the fucking drummer??

[Alpachiris]

Who ??

[Satapher]

adler??? 

[D]

I think whoever hits Play on the drum machine

[CheapJon]

Dizzy is, at least he's playing them bongo drums on wttj right?

[polluxlm]

The guy without the guitar.

[AdZ]

Jesus we get a thread like this every day.

[PJ]

the guy with the ?guitar ?

[Lucky]

Looks like Slush took a haircut

[Tatu]

Frank Ferrrer 


Brain is gone 
Matt is gone 
Steven is gone (but he can return)

[von]

Frank is the drummer. Those drummers were a lie. A lie!

[estebanf]

The drummer is the one who looks like Whoopi Goldberg

[ChrisPittman]

whoever started this thread should be banned, i mean, we already had a thread about the drummers in GNR started yesterday. in this picture, frank is the black man, and bryan is not pictured. both are officially guns n roses members. frank also played with TOOL, once, in 2002 when the band needed two drummers onstage for the song 'Triad'

also, since both are counted as GNR members, perhaps we have duel drums on the cd (not likely) or we have each man playing a selection of tunes with the band a night. although that would mean changing the drum specifications mid concert would be a pain in the arse

still, if bryan is headed back and still listed as an official member then why has frank been allowed record all the drum parts on chinese democracy? it doesnt make sense

still, i dont care really, the album is finished and theyre just mixing now so no delays for a nice summer release

[bringbackadler]

 I hope Ferrar IS NOT the drummer.

 Although, I think I prefer him to Brain.

 I'm praying since Steven and Axl talked, we can plan to see them together in the future.

 Ferrar and Brain can't even remotely compare to Adler's drumming ability.

 C'mon 'Popcorn' !! We want you back, bro !!


/bringbackadler

[RageNirvanaNIN]

 I hope Ferrar IS NOT the drummer.

 Although, I think I prefer him to Brain.

 I'm praying since Steven and Axl talked, we can plan to see them together in the future.

 Ferrar and Brain can't even remotely compare to Adler's drumming ability.

 C'mon 'Popcorn' !! We want you back, bro !!


/bringbackadler

I hope you are joking , adler was the worst GNR drummer , technically speaking hahahaa!

[Ganja4Life]

 I hope Ferrar IS NOT the drummer.

 Although, I think I prefer him to Brain.

 I'm praying since Steven and Axl talked, we can plan to see them together in the future.

 Ferrar and Brain can't even remotely compare to Adler's drumming ability.

 C'mon 'Popcorn' !! We want you back, bro !!


/bringbackadler

I hope you are joking , adler was the worst GNR drummer , technically speaking hahahaa!

go listen to the beats on appetite..then on illusions..then come back and try to say the same thing    Adlers my favorite drummer too but..out with the old,in with the new

[Wooody]

 I hope Ferrar IS NOT the drummer.

 Although, I think I prefer him to Brain.

 I'm praying since Steven and Axl talked, we can plan to see them together in the future.

 Ferrar and Brain can't even remotely compare to Adler's drumming ability.

 C'mon 'Popcorn' !! We want you back, bro !!


/bringbackadler

I hope you are joking , adler was the worst GNR drummer , technically speaking hahahaa!

go listen to the beats on appetite..then on illusions..then come back and try to say the same thing ? ?Adlers my favorite drummer too but..out with the old,in with the new

1- You could be mine.

Thank you.

[CheapJon]

 I hope Ferrar IS NOT the drummer.

 Although, I think I prefer him to Brain.

 I'm praying since Steven and Axl talked, we can plan to see them together in the future.

 Ferrar and Brain can't even remotely compare to Adler's drumming ability.

 C'mon 'Popcorn' !! We want you back, bro !!


/bringbackadler

I hope you are joking , adler was the worst GNR drummer , technically speaking hahahaa!

go listen to the beats on appetite..then on illusions..then come back and try to say the same thing    Adlers my favorite drummer too but..out with the old,in with the new

1- You could be mine.

so woody you say matt is better 'cuz of one song compared to whole of AFD.. well ok (and u prolly know that duff came up with the YCBM intro) I respect your opionion but just like saying YCBM like that isn't much..

and BBA, are you really that naive or are you just seeking attention like the pitman guys, 'cuz that's what it look like when you talk about adler all the time

[Ganja4Life]

 I hope Ferrar IS NOT the drummer.

 Although, I think I prefer him to Brain.

 I'm praying since Steven and Axl talked, we can plan to see them together in the future.

 Ferrar and Brain can't even remotely compare to Adler's drumming ability.

 C'mon 'Popcorn' !! We want you back, bro !!


/bringbackadler

I hope you are joking , adler was the worst GNR drummer , technically speaking hahahaa!

go listen to the beats on appetite..then on illusions..then come back and try to say the same thing ? ?Adlers my favorite drummer too but..out with the old,in with the new

1- You could be mine.

so woody you say matt is better 'cuz of one song compared to whole of AFD.. well ok (and u prolly know that duff came up with the YCBM intro) I respect your opionion but just like saying YCBM like that isn't much..

and BBA, are you really that naive or are you just seeking attention like the pitman guys, 'cuz that's what it look like when you talk about adler all the time

I think he just knows he's an awesome drummer ..even my grandma said it when I lived with her..she didnt like Guns N' roses cause it was all I ever played ..but she said she loved the groove of the drums..I played illusions..she didnt like the drums..she loves Queen,the eagles..all the awesome old bands...Sorum is a robot..Adler had groove..I'd rather hear groove then some guy poundin the same beat over and over...Adler on Illusions would've been awesome..Civil War has the best drums on the entire album

[JohnMorrison73]

The drummer is the one who looks like Whoopi Goldberg

  LMFAO!

[Neemo]

i honestly dont know what the big secret is...lol

from the look of things its Frank, since Brain isn't really mentioned on GnR.com

[ibelieveinaxl]

this thread should be in the main section. this question is not known!

[Jim Bob]

this threat should be in the main section. this question is not known!

Frank said on the talking metal interview that he was going to be on the road with teh band for the African shows.    That coupled with the fact that he has recorded parts on the album tells me he is still going to be involved in the band, but we may not have seen the last of Brain.   

[tomass74]

Let me guess,  Frank is the best drummer Gn'R ever had right? Just liek Brain was before him and Freese before him...   

[ibelieveinaxl]

Let me guess,? Frank is the best drummer Gn'R ever had right? Just liek Brain was before him and Freese before him...? ?

brain is far superior to frank. the band should be truthful about the status of the drummer.