If These Bands Would Reunite, Who would be most succesfull...

[Neemo]

Of Course Pink Floyd Would Be the biggest by far. I'm asking for more of an order 1-5 of the listed bands which would be biggest

I saw Roger Waters Last night at MSG (saw him twice there this past september) He could sell out as many shows as he can play and demand would still be huge.

I like GNR better than Pink Floyd (and i like the new GNR songs alot better than the Roger Waters Solo songs) But I was in the worst seat at MSG last night and I still thought it was 10X better than when I saw GNR there Front Row at MSG this past November

okay if we go by total tour revenue....i'd say

1 Floyd
2 Kiss
3 Zeppelin
4 VH
5 Guns

[GeraldFord]

Another KISS reunion doing better than a GN'R reunion?

Gimmie what your smokin'!

[freedom78]

Another KISS reunion doing better than a GN'R reunion?

Gimmie what your smokin'!

And that's the key to my ranking KISS 5th...ANOTHER reunion...not THE reunion...ANOTHER.  As in, another "Hey, didn't they do a few farewell tours?" reunion.

[Izzy]

Zeppelin and Floyd would break every record going if they hit the road again

They'd be quite capable of filling every stadium across the globe

[Neemo]

this kiss army is huge and extremely loyal

[mrlee]

this kiss army is huge and extremely loyal

*shudders* 

god damn gene simmons and his subliminal messaging.

[GeraldFord]

this kiss army is huge and extremely loyal

The KISS ARMY will go see them with or without Ace and Peter.

[Thorned Rose]

I would say Van Halen and Gn'R

Maybe Zepplin

[Verse Chorus Verse]

I agree with Floyd. And, I'd love to see it happen, too.

[Juanjay]

Zep+Floyd co headlining tour.....

Now THAT will shatter any tour records ever.

As for order I still have the

Zep
Floyd
Kiss
GNR
VH

I see kids all the time rocking Zep, they would pay to just say they saw them. I see kids rocking Floyd all the time and last proper album they did "The Division Bell" was number 1 for a while, the tour that followed was a huge success. So put Roger and Dave back together and thats a sure success.