Here Today... Gone To Hell!

Guns N' Roses => Guns N' Roses => Topic started by: jarmo on April 12, 2005, 01:47:19 PM



Title: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: jarmo on April 12, 2005, 01:47:19 PM
Since we've been on a holiday, this GN'R track was leaked.

This is the thread for discussing the song, its lyrics etc.


Rules:
- Absolutely no links to places where youcan download the track. Posts with links will get deleted without any warning. Users posting links should know that they might get banned for doing so.

- No begging others to send you the file. This isn't a thread dedicated for filesharing.




/jarmo


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Nytunz on April 13, 2005, 02:03:16 PM
Hey Jarmo!
Nice to be back!! Missed the site alot!

IRS is awsome! The quality is bad, but you can really listen that this is a great song!!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dont Try Me on April 13, 2005, 02:08:34 PM
Glad forum is back up!

These are the lyrics we have so far. There is still much debate going on on the lyrics but we're in the good direction.

0:00
Gonna call the President
Gonna call the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

0:11
There's not anymore that I can do
All the ? they tell me, I follow you
So when you ?, that'll be the (energizers/advertisers) too? <------ must sound something like that, the same verbal tone. Anyone have suggestions?     

0:27
Wouldnt be the first time I've been gone(wrong)
Wouldnt be the last I sure have found
All the rumours I can tell, some things didn't work so well

0:37
When any way it's feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the luck gettin out of this wreck
A fact that you've got to hear the worst(word(s)) yet
When I need another favourite I take???
It means your life will be gone anyway???
I can't believe now and I lingered on
Couldn?t see it coming all along

1:05
well its true...ooh...I ask, my God it was you
Gonna call the President
Gonna call into my Private Eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

1:24
Gonna make this a federal case
(Blow the wind up), write that out in your face
Rearrange (re-debate???) (it when your morning is noon???) <----- this one is hard too, rearrange?? it's sound more like "debate" or something? suggestions anyone?
(With the police hang together???)
(And the headlines due now???)

{Finck Solo}Oh Oh..{Finck Solo}


1:55
I've been to sure to offer my help
I set it up again dressed as somebody else
feel like stumbling on the road
feel like I'll never get ya out of this song
Well I'm just too sad to kill
Maybe like I just walked in my shit
They'll be waiting on me I know
Like a broken record for so long

2:17
Can I do
Ooh, oh.
I'm gonna call the President
gonna call the Private Eye
I'm gonna get the IRS
Gonna need myself the FBI

2:33
Ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you, ooh ohh
It's such a crime you now it's true oooh

{Bucket solo}

3:10
I'm gonna call the President
Gonna need myself a Private Eye
Ooh, Gonna need the IRS
I'm gonna get the FBI

3:20
Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna wave it, write that out in your face
Rearrange it when your morning is noon??? re-debate???
And the police hang together???
and the headlines due???


3:32
There's not anymore that I can do


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: makemyday on April 13, 2005, 02:12:14 PM
Listened twice but I don't really like it. Although the solo is pretty nice at the end.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: killingvector on April 13, 2005, 02:14:12 PM
Whoohooo. Great to be back!

I really enjoy IRS very much. Very infectious. Bucket solo could be a bit more melodic and Finck's fattened up a bit, but overall a very good track. 7/10.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: AxlGunner on April 13, 2005, 02:18:29 PM
Axl is the best part of the song. Great voice/melody/etc. Makes me look forward to what else he can put out.

I'm a little surprised, but not much.

oh, but is it me or does he do some variation of "oooooh" or "aaah" in almost all the new songs.  ???


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: pilferk on April 13, 2005, 02:21:20 PM
So, jarmo....disregarding the quality of the recording..what do YOU think of it?

I like it. A lot. 

The scream before the bucket solo...fucking wicked.



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Rhythm-n-Booze on April 13, 2005, 02:22:41 PM
I think it's a good sounding riff and Bucket's solo is pretty cool. I also like how long Axl holds the scream when going into Bucket's solo.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Izzy on April 13, 2005, 02:24:25 PM
The quality is really too bad for any kind of judgement - and this song could be up to 10 years old, god only knows what version of the song was leaked - the band said many songs have three versions


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: GNROSAS on April 13, 2005, 02:25:07 PM
I.R.S Sounds cool and promising...

Let's see how it will turn up on CD..


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 13, 2005, 02:27:22 PM
First and foremost

Welcome back Jarmo

Im very dissapointed the whole HTGTH and GNR have teamed up conspiracy has amounted to nothing....but I knew it wouldnt and tried to warn people...hope is a bitch in the GNR world.

As far as the song...as a demo 8/10. Axla vocals...brilliant...lyrics...average...musicianship....derivative of zeppelin, and neither loud and raw or otherwise, a lil bland.

Overall as a demo cool.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: usurper on April 13, 2005, 02:27:53 PM
I am the only fucking one that has not bloody heard it!!!!!! FUCK!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Falcon on April 13, 2005, 02:28:33 PM
I find the song interesting, makes me want to hear the finished product. ?

Axl sounds good, great scream going into a solo.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: horsey on April 13, 2005, 02:29:27 PM
 :hihi:
yes axl still kicks ass !
ive herd it and don't believe it is fake either.everyone said it was fake right away NOT ME
i knew it was real from the gate.
glad to be back,keep the site alive !
rock - on peoples'


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: usurper on April 13, 2005, 02:34:59 PM
:'( Have some mercy Jarmo!!!! I just want to listen to it once!! Come on!!!!  :'(


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: sandman on April 13, 2005, 02:35:25 PM
it seems like alot of new songs have axl singing non-stop in a VERY high pitch, intense manner.

the solo is awesome. kinda reminds me of a slash solo.

i can't give a fair opinion of it though. the version i heard is awful. very "busy" sounding though.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Smoking Guns on April 13, 2005, 02:36:16 PM
Glad the site is back. ?I felt weird on the other board! ?I don't like what i have heard ?(IRS) because i can't hear the whole thing. ?Jarmo, are you sure this server is faster? ?just kidding. ?Glad HTGTH is back though and I am one of the first 50 or so posts on the new server! ?Whew Who!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Axl4Prez2004 on April 13, 2005, 02:37:22 PM
Horsey, I was right there with ya. ?It was obviously real. ?It's a kick-ass song. ?It's also a huge relief to hear Axl's vocals. ?He sounds awesome. ?Obviously, just a demo., but what fantastic potential!!!

-Axl4Prez ?8)

PS ?Damn I missed this message board! ?This is BY FAR, the best GNR site on the 'net. ? :peace:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: R4tfink on April 13, 2005, 02:41:45 PM
From what i can "hear" its promising.
However...its a Demo..so the song could change considerably before we actually here the "Real" Recording.
I wont pass actual judgement until that point in time.

At least its something...


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: sandman on April 13, 2005, 02:45:25 PM
one i thing i really love about the song is the rhythm guitar. heavy and grooving, like an old classic metal riff. (it actually reminds me a little of the guitar in "sweetleaf")


(PS - awesome site....glad it's back....my days at work were DRAGGING!)


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 13, 2005, 02:45:56 PM
If anyone wants to 'chat' about the demo, feel free to PM me. Especially if u havent heard it id like to give you my opinions of it.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: usurper on April 13, 2005, 02:49:44 PM
Just heard it! It fucking rules!!!!!!!!!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 13, 2005, 02:50:20 PM
Whilst the vocal melody and singing is very cool...I have to say that the basic music is very boring. I am hoping for more music along the lines of live n let die or jungle, and hoping that november rain like songs are left alone.....dont need any blurring the lines between the best rock band of all times and 70's schmaltz rock balladeering.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on April 13, 2005, 02:50:59 PM
first of all I don't know how people got most of these lyrics cause its hard as hell to hear most of it cause it's such brutal quality, but it seem like a decent song, it would be nice to hear a real version.

Anyway here are my thoughts on the first bit of the song lyrics from Don't Try Me

Quote

0:11
There's not anymore that I can do
All the legions they tell me, I follow you
So when you plead the fifth, that'll be the end of time it's true


I don't like this line it doesn't sound right

Quote

0:27
Wouldnt be the first time I've been gone
Wouldnt be the last I sure have found
All the rumours I can tell, some things didn't work so well


I think it's

"Wouldn't be the first time I'd been wrong"
"Wouldn't be the last, I'm sure, I've found"
"With all the rumors I can tell, Some things didn't work so well"

Quote

0:37
When any way it's feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the luck gettin out of this wreck
A fact that you've got to hear the worst yet
When I need another favourite I take
It means your life will be gone anyway
I can't believe now and I lingered on
Couldn?t see it coming all along


I think this says

When you first told me you were gone
Somehow I'd known that I'd been here alone
? To all the luck gettin out of this wreck ?
? A fact that you've got to hear the worst yet ?
? When I need another favourite I take ?
You made up your mind, and off you went
I can't believe now how that lingered on
Couldn?t see it coming all along

I don't know. Its really bad quality, but I think it's about the GnR Breakup and the lawsuits and shit. I know it sounds like old news but Axl hasn't really said too much about it yet so, whatever

The president is David Geffen
The private Eye is to look to see what they have on him
The IRS part is to track his income on the old material
The FBI is to see if he has a case I don't know I'm just pulling this out of my ass really

What does everyone think, Am I totally wrong?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: horsey on April 13, 2005, 02:52:21 PM
Horsey, I was right there with ya. ?It was obviously real. ?It's a kick-ass song. ?It's also a huge relief to hear Axl's vocals. ?He sounds awesome. ?Obviously, just a demo., but what fantastic potential!!!

-Axl4Prez ?8)

PS ?Damn I missed this message board! ?This is BY FAR, the best GNR site on the 'net. ? :peace:




yes i knew it right away.no other voice like it.a bit higher but indeed axl's.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: EET_FUK on April 13, 2005, 02:58:22 PM
I thought it was okay. ?Maybe I was expecting a little more after a decade plus of writting. ?Plus, the lyrics are a little hokie.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Luigi on April 13, 2005, 03:00:28 PM
 I love it, don't need to explaine it, I understand it, Axl's got a hot one on his hands, I can't wait ta hear the studio version and the rest. : ok:     


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 13, 2005, 03:03:13 PM
As a demo its cool...but the musicianship is somewhat bland....and if the lyrics were better (say as good as locomotive/sympathy for the devil)...then the song would be an all time classic......as is its just a good rock song that would have been just below civil war status on the Illusions

vocals sound fantastic though i must say


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Ignatius on April 13, 2005, 03:06:47 PM

Didn't any of you guys were nervious before listening to the track? I first downloaded the 32 sec file, then the 44sec and then the complete song. I felt like I did back 6 years ago when I first heard "Oh my God". Man, I had to listen to the track at least 3 times cause the first two I didn't know what the hell whas going on..between the excitement, the adrenaline...

Anyway, despite the quality, it's a good, solid song. I can't wait to hear the finishing product. Axl sounds great.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: killingvector on April 13, 2005, 03:08:00 PM
Quote
Gonna make this a natural case
Blow the wind up, write that out in your face
Rearrange it when your morning is noon?
With the police hang together?
And the headlines due now

I don't think that is right.

