finck: not the studio guy?

[jimb0]

If I had to pick my favorite of the new lineup, I'd have to say Izzy !   

Hello? He's not in the band...

I guess you knew it and you're only testing to see how long before we kick your reunion ass out of here.




/jarmo

Izzy is very cool.

[AdZ]

Hooray!


Thanks for telling us.

[von]

That's a good point you make. People are so willing to accept the nonsensical idea of there being "two official drummers in GN'R because they said so" which is like telling a child Santa Claus is real, yet accepting that Izzy has played numerous shows with them and is strongly rumored to have contributed something to the new album is just...beyond impossible.

[AdZ]

It's not strongly rumoured, people just started speculating about it after he played a few songs at a bunch of shows.

[PhillyRiot]

Not to take this too much more off topic, but what constitutes a being a member of GNR nowadays?  Is Frank Ferrer is considered a member, I say Izzy may be too.  Do you have to have a recording on Chinese Democracy to be a member? 

[bringbackadler]

Something tells me Adz is digging the whole Izzy in the band theory.   

[bringbackadler]

Not to take this too much more off topic, but what constitutes a being a member of GNR nowadays?? Is Frank Ferrer is considered a member, I say Izzy may be too.? Do you have to have a recording on Chinese Democracy to be a member??

PhillyRiot,

I haven't seen you since Jarmo told you to get over the riot.? ?

That's my point, if you accept Ferrar as a member, Izzy shouldn't be much of a stretch.? ?

[WARose]

Not to take this too much more off topic, but what constitutes a being a member of GNR nowadays?  Is Frank Ferrer is considered a member, I say Izzy may be too.  Do you have to have a recording on Chinese Democracy to be a member? 

PhillyRiot,

I haven't seen you since Jarmo told you to get over the riot.   

That's my point, if you accept Ferrar as a member, Izzy shouldn't be much of a stretch.   

well.....  it`s quite obvious, that neither izzy, nor the current members of gnr (axl....) think izzy is a member of gnr.

frank played half of the european tour and the entire north american tour. izzy played some songs in like 20 shows...

[bringbackadler]

Not to take this too much more off topic, but what constitutes a being a member of GNR nowadays?? Is Frank Ferrer is considered a member, I say Izzy may be too.? Do you have to have a recording on Chinese Democracy to be a member??

PhillyRiot,

I haven't seen you since Jarmo told you to get over the riot.? ?

That's my point, if you accept Ferrar as a member, Izzy shouldn't be much of a stretch.? ?

well.....? it`s quite obvious, that neither izzy, nor the current members of gnr (axl....) think izzy is a member of gnr.

frank played half of the european tour and the entire north american tour. izzy played some songs in like 20 shows...

Really? Have you heard the band say that Izzy is not a member ?   

[Where is Hassan Nasrallah ?]

Not to take this too much more off topic, but what constitutes a being a member of GNR nowadays? ?Is Frank Ferrer is considered a member, I say Izzy may be too. ?Do you have to have a recording on Chinese Democracy to be a member? ?

PhillyRiot,

I haven't seen you since Jarmo told you to get over the riot. ? ?

That's my point, if you accept Ferrar as a member, Izzy shouldn't be much of a stretch. ?

well..... ?it`s quite obvious, that neither izzy, nor the current members of gnr (axl....) think izzy is a member of gnr.

frank played half of the european tour and the entire north american tour. izzy played some songs in like 20 shows...

Is the glass half empty or half full?

[bringbackadler]

Not to take this too much more off topic, but what constitutes a being a member of GNR nowadays? ?Is Frank Ferrer is considered a member, I say Izzy may be too. ?Do you have to have a recording on Chinese Democracy to be a member? ?

PhillyRiot,

I haven't seen you since Jarmo told you to get over the riot. ? ?

That's my point, if you accept Ferrar as a member, Izzy shouldn't be much of a stretch. ?

well..... ?it`s quite obvious, that neither izzy, nor the current members of gnr (axl....) think izzy is a member of gnr.

frank played half of the european tour and the entire north american tour. izzy played some songs in like 20 shows...

Is the glass half empty or half full?

Yes. Exactly.   

[1badapple]

It's not strongly rumoured, people just started speculating about it after he played a few songs at a bunch of shows.

IIRC, the rumors started after Izzy stated that he'd been doing some writing with Axl.

