Mr. Brownstone different studio version?

[Oh My Choking Soul]

nice

[Locomotive98]

Doesnt sound much different to me. Still its always great to hear this. its my fave GNR tune....

Nice to know though that good old Axl spent so much time re-recording an album that couldnt be bettered, whilst we wait here, years down the line, for a new one.....

Timewaster? Surely not....

Cheers

[Origen]

Doesnt sound much different to me. Still its always great to hear this. its my fave GNR tune....

Nice to know though that good old Axl spent so much time re-recording an album that couldnt be bettered, whilst we wait here, years down the line, for a new one.....

Timewaster? Surely not....

Cheers

Because he did different takes like all bands do while recording the song.

Timewaster ? Surely yes

[Locomotive98]

No I meant the re-recording of Appetite he did with the new 'GnR'....

Why bother?

[Origen]

No I meant the re-recording of Appetite he did with the new 'GnR'....

Why bother?

Why re-record Appetite ? I don't know I asked the same thing here the other day.

Someone said it would help them play the songs better live (which I don't understand how) that's what rehearsals are for, and what about the Illusion songs they played live, they didn't  re-record the Illusion albums but they were still able to play the songs live.

[Shaft]

Sweet Child O' Mine is re-registered too right?

[Locomotive98]

Read somewhere it was so he could release the AFD songs for soundtracks etc without having having to pay Slash etc royalties. Seems a bit wankerish to me.... But I really wouldnt be surprised.....

[anythinggoes]

could it be anything to do with this

GUNS N ROSES CD MISTA BROWNSTONE UNRELEASED ALAN NIVEN! LIVE STONES ALICE COOPER ORIGINAL MIX MISTA BROWNSTONE
DETAILS:
SALT OFF THE EARTH WITH THE ROLLING STONES (recorded at the Trump Plaza Atlantic City 1989)
UNDER MY WHEELS WITH ALICE COOPER (recorded at the Long Beach Arena in 1987)
MISTA BROWNSTONE---the original mix by Alan Niven and Michael Lardie (mixed at Total Access Redondo Beach in 1987. This was the first song from "The Appetite Sessions" to get an accepted mix!

http://cgi.ebay.com/GUNS-N-ROSES-GREAT-WHITE-ALAN-NIVEN-PKG-RIAA-CD-LP-ELVI_W0QQitemZ7583516282QQcategoryZ53261QQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

[WARose]

http://s17.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=0XWQPXN6GM4TL3K5XFBB3IN66T

[Neemo]

http://members.aol.com/gunsnflowers2/Disc_easy.htm

UK 7" vinyl Promo 1987

GEF 22 (DJ)
Gef? 22 A 928 313-7

1)It's so easy (censored version)
2)Mr. Brownstone (different guitar mix)

I'll bet it's this

which would make it an official track. so no links please

[WARose]

http://members.aol.com/gunsnflowers2/Disc_easy.htm

UK 7" vinyl Promo 1987

GEF 22 (DJ)
Gef  22 A 928 313-7

1)It's so easy (censored version)
2)Mr. Brownstone (different guitar mix)

I'll bet it's this

which would make it an official track. so no links please

fortunately i got it!

it`s superior to the appetite version imo...  sounds the way all old gnr songs ought to

[life_247]

Strange thing is it sounds very modern there are also no backing vocals (that you can properly hear).

This doesn't sound like it came from a tape recording set up - also there is no reverb on the drums like axl said in rs 99. Furthermore it doesn't sound like duff on bass.

[Neemo]

Strange thing is it sounds very modern there are also no backing vocals (that you can properly hear).

This doesn't sound like it came from a tape recording set up - also there is no reverb on the drums like axl said in rs 99. Furthermore it doesn't sound like duff on bass.

bound and determined huh?

if that's not izzy at 1:18-1:35 & 2:42-2:59, and if the music after the intro isn't identical to the version on AFD then i have never heard that album. I can hear the backing vocals out of crappy computer speakers with no headphones and the volume turned down low, how can you not hear it? And I highly doubt Axl could redo that low voice of his from 20 years ago. If he can, sweet, but i don't think so.

Face it, this is a remix of the orig tune, prolly most definately by that Alan Niven dude.

Story over. Sorry, no post-1995 GnR here

[Neemo]

another thing if it was Nu-GnR don't you think the solo would be a crazy buckethead one like on the 2002 tour and not a carbon copy of Slash's?

[Neemo]

Also Axl uses different vocal patterns on that tune than he did in the 80's

Biggest one "worryin's a waste of my "FUCKING" time"

and Robins voice is way more raspy than the backup vocals are on that track. I take back the buckethead solo thing, robin does that one and he pretty much plays Slash's note for note, i had Brownstone confused with Nightrain sorry.

Last point, they didn't use the cheesy guitar ending in 2002 either

Here's Mr. Brownstone from RioIII to compare
Mr Brownstone - RIR3

[Steel_Angel]

Yeah, it's clearly not New GNR's rerecording ... you people love to play your stupid fucking games, don't you?

Well I don't find you very amusing.? Fuck off.

it was obviously a mistake and atleast we shared. fuck off.

[Neemo]

it was obviously a mistake and atleast we shared. fuck off.

Hey I'm quite happy, and if i didn't say it before, then thankyou guys, you rock

[echrisl]

Yeah, it's clearly not New GNR's rerecording ... you people love to play your stupid fucking games, don't you?

Well I don't find you very amusing.  Fuck off.

it was obviously a mistake and atleast we shared. fuck off.

It was a mistake that you changed the name to include 1999 and then acted like you couldn't reveal the super-secret source you got it from?  Mmmhmm.  I'll bet.

Just for my personal edification, are you deaf as well?  Because it really shouldn't be all that hard to determine that this is not New GNR if you actually listened to the track ...

Just to follow what has become the traditional back-and forth message ending between the two of us in this thread ... fuck off.

[WAR41]

its legit 
i'll tell yall how i got it later. that is IF that person wants to be mentioned...

ummmmm..... so how did you get this oh so rare song?

[echrisl]

its legit 
i'll tell yall how i got it later. that is IF that person wants to be mentioned...

ummmmm..... so how did you get this oh so rare song?

Dammit!  He can't let the secret slip now!  Are you crazy man?