Dave posted these lyrics which still aren't right, but I think are alot closer:

Gonna call the president
Gonna make myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

3:20
Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna win and knock it outta your face
Rearrange it when your morning is noon?
And the police hang together, and their headlines true


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: pilferk on April 13, 2005, 03:11:23 PM
0:27
Wouldnt be the first time I've been gone
Wouldnt be the last I sure have found
All the rumours I can tell, some things didn't work so well


I think it's

"Wouldn't be the first time I'd been wrong"
"Wouldn't be the last, I'm sure, I've found"
"With all the rumors I can tell, Some things didn't work so well"


I actually think I finally got this part when I isolated the voice track a little more.? I think it's:

"Wouldn't be the first time I went wrong
Wouldn't be the last time I should've known
With all the rumors I can tell Some things didn't work well"
Quote


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: usurper on April 13, 2005, 03:12:02 PM
I don't give a hell about the lyrics!!!! I just heard the song!!!!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dont Try Me on April 13, 2005, 03:14:53 PM
Quote
Gonna make this a natural case
Blow the wind up, write that out in your face
Rearrange it when your morning is noon?
With the police hang together?
And the headlines due now

I don't think that is right.

Dave posted these lyrics which still aren't right, but I think are alot closer:

Gonna call the president
Gonna make myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

3:20
Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna win and knock it outta your face
Rearrange it when your morning is noon?
And the police hang together, and their headlines true


I've seen his set of lyrics but the first one you qouted me on was the 1:24. There axls says " natural case"
on 3:20 there axl says "federal case" like you said :)

However "Gonna win and knock it outta your face" I'm 99% positive axl says "gonna wave it, write that out in your face" Altho dave's line lays better in the story, it's in fact not closer then to what Axl sings.


but much remains open to discussion since this is a bad quality demo.  :'(




Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: jarmo on April 13, 2005, 03:16:41 PM
Im very dissapointed the whole HTGTH and GNR have teamed up conspiracy has amounted to nothing....but I knew it wouldnt and tried to warn people...hope is a bitch in the GNR world.

There's nothing I can do about that. I never "hyped" it. We moved the site to a new server, that's it.




/jarmo



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: killingvector on April 13, 2005, 03:17:50 PM
Quote
Gonna make this a natural case
Blow the wind up, write that out in your face
Rearrange it when your morning is noon?
With the police hang together?
And the headlines due now

I don't think that is right.

Dave posted these lyrics which still aren't right, but I think are alot closer:

Gonna call the president
Gonna make myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

3:20
Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna win and knock it outta your face
Rearrange it when your morning is noon?
And the police hang together, and their headlines true


I've seen his set of lyrics but the first one you qouted me on was the 1:24. There axls says " natural case"
on 3:20 there axl says "federal case" like you said :)

However "Gonna win and knock it outta your face" I'm 99% positive axl says "gonna wave it, write that out in your face" Altho dave's line lays better in the story, it's in fact not closer then to what Axl sings.



Ahh ok, gotcha. I stand corrected. i think the second line after federal case needs some work in both cases.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dont Try Me on April 13, 2005, 03:19:13 PM
Quote
Gonna make this a natural case
Blow the wind up, write that out in your face
Rearrange it when your morning is noon?
With the police hang together?
And the headlines due now

I don't think that is right.

Dave posted these lyrics which still aren't right, but I think are alot closer:

Gonna call the president
Gonna make myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

3:20
Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna win and knock it outta your face
Rearrange it when your morning is noon?
And the police hang together, and their headlines true


I've seen his set of lyrics but the first one you qouted me on was the 1:24. There axls says " natural case"
on 3:20 there axl says "federal case" like you said :)

However "Gonna win and knock it outta your face" I'm 99% positive axl says "gonna wave it, write that out in your face" Altho dave's line lays better in the story, it's in fact not closer then to what Axl sings.



Ahh ok, gotcha. I stand corrected. i think the second line after federal case needs some work in both cases.

true that, it's hard to tell, since his voice is high pitched too.



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: badintentions on April 13, 2005, 03:23:25 PM
As a demo its cool...but the musicianship is somewhat bland....and if the lyrics were better (say as good as locomotive/sympathy for the devil)...then the song would be an all time classic......as is its just a good rock song that would have been just below civil war status on the Illusions

vocals sound fantastic though i must say

hmmm....you do realize that sympathy for the devil was a cover right? and you said something about wishing the music was more like live and let die, you know that is a cover as well right? by "cover" i mean a song someone else wrote and performed and made famous.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dont Try Me on April 13, 2005, 03:27:26 PM
0:00
Gonna call the President
Gonna call the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

0:11
There's not anymore that (then) I can do
All the legions they tell me, I follow you
So when you plead the fifth, that'll be the end of time plus two //// So when you plead the fifth, that'll be the end of time it's true???? //// energizers too?

0:27
Wouldnt be the first time I've been gone (wrong) //// Wouldn't be the first time I'd been wrong
Wouldnt be the last I sure have found //// Wouldn't be the last, I'm sure, I've found

All the rumours I can tell, some things didn't work so well

0:37
When (well) any way it's feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the luck gettin out of this wreck
A fact that you've got to hear the worst (word(s)) yet
When I need another favourite I take???
It means your life will be gone anyway???
I can't believe now and I lingered on
Couldn?t see it coming all along

1:05
well its true...ooh...I am, My God it was you
Gonna call the President
Gonna call into my Private Eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

1:24
Gonna make this a natural case
Blow the wind up, write that out in your face
Rearrange it when your morning is noon??? re-debate???
With the police hang together???
And the headlines due now???


{Finck Solo}Oh Oh..{Finck Solo}


1:55
I've been to sure to offer my help
I set it up again dressed as somebody else
feel like stumbling on the road
feel like I'll never get ya out of this song
Well I'm just too sad to kill
Maybe like I just walked in my shit
They'll be waiting on me I know
Like a broken record for so long

2:17
Can I do
Ooh, oh.
I'm gonna call the President
gonna call the Private Eye
I'm gonna get the IRS
Gonna need myself the FBI

2:33
Ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you, ooh ohh
It's such a crime you now it's true oooh

{Bucket solo}

3:10
I'm gonna call the President
Gonna need myself a Private Eye
Ooh, Gonna need the IRS
I'm gonna get the FBI

3:20
Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna wave it, write that out in your face
Rearrange it when your morning is noon??? re-debate???
And the police hang together???
and the headlines due???


3:32
There's not anymore that I can do

---------

These are I think the most important working points for us to find out?



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 13, 2005, 03:33:08 PM
As a demo its cool...but the musicianship is somewhat bland....and if the lyrics were better (say as good as locomotive/sympathy for the devil)...then the song would be an all time classic......as is its just a good rock song that would have been just below civil war status on the Illusions

vocals sound fantastic though i must say

hmmm....you do realize that sympathy for the devil was a cover right? and you said something about wishing the music was more like live and let die, you know that is a cover as well right? by "cover" i mean a song someone else wrote and performed and made famous.


Yes obviously I am aware of both.

simply meant that without the outstanding lyrics of a song such as locomotive or SFTD...or outstanding music like Jungle or LALD....this song is dissapointing as a whole if the standard is to be held to a 10 YR wait. Great vocals...very good vocal melody.....average lyrics and music..IMHO

Good to great song overall,  i expect better lyrics and music if Axl is to explain the demise of GNR...



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: shaun on April 13, 2005, 03:34:59 PM
IRS sounded average on the first few hearings... then, then it got better  : ok:
Poor quality sound recording to one side, i really quite like the track  :beer:
IRS is on my site, and no i cannot tell you the location as that would be wrong  ;)
Roll on the finished album  :peace:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dont Try Me on April 13, 2005, 03:39:48 PM
first of all I don't know how people got most of these lyrics cause its hard as hell to hear most of it cause it's such brutal quality, but it seem like a decent song, it would be nice to hear a real version.

Anyway here are my thoughts on the first bit of the song lyrics from Don't Try Me

Quote

0:11
There's not anymore that I can do
All the legions they tell me, I follow you
So when you plead the fifth, that'll be the end of time it's true


I don't like this line it doesn't sound right

Quote

0:27
Wouldnt be the first time I've been gone
Wouldnt be the last I sure have found
All the rumours I can tell, some things didn't work so well


I think it's

"Wouldn't be the first time I'd been wrong"
"Wouldn't be the last, I'm sure, I've found"
"With all the rumors I can tell, Some things didn't work so well"

Quote

0:37
When any way it's feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the luck gettin out of this wreck
A fact that you've got to hear the worst yet
When I need another favourite I take
It means your life will be gone anyway
I can't believe now and I lingered on
Couldn?t see it coming all along


I think this says

When you first told me you were gone
Somehow I'd known that I'd been here alone
? To all the luck gettin out of this wreck ?
? A fact that you've got to hear the worst yet ?
? When I need another favourite I take ?
You made up your mind, and off you went
I can't believe now how that lingered on
Couldn?t see it coming all along

I don't know. Its really bad quality, but I think it's about the GnR Breakup and the lawsuits and shit. I know it sounds like old news but Axl hasn't really said too much about it yet so, whatever

The president is David Geffen
The private Eye is to look to see what they have on him
The IRS part is to track his income on the old material
The FBI is to see if he has a case I don't know I'm just pulling this out of my ass really

What does everyone think, Am I totally wrong?


could be right on quite a few points. Check my latest post with the bold text. That shows the working points, the same you just pointed out. :)



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on April 13, 2005, 03:53:32 PM

could be right on quite a few points. Check my latest post with the bold text. That shows the working points, the same you just pointed out. :)


Yeah I've been monitoring' this topic.  :)

I get frustrated in the 0:37 verse it's to distorted and I can't make anything out really then I don't want to go farther. I've been trying though. What do you think the song is about?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: D on April 13, 2005, 03:57:47 PM
As a demo its cool...but the musicianship is somewhat bland....and if the lyrics were better (say as good as locomotive/sympathy for the devil)...then the song would be an all time classic......as is its just a good rock song that would have been just below civil war status on the Illusions

vocals sound fantastic though i must say

hmmm....you do realize that sympathy for the devil was a cover right? and you said something about wishing the music was more like live and let die, you know that is a cover as well right? by "cover" i mean a song someone else wrote and performed and made famous.



U need to enter that avatar into my contest! :hihi: :hihi: :hihi: the bald axl, that look is hilarious!

anyhow, the demo is not good enough quality to truly judge

im sure the music is great * u really cant make much of it out*

I'm sure IRS has some deep metaphorical meaning, im pretty sure it isnt about the Internal Revenue Service.

gotta hear the finished product to judge.

from what ive heard though it is very rockin and very catchy

plus most importantly

Axl sounds like Axl of old

that was one of our biggest debates and he proved that in the studio he still has it and the touring voice was to save his throat.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: WanaBGunner on April 13, 2005, 04:01:32 PM
I just got done listening to the real song that will probebly be on the CD. Theres lots of lil shit u CANT hear in the sound clip thats going around right now. Very bad ass song. Here are the lyrics...