[whiny]

True, Finck has never recorded a full studio album. Its just never happened. He has done some work with NIN, and on some GNR tracks like SCOM and Oh My God (he denied being on oh my god, but axl says he's on the track). He also did work for the Ghosts of Mars soundtrack.

I don't think his lack of studio recorded and? released work? is a weakness, he's spent the better part of a decade working on CD.

i never wanted to say that it's a weakness.

[1badapple]

Didn't Finck contribute to the Impotent Sea Snakes debut cd? I thought i had heard that somewhere.

[Robman?]

True, Finck has never recorded a full studio album. Its just never happened. He has done some work with NIN, and on some GNR tracks like SCOM and Oh My God (he denied being on oh my god, but axl says he's on the track). He also did work for the Ghosts of Mars soundtrack.

I don't think his lack of studio recorded and  released work  is a weakness, he's spent the better part of a decade working on CD.

i never wanted to say that it's a weakness.

yeah, i realize that, i was just trying to say he does have experience in the studio 

Didn't Finck contribute to the Impotent Sea Snakes debut cd? I thought i had heard that somewhere.

thats an interesting point you bring up, I'll have to look into it

[jarmo]

Not to take this too much more off topic, but what constitutes a being a member of GNR nowadays?  Is Frank Ferrer is considered a member, I say Izzy may be too.  Do you have to have a recording on Chinese Democracy to be a member? 

Is Sebastian Bach part of GN'R too then?


Izzy is cool, it was nice seeing him join GN'R onstage for a few numbers across Europe last summer.

That doesn't make him a band member.

Izzy is very cool.

Now you're just being an ass.

Great job. 


/jarmo

[Bartlet]

Not to take this too much more off topic, but what constitutes a being a member of GNR nowadays?? Is Frank Ferrer is considered a member, I say Izzy may be too.? Do you have to have a recording on Chinese Democracy to be a member??

Is Sebastian Bach part of GN'R too then?


Izzy is cool, it was nice seeing him join GN'R onstage for a few numbers across Europe last summer.

That doesn't make him a band member.

Izzy is very cool.

Now you're just being an ass.

Great job.?


/jarmo

Jarmo, you know you're streatching the point there.

I have to agree with the point someonne made about two drummers in gnr and there being a santa clause too.

[bringbackadler]

Not to take this too much more off topic, but what constitutes a being a member of GNR nowadays?? Is Frank Ferrer is considered a member, I say Izzy may be too.? Do you have to have a recording on Chinese Democracy to be a member??

Is Sebastian Bach part of GN'R too then?

/jarmo

That is completely different. Sebastian Bach was not an original band member. Sebastian Bach did not write half the lyrics for Appetitte and the Illusions. Sebastian Bach had nothing to do with the way the band imploded back in the day. Izzy had ALOT to do with it.

I'm sure you saw the way that the crowd reacted when Izzy was announced at the shows last year.  If not, youtube shows it.

I think its fair to say that the majority of fans view Izzy as a band member in some way.  If youtube and the fans on this forum isn't proof then I don't know what is.

Before you even say it, this has absolutely nothing to do with a reunion. I can still see Izzy as much of a part of today's lineup than as the past.   

[jarmo]

My God. The crowd or fans don't decide who's in the band.


If you think Izzy is as big part of the band as he was up until 1991, then I think you're wrong.


I think the majority of fans view Izzy as a former band member who did some guest spots here and there because he likes to play with the band and he got in touch with Axl again after all these years.




/jarmo

[whiny]

Not to take this too much more off topic, but what constitutes a being a member of GNR nowadays?? Is Frank Ferrer is considered a member, I say Izzy may be too.? Do you have to have a recording on Chinese Democracy to be a member??

Is Sebastian Bach part of GN'R too then?

/jarmo

That is completely different. Sebastian Bach was not an original band member. Sebastian Bach did not write half the lyrics for Appetitte and the Illusions. Sebastian Bach had nothing to do with the way the band imploded back in the day. Izzy had ALOT to do with it.

I'm sure you saw the way that the crowd reacted when Izzy was announced at the shows last year.? If not, youtube shows it.

I think its fair to say that the majority of fans view Izzy as a band member in some way.? If youtube and the fans on this forum isn't proof then I don't know what is.

Before you even say it, this has absolutely nothing to do with a reunion. I can still see Izzy as much of a part of today's lineup than as the past.? ?

and i was so naive to think we could be talking about robin...