|
Title: AFD Re Made... Post by: gnr_12 on March 09, 2006, 02:11:52 AM If the new band was to re record, which i beleive axl has stated they have, do you think they would release it into stores? I mean... i know a lot of you are going to say thats crazy it could ruin the AFD original and make it less relevant and such.. but would it be a good idea to re make it and release it? i know i would buy it... just to see how they re did everything.. what changes they made... how axl changed his vocals on certain parts... it would be pretty cool.. what do you think?
Please dont just make posts bashing this idea... just thought id start a topic which didnt have to do with chinese democracy which would take people minds off of it for at least a bit... Title: Re: AFD Re Made... Post by: Axlative on March 09, 2006, 02:20:50 AM IMO it'd be cool if the re-recorded tracks were released in internet or as b-sides one or two at a time. That way there wouldn't be a "new AFD", but just new studio takes on the old songs and the comparison would be track vs. track instead of on album level where the bashing would never end...
Title: Re: AFD Re Made... Post by: jameslofton29 on March 09, 2006, 02:21:44 AM It'll take more than that to get my mind off of chinese democracy. :hihi: Seriously though, this is a dead horse, but you're a noob and might not have seen this discussed before. In my opinion, the reason AFD vol. 2 hasnt been released is because he would have to get the old band members permission to do so. Thats not happening anytime soon. I doubt if it ever gets released.
Now, back to Chinese Democracy...... Title: Re: AFD Re Made... Post by: gnr_12 on March 09, 2006, 02:22:15 AM IMO it'd be cool if the re-recorded tracks were released in internet or as b-sides one or two at a time. That way there wouldn't be a "new AFD", but just new studio takes on the old songs and the comparison would be track vs. track instead of on album level where the bashing would never end... Yeah that sounds pretty good... id love to hear a new take on SCOM or Rocket Queen... Title: Re: AFD Re Made... Post by: gnr_12 on March 09, 2006, 02:23:41 AM It'll take more than that to get my mind off of chinese democracy. :hihi: Seriously though, this is a dead horse, but you're a noob and might not have seen this discussed before. In my opinion, the reason AFD vol. 2 hasnt been released is because he would have to get the old band members permission to do so. Thats not happening anytime soon. I doubt if it ever gets released. Now, back to Chinese Democracy...... HAHAAH.. good point man.. sorry if uve been around this track a couple of times.. lol... i guess ill need something a little more intense than this.. Title: Re: AFD Re Made... Post by: GnR-NOW on March 09, 2006, 10:33:19 AM the original AFD is awesome, theres no question. But I always thought that Nightrain and Rocket Queen sounded way better live. I'd like to hear the new band's version of AFD. I doubt it would hurt the original AFD, I mean it only sold how many millions of cds.
Title: Re: AFD Re Made... Post by: PJ on March 10, 2006, 09:51:41 PM IMO it'd be cool if the re-recorded tracks were released in internet or as b-sides one or two at a time. That way there wouldn't be a "new AFD", but just new studio takes on the old songs and the comparison would be track vs. track instead of on album level where the bashing would never end... Yeah that sounds pretty good... id love to hear a new take on SCOM or Rocket Queen... Title: Re: AFD Re Made... Post by: CAFC Nick on March 11, 2006, 04:16:07 PM I wanted to hear a re-recorded version of Rocket Queen and WTTJ.
Title: Re: AFD Re Made... Post by: estrangedpaul on March 14, 2006, 06:11:34 AM I guess you could hear any major differences by downloading a soundboard recording from 2002. Any major differences, such as Buckhethead's ending to the Nightrain solo, or his shred version of the PC outro, should be noticeable on the live recordings from 2002.
|