Gonna call the President
Gonna call the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI
Theres not anymore that I can do
All religion is that to me I follow you
When you plead the fifth that'll be the end of time plus two
Wouldnt be the first time Ive been gone
Wouldnt be the last I'm sure I'm on
All the rumours I can tell
Somethings didnt work so well
With any way it feels the same
When you first told me you were gone
So long ago but I've been here long
to all the luck gettin out of this wreck
A fact that you've got to hear worst yet
when I need another favourite I take
It means your life will be gone anyway
cant believe that I was out there at all
couldn't see it coming all along
well its true ooh I am but dont forget ooh ooh
Gonna call the President
Gonna call into my Private EYe
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI
Gonna make this a federal case
Theres no way that I'll get out of your face
repeat it with you're mortgage gone
with the police hangever
and a head like you no
Oh Oh
I've been to sure to offer my help
I set it up again dressed as somebody else
feel like stumbling on the the road
feel like I'll never get ya out of this song
Well I'm just too sad to kill
maybe like I just walked in my shit
They'll be waiting on me I know
like a broken record for so long
What can I do
Ooh oh
I'M Gonna call the President,
I'm gonna call the private eye
gonna get the IRS
gonna get myself the FBI
ooh what shall I do
if I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime you now it's true oooooooohhh
Gonna call the president
Gonna make myself a private eye
ooh, Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI
Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna wave it right there out in your face
rearrange it when your morning is noon
and the police hang together,and their headlines true
Theres not anymore that I can do

 :beer:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 13, 2005, 04:04:34 PM
[
that was one of our biggest debates and he proved that in the studio he still has it and the touring voice was to save his throat.
[/quote

As cool as he sounds on IRS I simply do not buy that saving his voice stuff....he was trying his best, and he surely was not 'saving his voice' during the VMA's....he simply couldnt sing well live....pretty simple.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: kaasupoltin on April 13, 2005, 04:06:42 PM
It doesnt sound like GNR... GNR sounds like Appetite For Destruction.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on April 13, 2005, 04:10:13 PM
It doesnt sound like GNR... GNR sounds like Appetite For Destruction.

Well guess what? we're in 2005 not 1987 and the most current thing we've heard from the gnr camp is IRS. Soooooooooooo, I guess it sounds like GnR, cause the most current incarnation GnR (that we've seen) wrote and performed it.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Eppe on April 13, 2005, 04:11:46 PM
I think the song is amazing! The quality is bad, but you can still hear the potential of the song. If the rest of the record is as good then Chinese Democracy will be one of the greatest albums of all time.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dont Try Me on April 13, 2005, 04:12:53 PM

could be right on quite a few points. Check my latest post with the bold text. That shows the working points, the same you just pointed out. :)


Yeah I've been monitoring' this topic.? :)

I get frustrated in the 0:37 verse it's to distorted and I can't make anything out really then I don't want to go farther. I've been trying though. What do you think the song is about?

I have no clue. But I specially like these few bits:


I've been to sure to offer my help
I set it up again dressed as somebody else ? ?<----- cool line, referring too new guns?
feel like stumbling on the the road
feel like I'll never get ya out of this song
Well I'm just too sad to kill
maybe like I just walked in my shit
They'll be waiting on me I know
like a broken record for so long
<---- very very interesting.


ooh what shall I do
if I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime you now it's true oooooooohhh


--------
very cool lyrics. The safest bet is it's about the whole proces of beginning something new. Getting away from the old. Not specificly the old band, could be about everything.




Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Jonx on April 13, 2005, 04:16:01 PM
I just got done listening to the real song that will probebly be on the CD. Theres lots of lil shit u CANT hear in the sound clip thats going around right now. Very bad ass song. Here are the lyrics...


How exactly did you hear the "real song that will probably be on the CD". Are you saying you have the proper version?

Jonx


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: D on April 13, 2005, 04:23:08 PM
whenu guys are tryin to figure out lyrics, it has to make sense

some of the stuff u guys have listed makes no sense whatsoever like that line

"All religion is that to me I follow you"      what the hell is that? that makes no sense whatsoever.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Nytunz on April 13, 2005, 04:23:40 PM
I just got done listening to the real song that will probebly be on the CD. Theres lots of lil shit u CANT hear in the sound clip thats going around right now. Very bad ass song. Here are the lyrics...


How exactly did you hear the "real song that will probably be on the CD". Are you saying you have the proper version?

Jonx

Dont belive him..  :rant:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: badintentions on April 13, 2005, 04:24:17 PM
I just got done listening to the real song that will probebly be on the CD. Theres lots of lil shit u CANT hear in the sound clip thats going around right now. Very bad ass song. Here are the lyrics...


How exactly did you hear the "real song that will probably be on the CD". Are you saying you have the proper version?

Jonx

yeah! explain please.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on April 13, 2005, 04:29:28 PM
whenu guys are tryin to figure out lyrics, it has to make sense

some of the stuff u guys have listed makes no sense whatsoever like that line

"All religion is that to me I follow you"? ? ? what the hell is that? that makes no sense whatsoever.

I agree 100% D! That's why I ask what everyone thinks the song is about, then with that in mind we can sorta, maybe, kinda have an easier time figuring out what he says, "WHen you plead the 5th it be The end of time + 2 or its true" doesn't make sense either

I think it sounds more like "when you see my pictures and the advertisements too" or "will you be the victims and the agonizers too" or something. Like I said its hard to make out anything.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Doc Emmett Brown on April 13, 2005, 04:32:15 PM
I AM REALLY PISSED OFF

I have tried to download this song 3 times now and each time I get a wrong song that is mislabeled as 'Guns N' Roses - IRS leak'

GOD DAMN IT!!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Pandora on April 13, 2005, 04:38:26 PM
I think the vocal melody is a major grower. Once it's stuck in your head, there's no way you can get rid of it. Unfortunately, the quality is shit and the instrumentation sounds like complete sludge, so I prefer not to pass judgment on that.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Malcolm on April 13, 2005, 04:49:13 PM
From what i can hear in this song i thaught it kicks major ass...The chorus part is sooo sweet..Sounds like a classic Appetite song to me...Good to hear


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: horsey on April 13, 2005, 04:53:34 PM
i say it has to do with lots of things in the past with axl.not the future of g n' r.it was something related to his love lost with stephannie and maybe the band.a bit of ranting and rambling so.about the system in general,such as f.b.i and i.r.s.maybe you all are reading way to much into this song as if it has answers or something,cause it doesn't.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dr. Blutarsky on April 13, 2005, 04:55:31 PM
IRS will be awesome! ?The version that was leaked is just a poor quality demo, and I can`t stop listening to it. To me it sounds like GNR brought up to date. ?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: The Estranged MrFlashbax on April 13, 2005, 04:58:40 PM
wow.. if it was only a  bit cleaner and louder, it would never leave my car steroe.. the rythm guitars sound so heavy and dark.. its awsome!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: damnthehaters on April 13, 2005, 05:12:29 PM
I can't believe I'm on a GNR site and I can't get the direct link to download the song.? Do some of you guys actually think that your in the band or close to them, and your afraid of hurting there feelings??

The song is already leeked, there is nothing now that the managment nor Axl can do.? Do I like GNR?? Do I respect GNR?? Yes, Yes, but the fact of the matter, is that the song has already been leeked.? I already listened to the 30 second clip but can't get ahold of the longer version.? I thought I could come on here and get a direct link, but I guess not.?

Some of you guys take this stuff way too seriously.? ?

Were FANS!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Scabbie on April 13, 2005, 05:24:48 PM
Quality aside, there's things I like and don't like about IRS. Axl's voice and the rythm guitars are the highlight (especially that scream), and I think the chorus is catchy. The song needs rearranging in parts, and Axl needs to let it breathe a little. Buckethead's solo is fast, but I'm not sure its very original, I've heard him do better.

Overall 7/10 but with a little work I think it could be an 8 or 9. I'd like to hear a little more about it as opposed to 'not even in the top 10 though'.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Jizzo on April 13, 2005, 05:25:23 PM
I can't believe I'm on a GNR site and I can't get the direct link to download the song. ?Do some of you guys actually think that your in the band or close to them, and your afraid of hurting there feelings? ?

The song is already leeked, there is nothing now that the managment nor Axl can do. ?Do I like GNR? ?Do I respect GNR? ?Yes, Yes, but the fact of the matter, is that the song has already been leeked. ?I already listened to the 30 second clip but can't get ahold of the longer version. ?I thought I could come on here and get a direct link, but I guess not. ?

Some of you guys take this stuff way too seriously. ?

Were FANS!

one word: Lawsuit

No one wants to get sued. By sharing the song on asite the owner is potentially liable to get sued by the bands management


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: WanaBGunner on April 13, 2005, 05:25:36 PM
I DL it from this place... daaa

I've said this B4 on this board and I will say it again, back in like 99 - 00, dont rele remember when. But it was about 6 months B4 the first tour, I DL 4 or 5 tracks off Ch Dem using limewire. I deleted them because I didnt know how important they were, I just figured everyone had em. I then found out that no one else had em and tryed to recover them but no luck. Me and a friend listened to em. So they have been around for a very long time...

And I dont care wut anyone else thinks.

And what did they sound like?... Well just like all the shit we've heard so far...


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dr. Blutarsky on April 13, 2005, 05:30:57 PM
I can't believe I'm on a GNR site and I can't get the direct link to download the song.? Do some of you guys actually think that your in the band or close to them, and your afraid of hurting there feelings??

The song is already leeked, there is nothing now that the managment nor Axl can do.? Do I like GNR?? Do I respect GNR?? Yes, Yes, but the fact of the matter, is that the song has already been leeked.? I already listened to the 30 second clip but can't get ahold of the longer version.? I thought I could come on here and get a direct link, but I guess not.?

Some of you guys take this stuff way too seriously.? ?

Were FANS!


I am not one of those who says you shouldn`t hear IRS because...........(insert reason here)

I think the more who hear it the better.

But... I understand why you can`t find it here. I speculate that Jarmo doesn`t want to piss off GNR`s management, their wishes are not to distribute unsolicited material. You piss off GNR~s management, you can have doors shut in your face like exclusive interviews, etc. And there`s the whole legal side to it. You can have a lawsuit on your hands if you post IRS.

If you really want the full version of IRS it is out there, you just have to look hard enough.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Malcolm on April 13, 2005, 05:31:04 PM
Anyone think the band put the song out on purpose? to stir a little news or somehting? it could be a version they worked on years ago and the finished version sounds alot different?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Jizzo on April 13, 2005, 05:31:51 PM
My take on the song is it is a very good song. 9 out of 10. Great lyrics with a chorus you cant get out of your head


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: *Izzy* on April 13, 2005, 05:36:36 PM
I haven't heard it yet? :crying: it seems to be takin' down from all the original places that it could be found.
So is it mostly guitar based or what? ???

 :smoking: Izzy? :smoking:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Allman on April 13, 2005, 05:41:05 PM
Izzy, i've listened to it twice and that's it. the quality is that bad.
It might be guitar driven but it's hard to hear anything, it's 2005 and the sound quality is more like the eighties  :P


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: billsguy on April 13, 2005, 05:42:37 PM
well i for one do not like bh's solo.  it does not fit the song at all.  you have a bluesy, heavy guitar riff throughout, and then this speed attack tapping machine going crazy at the end.  and to whoever said bh's solo doesn't sound that original, i swear most of his solos that aren't plain bizzare sound similar to me. 

also, it seems as though the transitions are really bad.  it goes from heavy to light and back without anything to make the move.  granted, this stuff may be added as the demo was worked on. 

i can only hope that not every song on cd has a roaring bh solo on it.  blues doesn't, maddy doesn't, even chinese democracy really doesn't.  that makes me think that those are really old songs that were finished before bh came to the project.  i would guess that means irs is newer, but thats speculation.  anyways, i hope finck and fortus put forth more bluesy solos like we all know they can that slow the tempo but keep those great bends in there.  just my 2 cents...



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: nesquick on April 13, 2005, 05:47:21 PM
My review?8)

Good points (x6):
- Axl's voice, this is the highligh of the song. His voice is Fantastic (have you heard that scream? :o)
- Good rythm, not too fast, not too slow, I like it.
- Good chorus
- good first little bluesy guitar solo (richard? robin?)
- Most of people don't speak enough about it: Tommy does a GREAT job on bass.
- It's just a demo, it means the final version will be better. Great potencial

Bad points (x2):
- Buckethead shred guitar solo, no feeling, heartless, useless. Bad, very bad. Must be erased or replaced.
- Rythm box there and then (real drums sound always better)

Note: 7/10 (could evolve to 8/10 with a good studio version)


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: *Izzy* on April 13, 2005, 05:52:03 PM
(have you heard that scream? :o)
No. Somebody give me the goddamn track? :crying:

Izzy, i've listened to it twice and that's it. the quality is that bad.
It might be guitar driven but it's hard to hear anything, it's 2005 and the sound quality is more like the eighties :P
Better quality than the Hollywood Rose recordings? ???

 :smoking: Izzy? :smoking:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dont Try Me on April 13, 2005, 05:52:14 PM
I DL it from this place... daaa

I've said this B4 on this board and I will say it again, back in like 99 - 00, dont rele remember when. But it was about 6 months B4 the first tour, I DL 4 or 5 tracks off Ch Dem using limewire. I deleted them because I didnt know how important they were, I just figured everyone had em. I then found out that no one else had em and tryed to recover them but no luck. Me and a friend listened to em. So they have been around for a very long time...

And I dont care wut anyone else thinks.

And what did they sound like?... Well just like all the shit we've heard so far...

Quote
I just got done listening to the real song that will probebly be on the CD. Theres lots of lil shit u CANT hear in the sound clip thats going around right now. Very bad ass song. Here are the lyrics...

I think your full of shit. You just finished listening to a version of IRS that is much clearer and that will most probably be on cd? And before that you deleted them and couldn't recover it..........then how did you finish listening to a good quality version of IRS? bullshit.



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: billsguy on April 13, 2005, 05:54:28 PM
^^^^^^^ yeah i agree, bs definitely. 


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: jgfnsr on April 13, 2005, 05:56:28 PM
Whatever your opinion on the 7 songs we've heard so from the new band, anyone else think none of them (except perhaps the title track) are among those that will be on the new album?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dave_Rose on April 13, 2005, 05:57:36 PM
I really like IRS, Axl's scream with Buckets solo its just awesome Axl still has it!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: just_one on April 13, 2005, 06:01:43 PM
am i the only one that loves the music but doesnt like axl voice at all?

i mean the first time i heard didnt reminded me of axl at ALL , sounded like a high pitched girl singing to be honest.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: AdZ on April 13, 2005, 06:05:11 PM
Just a point to anyone who dislikes the lyrics.. considering this is a demo, the lyrics may have changed by now.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: *Izzy* on April 13, 2005, 06:07:56 PM
I heard it now ?;)
Axl sounds like a woman >:(
I like the song, it's great. It reminds me of The Immigrant Song :)

I give it five thumbs up out of five
?? : ok:? : ok:? : ok:? : ok:? : ok:

 :smoking: Izzy ?:smoking:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dont Try Me on April 13, 2005, 06:10:11 PM
Just a point to anyone who dislikes the lyrics.. considering this is a demo, the lyrics may have changed by now.

yeah, and not only that...........we are not even sure what Axl sings on the demo, lots of stuff to be transcribed. And it's realy hard to hear. So the lyrics people read now, or what they make of the demo themselves, could be all wrong. That goes for me too. But so far I really dig what he sings.



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: just_one on April 13, 2005, 06:11:37 PM
Axl sounds like a woman >:(

unfortunally thats true :-\


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Scabbie on April 13, 2005, 06:14:14 PM
and to whoever said bh's solo doesn't sound that original, i swear most of his solos that aren't plain bizzare sound similar to me.?


that would be me. I especially didn't like the way it stops and then starts low again and goes really high...it seems I've heard that so many times before. I don't mind shredding when its done well - I recently heard a Zakk Wylde solo on a song called 'Bleed for Me' which I thought was awesome.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: noonespecial on April 13, 2005, 06:21:29 PM
I haven't actually heard the track, but it's nice to see that BH's stuff is still there. ;D


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: grog mug on April 13, 2005, 06:24:38 PM
I think the track is from 2003, could be a reason why Bucket's stuff still remains.  The track ROCKS hard....I love the 20+ second scream at the end with Bucket shredding in the background.  I think this album will surpass AFD when it comes out.  IRS is simply amazing.  Maybe this will spark Axl to release this damn thing once and for all.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: welshrose on April 13, 2005, 06:28:05 PM
What gets me is that I didnt hear one conventional chord.  Musically its all over the place.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: jimmythegent on April 13, 2005, 06:31:24 PM
my thoughts on IRS?
it shows alot of promise as a demo, but it's nothing to get too excited about
if anything, it shows there are songs there, and that Axl hasnt gone completely industrial as far as harder rocking tunes are concerned
BH solo is tasty IMO but that first solo (Fink?) is messy and sounds directionless
Axls voice sounds pretty good, so all in all, a solid sounding song  : ok:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Voodoochild on April 13, 2005, 06:36:53 PM
I think the track is from 2003, could be a reason why Bucket's stuff still remains.  The track ROCKS hard....I love the 20+ second scream at the end with Bucket shredding in the background.  I think this album will surpass AFD when it comes out.  IRS is simply amazing.  Maybe this will spark Axl to release this damn thing once and for all.
Trunk said that the cd-r with the IRS was on Piazza's fan mail. He said it could be there even before the MSG '02 gig, when they meet Axl. So, this version could be from the 2002 sessions or even older.

About the song: I really love it. Can't stop listening to it. And, despite some users view, I LOVE the Buckethead solo.  :beer:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: horsey on April 13, 2005, 06:46:26 PM
ya think axl knows about the leak by now.im pretty sure of it,i wonder what he is thinking.he would prolly like some of the feedback and not some of it either.id like to be a fly on his computer right now lol.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: badintentions on April 13, 2005, 06:54:10 PM
i came across a few articles on the following sites.
http://www.melodicrock.com/
http://www.fmqb.com/Article.asp?id=77720
http://www.xfm.co.uk/article.asp?id=77644

listened to the song a few times myself seems good why does this leak seem intentional to me though.
the sound quality is to bad to be from a radio recording its the digital age after all.my dads old rolling stones records sound much better,and there 40 years old.lol.

i would say it sounds like someone taped it off the radio using shitty equipment that's all. they may have used a cell phone to record it or something else that has bad sound. i would say that this is almost definitely from the radio (maybe the reason the intro isn't on it) and it was almost definitely not an intentional leak.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: RyanMFGs on April 13, 2005, 06:58:14 PM
I think the song is amazing! The quality is bad, but you can still hear the potential of the song. If the rest of the record is as good then Chinese Democracy will be one of the greatest albums of all time.

im not trying to be a dick... but do you actually believe that?

I admit, thinks look good IF CD ever does come out, I know it's going to rule, but one of the greatest albums of all time? Not too sure about that.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Scabbie on April 13, 2005, 07:11:22 PM
Still find it utterly bizarre how the whole IRS story didn't get published on Blabbermouth.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: killingvector on April 13, 2005, 07:17:43 PM
I enjoy this song the more I hear it. With a bit of tightening, a better, less noodled bucket solo and this could be a third or fourth single.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Freya on April 13, 2005, 07:50:51 PM
I like it.  Axl's vocals are fantastic, no one can spit out a line like he can.  The BH solo didn't bother me, I think the song has a good groove to it.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Jonx on April 13, 2005, 07:59:16 PM
Still find it utterly bizarre how the whole IRS story didn't get published on Blabbermouth.

Yeah i find this a little strange aswell, Blabbermouth are usually pretty up to date with any developments in the Guns N Roses world. XFM were the first big media outlet to pick it up, strange considering its only a small radio station that broadcasts over London (digital and web excluded). All the other media sites seem to just have recycled this report for themselves.

It certainly sounds like a promising song, i especially like the last minute where Axl screams over Buckets solo, very nice indeed! Still the quality makes it hard to judge. Cant wait for the final version, it cant be that far off.

Jonx


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Voodoochild on April 13, 2005, 08:04:29 PM
i would say it sounds like someone taped it off the radio using shitty equipment that's all. they may have used a cell phone to record it or something else that has bad sound. i would say that this is almost definitely from the radio (maybe the reason the intro isn't on it) and it was almost definitely not an intentional leak.
To me it's obvious that the guy used the pc mic to record the song. He just put the mic near the stereo speakers and started to record with the windows voice recorder. That's why the quality sucks. He could put a cable linking the stereo (with the tape) to the pc. It's quite simple...


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: GnFnR87 on April 13, 2005, 08:17:42 PM
love it...its different but good. This song is hard to get bored of. Great beat, two totally different guitar solos, excellant chorus, Axl singing with alot of feeling and conviction (no surprise there  :hihi:). I like the solos, one touchy feely emotional one, then bucket shredding. Axl sounds pretty good, i like the scream. This song gets me even more excited about Chinese Democracy.......and its just a demo!!.It also further proves the fact that we will certainly NOT be dissapointed with this album.. Axl your killin' me(and us)!!!! just release it!!!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Malcolm on April 13, 2005, 08:57:15 PM
The more and more i listen to this song i just love it..I still think it could be intentional so the fans arent suprised by what the music sounds like...and wow that scream..Holy shit its cool...And ya im glad they got ride of Buckethead..Hes a good guitar player but he has no feeling in it..The song is sweet


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Sentimental Rose on April 13, 2005, 09:02:04 PM
I like it! I'm gonna try not to judge the song that much cause its a Fuzzy Demo, but what I can make out I like. ?I like it but I'm not gonna go crazy and say OH MY GOD its the best fucking song ever! ?It may be, but I'll have to wait for the album version to make that judgment. ?What this song has done is to stir up interest in CD. I personally had lost interest in the album, but this song has Peaked my interest in a way it hasn't been since the 2002 tour. ?I've had friends listen to the song and they're like cool I'll have to pick that up when it comes out. So I think this leak has done Axl some good, I hope he?ll hurry up and get the damn thing out while interest is Peaked!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: cheeser on April 13, 2005, 09:02:59 PM
CONSPIRACY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

jarmo's message board "goes down" or so he says during the time that  the IRS clip is released.....hmmmm, seems pretty convenient if you ask me.  so jarmo, whats the deal?  Are you the reason that CD hasn?t been released?  maybe you've got axl rose tied up over seas?  Maybe you are axl??????????????????


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Timmy on April 13, 2005, 09:04:26 PM
I thought the track was fantastic and I hope this whole ordeal promps them to do something proactive.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: marcos on April 13, 2005, 09:06:58 PM
the first thing that struck me from the first 32 second clip that was released was the drumming.  nice heavy bass drum, robin's guitar playing is fucking fantastic, great headphones song


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on April 13, 2005, 09:38:25 PM
Gonna call the President
Gonna call the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

0:11
There?s not anymore that I can do
All the legions said to me, I?ll follow you
When you plead the fifth, in the end of time is true

0:27
Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last time should I?m gone
All the rumors I can tell,
Something?s didn't work so well

0:37

With any way it feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the luck gettin out of this wreck
A fact that you've got to hear worst yet
When I need another favorite I take
It means your life will be gone anyway
Can?t believe that I was out there at all
Couldn?t see it coming all along

1:05
Well its true...ooh...I am, But don?t forget ooh ooh
Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a Private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

1:24 (need help with this)
Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna win and knock it outta your face
Rearrange it when your morning is noon?
And the police hang together, and their headlines true
[Finck Solo]

1:55
I've been too sure to offer my help
I set it up again dressed as somebody else
Feel like stumbling on the road
Feel like I'll never get ya out of this song
Well I'm just too sad to kill
Maybe like I just walked in my shit
They'll be waiting on me I know
Like a broken record for so long



2:17
What can I do?
Ooh, oh.
I'M Gonna call the President,
I'm gonna call a private eye,
Gonna get the IRS,
Gonna get myself the FBI.

((PS to me it seems here a part of the song has been edited out)

2:33
ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime you now it's true

[Bucket solo]

3:10
Gonna call the president
Gonna make myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

3:20
Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna win and knock it outta your face
Rearrange it when your morning is noon?
And the police hang together, and their headlines true


3:32
There's not anymore that I can do


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on April 13, 2005, 09:40:48 PM
Whats up everyone...
Id first lik to say that after the board being down for awhile, I have realized that this is hands down the best gnr mesesage board. no contest. We all have our differences when it comes to gnr, but atleast its constructive and organized. Jarmo and company run a very professional type site and the posters for the most part are cool too. Good stuff we have here...lets keep it up

as for IRS....
When I first heard the song I was a little disappointed. The song sounded disorganized to me. But after hearing thru the shitty quality, the song is amazing. I love it a lot. I love the way Axl sings on all parts, I love the tempo changes of the song, the background vocals/effect, and the solos. I can only imagine what the studio will sound like.


During the initial phases of discussuion with this song i read a lot of "its real good but is it 10 yrs worth". My question si what does that "sound" sound like?
IMO, IRS is a very good song. Is it a comeback/big gun type...I personally dont think so. If it was another band not named GNr doing this then the song would get great reviews. But give the circumstances with GNR, the song is very good. Just comes with the territory I guess. So if this song turns out to be a "filler" we are gonna be in for a real treat.

The song has a catchy chorus and cool hooks. Cant get the thing out of my head.

Keep up the great work...HTGTH,GNR fans and of course...GN"F"R!.....
Please make soon the word!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: WanaBGunner on April 13, 2005, 09:41:03 PM
I DL it from this place... daaa

I've said this B4 on this board and I will say it again, back in like 99 - 00, dont rele remember when. But it was about 6 months B4 the first tour, I DL 4 or 5 tracks off Ch Dem using limewire. I deleted them because I didnt know how important they were, I just figured everyone had em. I then found out that no one else had em and tryed to recover them but no luck. Me and a friend listened to em. So they have been around for a very long time...

And I dont care wut anyone else thinks.

And what did they sound like?... Well just like all the shit we've heard so far...

Quote
I just got done listening to the real song that will probebly be on the CD. Theres lots of lil shit u CANT hear in the sound clip thats going around right now. Very bad ass song. Here are the lyrics...

I think your full of shit. You just finished listening to a version of IRS that is much clearer and that will most probably be on cd? And before that you deleted them and couldn't recover it..........then how did you finish listening to a good quality version of IRS? bullshit.



First off I dont get what u mean. How do u not get what i just said. I download about 5 songs off limewire like 4 years ago then deleted them about 2 weeks later... I then downloaded (today) IRS which sounded like any other MP3 a band would put out. Then I took the lyircs from it and put it here. Whats there not to get?

100% truth, I had 4 or 5 tracks off CH Dem, I dont even remember the names. One was CH Dem i know for shure. I had no idea what the band was up to at this time, No idea who was in the new line up, how long they had been working on them. I thought of it as no big deal. So I deleted them to make room for other songs since it was a shity PC with little memory. End of storie. When I got done listening to them I thought "humm not bad, sounds like a good rock band"

Unless u guys can tell me how to go threw my old computer and some how find files I deleted from that long ago. If thats possible I can get you 4 or 5 tracks....


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Krispy Kreme on April 13, 2005, 10:17:01 PM
I think the song is mediocre at  best. No real melody. A  lot of random  noise. Very weak overall. Better than Rhiad but not close  to what the old  band put out. 3 out of 10, generously speaking. I hope the rest of the album is not this way or GNR is heading for a train wreck.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on April 13, 2005, 10:20:57 PM
I think the song is mediocre at? best. No real melody. A? lot of random? noise. Very weak overall. Better than Rhiad but not close? to what the old? band put out. 3 out of 10, generously speaking. I hope the rest of the album is not this way or GNR is heading for a train wreck.

Its just a demo and this song is much better than most singles on the radio. This song is catchy, the chorus gets stuck in your head.? Like I said its just a demo and we have not even heard the intro, and i am sure the solos will be changed and other stuff like that.? Id give it a 8/10. This song is on the same level as YCMB. And the song has been pretty much 90% postive for gnr fans? on the boards.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: jarmo on April 13, 2005, 10:22:04 PM
No you're not!

This isn't gonna be a IRS vs (VR song) thread.

It would be pointless...... Everybody has their own personal tastes.





/jarmo


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: D on April 13, 2005, 10:27:57 PM
There?s not anymore that I can do
All the legions said to me, I?ll follow you
When you plead the fifth, in the end of time is true

0:27
Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last time should I?m gone
All the rumors I can tell,
Something?s didn't work so well


are there typos in that?

when u plead the fifth,in the end of time is true   *that makes no sense, that cant be the lyric

wouldnt be the last time should im gone *once again any songwriter worth a shit wouldnt write that, that makes no sense either

none of that really flows or makes sense.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on April 13, 2005, 10:30:29 PM
There?s not anymore that I can do
All the legions said to me, I?ll follow you
When you plead the fifth, in the end of time is true

0:27
Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last time should I?m gone
All the rumors I can tell,
Something?s didn't work so well


are there typos in that?

when u plead the fifth,in the end of time is true ? *that makes no sense, that cant be the lyric

wouldnt be the last time should im gone *once again any songwriter worth a shit wouldnt write that, that makes no sense either

none of that really flows or makes sense.


I cant figure out that part. Any ideas?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: D on April 13, 2005, 10:34:05 PM
I havent really tried to figure out the lyrics yet

but ill try tonight

it is hard to decipher

i like most of what u have though

I just want everyone to not only listen to the lyrics but to also keep a creative mind while figuring them out. whatever anyone figures out read over and make sure that it fits together and adds up and that it seems like something axl would write and say


alot of that is very good though Dave, i have no idea how u made all that out! good job : ok:



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on April 13, 2005, 10:39:29 PM
Quote
when u plead the fifth,in the end of time is true
i think its

when you plead the 5th, that'll be the end of time if true.

hes saying by not saying anything/taking the easy way out, your indirectly saying what he doesnt want to believe...and as a result...they are done

Quote
wouldnt be the last time should im gone

wouldnt be the the last I should have known


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on April 13, 2005, 10:40:36 PM
I had a lot of help from cd.com and mygnr.com.
And people should remember when  trying to figure out the lyrics, most times every two lines rhyme.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on April 13, 2005, 11:06:46 PM
i also think the lyric is sin not shit....

this song convinces me that Axl and this band are going to be able to deliver a normal structured song. This song can go on radio right now and do well. A song like Maddy is a fan song.



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: D on April 13, 2005, 11:11:58 PM
yeah but a song is way more than lines rhyming

they have to go together to tell a story and make sense.

thats all im saying, just make sure the lines rhyme but also go together and make sense.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Jizzo on April 13, 2005, 11:19:40 PM
it easily has the potential to be a hit single.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: D on April 13, 2005, 11:57:58 PM
Dave  great fuckin job dude!!


i listened while following the lyrics u put out and i must say u are at least 95 percent accurate

that morning noon line, i have no clue what he says there though.

but great job

and i must say after listening to this song again IT KICKS SO MUCH FUCKIN ASS! i mean seriously this is a shitty demo and it fuckin blows anything i have heard in the last who knows how long out of the fuckin water!

it grows on u and when it does, holy shit does it grow!

the only thing i dont much care for is Finck's solo in the middle, the outro solo fuckin rules though, i still think finck should stick to rhythm.

anyhow great job Dave and whoever helped out! : ok:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: estranged.1098 on April 14, 2005, 12:03:21 AM
I love the slow solo, but it sounds like Buckethead to me, I don't know why everyone says it's Finck. I don't really like the second one, I hope it's improved (and I'm sure it will be) on the album.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: D on April 14, 2005, 12:09:06 AM
I tell u what, i never doubted Axl all that much but honestly whatever small doubts i had have been totally fucking erased

Do u hear those fuckin High notes he hits!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!


for those who dont like it, i know why

its cause u cant really understand what axl is saying *thats why i didnt like it at first*

read Dave's excellent interpretation of the lyrics while listening

it sheds a whole new brand new light on the song

i remember not digging Oh My God very much for the same reason, but once i read the lyrics while listening i was instantly hooked

I keep rockin the fuck out to IRS

I think it is amazing

AXL'S voice is the greatest rock voice ever

he is still the greatest, that shit is so amazing, i feel like a little nutswingin bitch right now but i cant help it

cause right now im truly in awe of Axl and what he has done with this song alone

if this really isnt top 10 then Axl will change the music universe

its that great to me.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: christina_rose on April 14, 2005, 01:13:31 AM
First off, big HUGE thank you to discobiscuit1 for your help.  :beer:

Secondly. HOLY F'N crap!!  :drool: The quality isn't the best. I had to turn my volume alllllll the way up, and my cats kept looking around trying to figure out where the sound was coming from, but OMG!!! I am soooooooooo excited now. This song sounds fantastic.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Scree on April 14, 2005, 02:17:44 AM
i came across a few articles on the following sites.
http://www.melodicrock.com/
http://www.fmqb.com/Article.asp?id=77720
http://www.xfm.co.uk/article.asp?id=77644
...
SNIP

This is something all 3 says

"The leak and rumoured emergence of other new tracks ?Madagascar? and ?The Blues? have all sparked rumours that the new GNR album ?Chinese Democracy? will get a release sometime in the near future, with some reports claiming that the album will finally hit stores in November this year."

rumored emergence? unless I am reading this wrong, are they saying demos of those 2 are floating about too?

Scree


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 14, 2005, 02:27:15 AM
The fact that Fortus has touring commitments until SEPTEMBER should make us fans  be a lil more realistic....at BEST CD will be released december....chances are yet another dead year.

So with that in mind and no forseeable release date, enjoy IRS cos the wait wont be over soon no matter how you look at it.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: estranged.1098 on April 14, 2005, 02:33:32 AM
The fact that Fortus has touring commitments until SEPTEMBER should make us fans  be a lil more realistic....at BEST CD will be released december....chances are yet another dead year.

So with that in mind and no forseeable release date, enjoy IRS cos the wait wont be over soon no matter how you look at it.

The IRS discussion thread


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: shaun on April 14, 2005, 02:50:57 AM
IRS sounded average on the first few hearings... then, then it got better  ok
Poor quality sound recording to one side, i really quite like the track  beer
IRS is on my site, and no i cannot tell you the location as that would be wrong  Wink
Roll on the finished album  peace


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 14, 2005, 03:03:43 AM
The fact that Fortus has touring commitments until SEPTEMBER should make us fans? be a lil more realistic....at BEST CD will be released december....chances are yet another dead year.

So with that in mind and no forseeable release date, enjoy IRS cos the wait wont be over soon no matter how you look at it.

The IRS discussion thread

Yes Im discussing the impact that IRS seems to be having and that so many people view it as a sign od CD's release.

As for the song, Axls vocals are great, musicianship a tad boring, solos are bland, and id like to hear the drums and percussion to be beefed up. As ive said before if the lyrics were as good as a song like locomotive or sympathy for the devil then it'd be an all time classic, as is its just a very good rock song.

Though its only a demo id say its one rung below a song like civil war, and thats a compliment.

If there are 10 songs on this album that are better then it'll be a fantastic disk.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Mikkamakka on April 14, 2005, 03:31:08 AM
Axl's vocal melodies are great, he proves that he has the talent, but he sounds like it'd be Hollywood Rose again. Since it's a demo the song's structure is not good and doesn't seem to be finished. The music is mediocre and sounds the same as the OMG-CD-Riyadh style, so it can be the 'new direction' which is kinda sad. Finck's solo is terrible, he's playing out of tone even in the studio  :nervous: Rid of this guy, please, he can't play lead for Guns N' Roses  :no: BTW Buckethead's solo is quite great  :yes:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 14, 2005, 03:36:07 AM
I think this is pre Fortus...listen to the music on his site, Im very impressed, very modern n cool, he would be great to add rythm and lead. Maybe some of the rythm here is Paul Huge.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Cocaine__tongue on April 14, 2005, 03:56:19 AM
Besides the poor quality, it sounds like a very promising and good song. I think i'll love it once I get to hear it properly.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: estranged.1098 on April 14, 2005, 04:16:10 AM
One thing that's interesting is that this song was mentioned in the RS article (January 2000), Buckethead joined in October. Possibly he plays both solos on that song, the beautiful one and the one introduced by Axl's long scream.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: hackvresse on April 14, 2005, 05:07:31 AM
I really like IRS

but the slow Solo sucks! especially  the beginning is bad. I hope they improved the solo


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: D on April 14, 2005, 05:56:16 AM

0:11
There?s not anymore that I can do
All the legions said to me, I?ll follow you
When you plead the fifth, in the end of time is true

0:27
Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last time should I?m gone
All the rumors I can tell,
Something?s didn't work so well



i think he is saying

when u plead the fifth it would be? the end of time its true

wouldnt be the first time ive beenwrong
wouldnt be the last time i shouldve known

youngunner was definitely right about those.


here is that other verse Dave, i think it says

gonna make this a federal case
gonna win and knock it out of your face
REarrange it with your MORAL Fool *im leaning towards Fool,would that make sense?
where the FLEET *paparazzi maybe*hang together and their headlines are true now



i dont think it says police, sounds like one syllable if u listen over and over and over. thats what i came up with, could be police but read the lyrics while u listen, after a few listens it sounds like MORAL Fool instead of morning noon.

second time around it says

REINVENT it with your moral avenue/attitude instead of REARRANGE it with your moral fool


I think this song is about Tabloids/paparazzi, lying journalist, all the bullshit about his goin crazy weightgain, maybe a bit with the old band.

just all the rumors and how people believe anything that is printed.

thats my interpretation


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Eppe on April 14, 2005, 07:05:35 AM
I think the song is amazing! The quality is bad, but you can still hear the potential of the song. If the rest of the record is as good then Chinese Democracy will be one of the greatest albums of all time.

im not trying to be a dick... but do you actually believe that?

I admit, thinks look good IF CD ever does come out, I know it's going to rule, but one of the greatest albums of all time? Not too sure about that.

Yes, I think CD can be one of the greatest albums of all time. The new songs we've heard are really something to be excited about and I think IRS is the best one of them. The more I listen to it the more I like it.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Voodoochild on April 14, 2005, 07:28:00 AM
Finck's solo is terrible, he's playing out of tone even in the studio  :nervous: Rid of this guy, please, he can't play lead for Guns N' Roses  :no: BTW Buckethead's solo is quite great  :yes:
:no:
Out of tone? Give me a break... You sure can not like the guy, but don't start to create false arguments.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Kefer on April 14, 2005, 08:06:02 AM
It may be "just a demo" but I can tell I like the song a lot and it is definitely the best new song I have heard in the last 5 years


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: pilferk on April 14, 2005, 08:12:50 AM
There?s not anymore that I can do
All the legions said to me, I?ll follow you
When you plead the fifth, in the end of time is true

0:27
Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last time should I?m gone
All the rumors I can tell,
Something?s didn't work so well


are there typos in that?

when u plead the fifth,in the end of time is true ? *that makes no sense, that cant be the lyric

wouldnt be the last time should im gone *once again any songwriter worth a shit wouldnt write that, that makes no sense either

none of that really flows or makes sense.


I cant figure out that part. Any ideas?

I think those two lines are:

Wouldn't be the frist time I went wrong
Wouldn't be the last time I should've known.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on April 14, 2005, 09:35:40 AM
There?s not anymore that I can do
All the legions said to me, I?ll follow you
When you plead the fifth, in the end of time is true

0:27
Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last time should I?m gone
All the rumors I can tell,
Something?s didn't work so well


are there typos in that?

when u plead the fifth,in the end of time is true ? *that makes no sense, that cant be the lyric

wouldnt be the last time should im gone *once again any songwriter worth a shit wouldnt write that, that makes no sense either

none of that really flows or makes sense.

Argree totally, "when you plead the fifth?" when all you people are saying it's "FIFTH" I clearly hear a 2-syllable word. there is no way in hell that word is fifth. for that matter I'm almost 100% that he doesn't say "the end of time" in fact i think what we have as "end of time" is one word



I think those two lines are:

Wouldn't be the frist time I went wrong
Wouldn't be the last time I should've known.


I agree? : ok:
well almost, I have

wouldn't be the first time I'd been wrong
wouldn't be the last, I'm sure I've found


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: yagami1gnr on April 14, 2005, 09:39:45 AM
The music is mediocre and sounds the same as the OMG-CD-Riyadh style, so it can be the 'new direction' which is kinda sad. Finck's solo is terrible, he's playing out of tone even in the studio? :nervous: Rid of this guy, please, he can't play lead for Guns N' Roses? :no: BTW Buckethead's solo is quite great? :yes:
Dude, Nobody have said that this is going to be AFD II, so stop with this sound is not GNR, GNR was always a mix of lot of sounds. As for Robin solo, is good but coud be better towards the end, but still good. ?:yes: I know that you wish that Slash would be in it but he's not, LIVE AND LET DIE. As for B'head solo if you like the same repetitive "see how fast can I play the same notes" guitar work, well it's up to you, to me it's boring. ?:no:
As for the demo, it's quite good but difficult to hear, what I like it's Axl's scream with the heavy sound, that doesn't come from B'head solo, I suppose is Tommy(Superb.) So I give it a 7.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: jarmo on April 14, 2005, 09:47:29 AM
As for the song, Axls vocals are great, musicianship a tad boring, solos are bland, and id like to hear the drums and percussion to be beefed up.


Though its only a demo


You basically answered your own request for better mixing of the drums. It's a demo, with low sound quality.


I don't know if you heard any of the Use Your Illusion demos, but for example, on the "Bad Obsession" demo it's just Izzy and a drum machine. The finished version sounds quite different and has actual drums on it. ;)



/jarmo


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: pilferk on April 14, 2005, 09:54:08 AM
As for the song, Axls vocals are great, musicianship a tad boring, solos are bland, and id like to hear the drums and percussion to be beefed up.


Though its only a demo


You basically answered your own request for better mixing of the drums. It's a demo, with low sound quality.


I don't know if you heard any of the Use Your Illusion demos, but for example, on the "Bad Obsession" demo it's just Izzy and a drum machine. The finished version sounds quite different and has actual drums on it. ;)



/jarmo

jarmo,
   I asked earlier..but it got buried quick:

What do you think of it?  I'm curious to hear your opinion...


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 14, 2005, 09:57:03 AM
We can only judge it as it is and hope that the direction and production goes certain directions.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: jarmo on April 14, 2005, 10:03:08 AM
I don't like to "review" songs on unfinished low quality demos. That clip didn't make me stop the playback and skip to the next song, so I guess I like what I heard. ?;)

Axl sounds great though. Not a surprise to me, but for all those "he can't sing anymore" people it must be a bit weird. Of course they'll say that the song is old and that he can't sing today. ?:hihi:




/jarmo


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Malcolm on April 14, 2005, 10:06:48 AM
Ok ill add another point of view i have..Like i said i love the song to death..And id could be a 2000 version for all we know..Axl sounds AMAZING and hasnt even come close to losing his touch..Still has the rasp when he needs and and i love the scream and the ending..Hopefully no one bashes me for this cause its jusut my opinion but its really lacking a good..Shall i say Slash solo...Or just someone that can play guitar better..Zakk,Slash,Ace or someone...But other then the solos i love the song...But i think Slash and Axl need to reunite desperately


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dont Try Me on April 14, 2005, 10:07:48 AM
0:00
Gonna call the President
Gonna call the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

0:11
There's not anymore that I can do
All the ? they tell me, I follow you
So when you ?, that'll be the (energizers/advertisers) too? <------ must sound something like that, the same verbal tone. Anyone have suggestions? ? ? ?

0:27
Wouldnt be the first time I've been gone(wrong)
Wouldnt be the last I sure have found
All the rumours I can tell, some things didn't work so well

0:37
When any way it's feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the luck gettin out of this wreck
A fact that you've got to hear the worst(word(s)) yet
When I need another favourite I take???
It means your life will be gone anyway???
I can't believe now and I lingered on
Couldn?t see it coming all along

1:05
well its true...ooh...I ask, my God it was you
Gonna call the President
Gonna call into my Private Eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

1:24
Gonna make this a federal case
(Blow the wind up), write that out in your face
Rearrange (re-debate???) (it when your morning is noon???) <----- this one is hard too, rearrange?? it's sound more like "debate" or something? suggestions anyone?
(With the police hang together???)
(And the headlines due now???)

{Finck Solo}Oh Oh..{Finck Solo}


1:55
I've been to sure to offer my help
I set it up again dressed as somebody else
feel like stumbling on the road
feel like I'll never get ya out of this song
Well I'm just too sad to kill
Maybe like I just walked in my shit
They'll be waiting on me I know
Like a broken record for so long

2:17
Can I do
Ooh, oh.
I'm gonna call the President
gonna call the Private Eye
I'm gonna get the IRS
Gonna need myself the FBI

2:33
Ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you, ooh ohh
It's such a crime you now it's true oooh

{Bucket solo}

3:10
I'm gonna call the President
Gonna need myself a Private Eye
Ooh, Gonna need the IRS
I'm gonna get the FBI

3:20
Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna wave it, write that out in your face
Rearrange it when your morning is noon??? re-debate???
And the police hang together???
and the headlines due???


3:32
There's not anymore that I can do


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on April 14, 2005, 10:14:05 AM

I've seen his set of lyrics but the first one you qouted me on was the 1:24. There axls says " natural case"
on 3:20 there axl says "federal case" like you said :)

However "Gonna win and knock it outta your face" I'm 99% positive axl says "gonna wave it, write that out in your face" Altho dave's line lays better in the story, it's in fact not closer then to what Axl sings.

but much remains open to discussion since this is a bad quality demo.? :'(


Hey guys how about this?

gonna make this a federal case
gonna win and wave it, right out in your face


anyway this is what I have up to that point

"IRS" - Guns N' Roses?

gonna call the president
gonna call that private eye
gonna get the IRS
gonna need the FBI

There's not anymore that I can do
With all the legions that tell me "I'll follow you"
?So when you see the pictures and the advertisements too?
OR
?will you be the victims and the agonizers too?

It wouldn't be the first time I've been wrong
It wouldn't be the last, I'm sure, I've found
With all the rumors I can tell
some things didn't work so well

Well anyway it feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
Somehow I'd known that I'd been here alone
? To all the luck gettin out of this wreck ? (I have no idea)
? A fact that you've got to hear the worst yet ? (I have no idea)
? When I need another favourite I take ? (I have no idea)
then you made up your mind, and off you went
I can't believe, now, how that lingered on
Couldn?t see it coming all along

"well it's due"
"Oh?", I asked, "My god! It was you?"

gonna call the president
gonna call myself a private eye
gonna need the IRS
gonna get the FBI

gonna make this a federal case
gonna win and wave it right out in your face


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Rain on April 14, 2005, 10:24:47 AM
Considering it's a demo version I kinda liked it. I mean I've listened to it several times and liked the feel ... But I have to acknowledge that I didn't even try to look up for the lyrics ... I hardly understand the chorus anyway.
One thing for sure, we hadn't seen it coming so it was a total surprise and now I'm eager to hear the final version that's for sure !  ;D


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dont Try Me on April 14, 2005, 10:26:01 AM

I've seen his set of lyrics but the first one you qouted me on was the 1:24. There axls says " natural case"
on 3:20 there axl says "federal case" like you said :)

However "Gonna win and knock it outta your face" I'm 99% positive axl says "gonna wave it, write that out in your face" Altho dave's line lays better in the story, it's in fact not closer then to what Axl sings.

but much remains open to discussion since this is a bad quality demo.? :'(


Hey guys how about this?

gonna make this a federal case
gonna win and wave it, right out in your face


anyway this is what I have up to that point

"IRS" - Guns N' Roses?

gonna call the president
gonna call that private eye
gonna get the IRS
gonna need the FBI

There's not anymore that I can do
With all the legions that tell me "I'll follow you"
?So when you see the pictures and the advertisements too?
OR
?will you be the victims and the agonizers too?

It wouldn't be the first time I've been wrong
It wouldn't be the last, I'm sure, I've found
With all the rumors I can tell
some things didn't work so well

Well anyway it feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
Somehow I'd known that I'd been here alone
? To all the luck gettin out of this wreck ? (I have no idea)
? A fact that you've got to hear the worst yet ? (I have no idea)
? When I need another favourite I take ? (I have no idea)
then you made up your mind, and off you went
I can't believe, now, how that lingered on
Couldn?t see it coming all along

"well it's due"
"Oh?", I asked, "My god! It was you?"

gonna call the president
gonna call myself a private eye
gonna need the IRS
gonna get the FBI

gonna make this a federal case
gonna win and wave it right out in your face

--------
gonna make this a federal case ?<------ yes, correct, i was wrong on 1:14 with "natural" case. it's both "federal" indeed
gonna win and wave it, right out in your face
<-------- ?Gonna ?"W" it, write that out in your face. BTW: I can't hear the "in" part of "win" so it can't be that.

Damn, I listened to it million times already......trying to figure out the lyrics with you guys. The song hooked me for sure. Awesome



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on April 14, 2005, 10:51:38 AM

--------
gonna make this a federal case ?<------ yes, correct, i was wrong on 1:14 with "natural" case. it's both "federal" indeed
gonna win and wave it, right out in your face
<-------- ?Gonna ?"W" it, write that out in your face. BTW: I can't hear the "in" part of "win" so it can't be that.

Damn, I listened to it million times already......trying to figure out the lyrics with you guys. The song hooked me for sure. Awesome


how about this?

gonna make this a federal case
gonna wave it, right there, out in your face


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dont Try Me on April 14, 2005, 11:05:30 AM

--------
gonna make this a federal case ?<------ yes, correct, i was wrong on 1:14 with "natural" case. it's both "federal" indeed
gonna win and wave it, right out in your face
<-------- ?Gonna ?"W" it, write that out in your face. BTW: I can't hear the "in" part of "win" so it can't be that.

Damn, I listened to it million times already......trying to figure out the lyrics with you guys. The song hooked me for sure. Awesome


how about this?

gonna make this a federal case
gonna wave it, right there, out in your face


Yes, I think that fits on 3:20. good find!
I'm still having problems with the same line round 1:24
it's sounds like it's starts with a "B"  .......... right there, out in your face, or does the sing the same as 3:20?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on April 14, 2005, 11:12:29 AM

--------
gonna make this a federal case ?<------ yes, correct, i was wrong on 1:14 with "natural" case. it's both "federal" indeed
gonna win and wave it, right out in your face
<-------- ?Gonna ?"W" it, write that out in your face. BTW: I can't hear the "in" part of "win" so it can't be that.

Damn, I listened to it million times already......trying to figure out the lyrics with you guys. The song hooked me for sure. Awesome


how about this?

gonna make this a federal case
gonna wave it, right there, out in your face


Yes, I think that fits on 3:20. good find!
I'm still having problems with the same line round 1:24
it's sounds like it's starts with a "B"? .......... right there, out in your face, or does the sing the same as 3:20?


I think its the same! He probably just repeats that verse.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dont Try Me on April 14, 2005, 11:18:21 AM
ok, cool, let's stick to them for now.  :)

how about these lines:

All the (1) they tell me, I follow you
So when you (2), that'll be the (3) too



1. sounds something like "legions", are there other words close to that?
2. So when you..... something that sounds like  "plead" but it it must fit with number 3 too. If 3 is "advertisers" then plead wouldnt make much sense?
3. that'll be...... something that sounds like "advertisers" "energizers"?




Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Jim on April 14, 2005, 11:27:51 AM
You know...

...I thought it sounded quite like 'religion', actually.

But y'know...What with getting it in context n' all...


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on April 14, 2005, 11:30:29 AM
I'm pretty sure its all the legions who tell me, "I'll follow you!"

the next part is har to figure out

will you be the buisiness and the advertisers too? ????
When you plead to bitches and the advertisers too ?:)
Will you be a witness and the prosecuter too?
So when you see the pictures and the advertisements too ?:no:
will you be the victims and the agonizers too?

I don't know man I just can't hear it yet.

I'm almost positive it's not religion


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: badintentions on April 14, 2005, 11:31:00 AM
Ok ill add another point of view i have..Like i said i love the song to death..And id could be a 2000 version for all we know..Axl sounds AMAZING and hasnt even come close to losing his touch..Still has the rasp when he needs and and i love the scream and the ending..Hopefully no one bashes me for this cause its jusut my opinion but its really lacking a good..Shall i say Slash solo...Or just someone that can play guitar better..Zakk,Slash,Ace or someone...But other then the solos i love the song...But i think Slash and Axl need to reunite desperately

i don't really care whether you think axl should reunite with slash or not, any boneheaded casual fan of gnr would say that (not saying you are one of those) but to lump ace (i assume ace frehley) in there as someone that "can play guitar better" is completely ridiculous. if you honestly think that ace frehley can play guitar better than finck, fortus, buckethead or even me you are crazy. come on man, you may like the way ace plays better but to say he is a better guitar player is completely ignorant. anybody that knows about playing guitar would tell you that ace is not exactly a great player.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dont Try Me on April 14, 2005, 11:36:07 AM
I'm pretty sure its all the legions who tell me, "I'll follow you!"

the next part is har to figure out

will you be the buisiness and the advertisers too? ????
When you plead to bitches and the advertisers too ?:)
Will you be a witness and the prosecuter too?
So when you see the pictures and the advertisements too ?:no:
will you be the victims and the agonizers too?

I don't know man I just can't hear it yet.

I'm almost positive it's not religion

hmmm, perhaps we should ask Axl..... Anyone seen him lately?  :hihi:



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on April 14, 2005, 11:39:54 AM
Ok ill add another point of view i have..Like i said i love the song to death..And id could be a 2000 version for all we know..Axl sounds AMAZING and hasnt even come close to losing his touch..Still has the rasp when he needs and and i love the scream and the ending..Hopefully no one bashes me for this cause its jusut my opinion but its really lacking a good..Shall i say Slash solo...Or just someone that can play guitar better..Zakk,Slash,Ace or someone...But other then the solos i love the song...But i think Slash and Axl need to reunite desperately

i don't really care whether you think axl should reunite with slash or not, any boneheaded casual fan of gnr would say that (not saying you are one of those) but to lump ace (i assume ace frehley) in there as someone that "can play guitar better" is completely ridiculous. if you honestly think that ace frehley can play guitar better than finck, fortus, buckethead or even me you are crazy. come on man, you may like the way ace plays better but to say he is a better guitar player is completely ignorant. anybody that knows about playing guitar would tell you that ace is not exactly a great player.

Right on badintentions! Being a guitar player myself, I have to say everything I've heard by BH is pretty fucking good, he was incredible live, the guy is a maniac and if you don't like his solo's (or think KISS solo's are better) then you have issues. Sorry, Just my opinion. Personally I think the solo sounds alot like like a Slash solo


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on April 14, 2005, 11:41:36 AM

hmmm, perhaps we should ask Axl..... Anyone seen him lately?? :hihi:


He was over at my place yesterday but he didn't feel like talking about the IRS leak? :hihi:

Instead we just hung out and played GTA  :rofl:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Saul on April 14, 2005, 11:44:41 AM
I like the song , love buckets solo.  : ok:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dont Try Me on April 14, 2005, 11:46:51 AM

hmmm, perhaps we should ask Axl..... Anyone seen him lately?? :hihi:


He was over at my place yesterday but he didn't feel like talking about the IRS leak? :hihi:

Instead we just hung out and played GTA? :rofl:

 :hihi:  : ok:



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on April 14, 2005, 12:05:07 PM
This song gets greater and greater with every listen. The whole vibe and attitude of the osng is great.

This is new gnrs YCBM. Same type of rocker. Great stuff.

As people have pointed out...this demo def shows that Axl can still sing. Whether its just spitting lyrics, a chorus or wailing. Hes still got it.

The music side is great as well. that middle part with Finck and Axl is so hooky. And Buckets speed complements this song. I love it.

And if this is not on the A list of song{whether that tunrs out to be true or not} is also another promising thing. This song is as good if not better than any single out there right now. I just heard the new NIN single. Its so boring. This has energy and everything. I would put this song up there with the new Audioslave single.

If this doesnt turn out to be a big gun, I think im never going to listen to another album ever again.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dr. Blutarsky on April 14, 2005, 12:16:13 PM
Keep in mind it`s a demo and not the finished product. But from the demo I think IRS will be phenominal.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Nytunz on April 14, 2005, 12:19:27 PM
is there any way we can make the quality better? Anyone in here have some knowlege on thiS?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 14, 2005, 01:05:22 PM
With work there are many programs that can improve the quality somewhat....so far the people who have tried have simply made it sound much worse (computerised sounding)

I think I could do a pretty good job improving it...but honestly, I have heard the bare bones of a new GNR song and dont see the point, I will hear a better version when CD is released or the actual track is leaked.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Sakib on April 14, 2005, 01:06:23 PM
i only hurd the 43 sec clip and it sounded kool


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Hoosier on April 14, 2005, 02:58:18 PM
just heard the song, and it fucking rocks! 8)


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: John Daniels on April 14, 2005, 03:10:09 PM
I like it, hope to hear the clear version some day. Everything else is goog but I hope a little bit effort to the guitar parts. I like Finck better than Buckethead in this song. Finck has more style in this demo, although Finck's "solo" is very limited. Finck is also more melodic player. This song is a little bit above of an average GNR songs but great song for today's music scene. 


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Mikkamakka on April 14, 2005, 04:48:31 PM
Finck's solo is terrible, he's playing out of tone even in the studio? :nervous: Rid of this guy, please, he can't play lead for Guns N' Roses? :no: BTW Buckethead's solo is quite great? :yes:
:no:
Out of tone? Give me a break... You sure can not like the guy, but don't start to create false arguments.

He can't play and these notes are false, not because he plays the wrong bars, but because his fingers fuck up every note. Sad but true, the world's worst lead guitarist.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: badintentions on April 14, 2005, 04:52:31 PM
Finck's solo is terrible, he's playing out of tone even in the studio? :nervous: Rid of this guy, please, he can't play lead for Guns N' Roses? :no: BTW Buckethead's solo is quite great? :yes:
:no:
Out of tone? Give me a break... You sure can not like the guy, but don't start to create false arguments.

He can't play and these notes are false, not because he plays the wrong bars, but because his fingers fucks up every note. Sad but true, the world's worst lead guitarist.

how could the "world's worst lead guitarist" play for cirque de soliel (sp?) ? they only hire excellant excellant musicians for that. you have no idea what you are talking about when it comes to guitar if you say that. you may not like the way he plays but that does not make him bad.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: hackvresse on April 14, 2005, 04:53:49 PM
Finck's got a sloppy style. He's a good guitar player but his style just sucks


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Mikkamakka on April 14, 2005, 04:54:18 PM
LOL, I've been playing guitar for 14 years now, my brither is a musician, I have a lot of friends who work in the music industry, and ALL of them think that Finck sucks. Sucks really badly. If you can't hear it, it's your problem.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: hackvresse on April 14, 2005, 04:57:16 PM
If he was really such a bad player he wouldn't have played for NIN or GnR.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on April 14, 2005, 04:57:36 PM
LOL, I've been playing guitar for 14 years now, my brither is a musician, I have a lot of friends who work in the music industry, and ALL of them think that Finck sucks. Sucks really badly. If you can't hear it, it's your problem.

He can't play the solo for patience very well IMO. Even I can play THAT solo, it's easy. I think his "style" does kinda blow.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: badintentions on April 14, 2005, 04:59:49 PM
LOL, I've been playing guitar for 14 years now, my brither is a musician, I have a lot of friends who work in the music industry, and ALL of them think that Finck sucks. Sucks really badly. If you can't hear it, it's your problem.

hahaha....if you have been playing 14 years and you think finck sucks then you may want to get a new hobby there buddy. i have been playing for 11 years myself, toured in bands and had an indie label put out a record. i know what i'm talking about and i'm pretty sure the people that select the musicians for cirque du soliel probably know a little something as well seeing as how they are very much know for the the musicians they select. seriously though...if you have played guitar for that long, time to pick up something else, preferably non musical....knitting perhaps?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: hackvresse on April 14, 2005, 05:01:52 PM
Quote
He can't play the solo for patience very well IMO. Even I can play THAT solo, it's easy. I think his "style" does kinda blow.

lol. He plays the solo intentionally different. It's not because he can't play the original solo. IMO the new one sounds much better


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Fosters on April 14, 2005, 05:07:30 PM
Mod edit : Jarmo said "NO LINK". Are you friggin blind?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Malcolm on April 14, 2005, 05:40:22 PM
Ok i should have uses Ace or Zakk as an example but i dont think it sounds like Slash at all...I think it just need a better solo thats all


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: badintentions on April 14, 2005, 05:54:14 PM
Ok i should have uses Ace or Zakk as an example but i dont think it sounds like Slash at all...I think it just need a better solo thats all

its not really supposed to sound like slash. i don't think axl went out and tried to get the 2 guitarests that most sounded like slash. i think he was going for something differant.....possilbly part of the reason slash isn't still playing with him? go figure....


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: philspectorshotme on April 14, 2005, 06:07:23 PM
little help? via pm of course. anyone?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: RyanMFGs on April 14, 2005, 06:15:33 PM
I think the song is amazing! The quality is bad, but you can still hear the potential of the song. If the rest of the record is as good then Chinese Democracy will be one of the greatest albums of all time.

im not trying to be a dick... but do you actually believe that?

I admit, thinks look good IF CD ever does come out, I know it's going to rule, but one of the greatest albums of all time? Not too sure about that.

Yes, I think CD can be one of the greatest albums of all time. The new songs we've heard are really something to be excited about and I think IRS is the best one of them. The more I listen to it the more I like it.

I don't know. I really quite like everything we've head. the 3 old new songs, and IRS. I think when it's finished, it'll be a great jam..

but I don't think it's gonna be one of the greatest albums ever. I'm sure there's gonna be at least 2 or 3 songs that we've never heard of that will knock us fans off our feet, but I don't know...

Greatest Albums only come along once or twice a generation. They had Appetite, and I think they should be satisfied that it's so legendary and just have fun with it from now on. VR did that. Their album isn't one of the greatest of all time, but I do love it. I think Axl isn't satisfied to do something like that. In his never ending quest to try to bury the past, including AFD, he just links himself closer to it by trying to top it. I know he can, but if that's his main focus, I don't think he ever will.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: D on April 14, 2005, 06:39:10 PM
i tried with the lyrics for 2 hours last night.

it has to have some sort of court/justice type theme.

its hard though i mean the way axl sings it sounds like 5 different things.

i still cant figure out OH MY GOD whether or not he says "to live in a tradeoff, believe you own version or something else.

Oh well, the possibilities are endless


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: metallex78 on April 14, 2005, 07:58:30 PM
The scream before the bucket solo...fucking wicked.

Yeah, when I heard that I was very very impressed, sounds like Axl is really pushing himself with the vocals on the new stuff!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Malcolm on April 14, 2005, 08:29:09 PM
Ok i should have uses Ace or Zakk as an example but i dont think it sounds like Slash at all...I think it just need a better solo thats all

its not really supposed to sound like slash. i don't think axl went out and tried to get the 2 guitarests that most sounded like slash. i think he was going for something differant.....possilbly part of the reason slash isn't still playing with him? go figure....

I know he wasnt looking for another slash..But im saying it would sound better with a better solo


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: ppbebe on April 14, 2005, 08:37:15 PM
Wow, so you all heard IRS?
I'm seriously behind you in information retrieval.

Still, I'd say the solo can't be better.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: shaved on April 14, 2005, 09:00:17 PM
I have forced myself to listen to this a few times.. not very good.  The lyrics are just.. cornball.

And whoever compared this to YCBM... tell me you are joking.  There are some promising parts but to compare it to YCBM?? 

His voice was high pitched and VERY feminine.  The solo was awful.. the scream was ok but not memorable. (yes I know, the quality is horrible.. its just a demo)  But If I heard welcome to the jungle with bad quality, it will still kick ass.

Every time I hear there is a new song (madagascar/chinese dem/Silk Worms/IRS/Rhiad) I am disapointed.  I mean is axl's goal to throw out songs that are not very good.. is that suppose to make us happy?  Not ONE of the songs that was released was a great song.. not one. I wouldnt waste a burnable cd on one of the songs to tell the truth. (I know I know, it must be a part of some master plan) Oh my god was halfway decent, along with The Blues.  But who wants to wait 10 years for a halfway decent song. 

I love GNR.. UYI 1 is in my car sterio as we speak, and I am wearing a gnr shirt, but with every song that is released (or leaked) I get more and more discouraged.  Not once has there been a true glimmer of hope for the new album.   I hope I am wrong and the cd will rock.. I honestly do. 

The only reason I would ever listen to this song more than once, is that I am a GNR fan. 



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: ppbebe on April 14, 2005, 09:03:46 PM
Or, maybe they are too advanced for you, love.  :D


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Jim on April 14, 2005, 09:12:26 PM
Yes yes yes. Muchly.

New GNR is a lot more...Out there.

It's not just Welcome to the Jungles anymore.

I'm not complaining.

I love depth in songs, which is what I'm sure we'll be getting.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on April 14, 2005, 09:15:02 PM
Quote
I have forced myself to listen to this a few times.. not very good.  The lyrics are just.. cornball.

And whoever compared this to YCBM... tell me you are joking.  There are some promising parts but to compare it to YCBM?? 

His voice was high pitched and VERY feminine.  The solo was awful.. the scream was ok but not memorable. (yes I know, the quality is horrible.. its just a demo)  But If I heard welcome to the jungle with bad quality, it will still kick ass.

Every time I hear there is a new song (madagascar/chinese dem/Silk Worms/IRS/Rhiad) I am disapointed.  I mean is axl's goal to throw out songs that are not very good.. is that suppose to make us happy?  Not ONE of the songs that was released was a great song.. not one. I wouldnt waste a burnable cd on one of the songs to tell the truth. (I know I know, it must be a part of some master plan) Oh my god was halfway decent, along with The Blues.  But who wants to wait 10 years for a halfway decent song. 

I love GNR.. UYI 1 is in my car sterio as we speak, and I am wearing a gnr shirt, but with every song that is released (or leaked) I get more and more discouraged.  Not once has there been a true glimmer of hope for the new album.   I hope I am wrong and the cd will rock.. I honestly do. 

The only reason I would ever listen to this song more than once, is that I am a GNR fan. 
did you become a new member just to say all that?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: ppbebe on April 14, 2005, 09:40:36 PM
To show how you are behind. well its just a matter of taste.

Not as a gnr fan, I'd say
This is what all the true rock devotees are waiting for.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: jgfnsr on April 14, 2005, 10:14:52 PM
I have forced myself to listen to this a few times.. not very good.? The lyrics are just.. cornball.

And whoever compared this to YCBM... tell me you are joking.? There are some promising parts but to compare it to YCBM???

His voice was high pitched and VERY feminine.? The solo was awful.. the scream was ok but not memorable. (yes I know, the quality is horrible.. its just a demo)? But If I heard welcome to the jungle with bad quality, it will still kick ass.

Every time I hear there is a new song (madagascar/chinese dem/Silk Worms/IRS/Rhiad) I am disapointed.? I mean is axl's goal to throw out songs that are not very good.. is that suppose to make us happy?? Not ONE of the songs that was released was a great song.. not one. I wouldnt waste a burnable cd on one of the songs to tell the truth. (I know I know, it must be a part of some master plan) Oh my god was halfway decent, along with The Blues.? But who wants to wait 10 years for a halfway decent song.?

I love GNR.. UYI 1 is in my car sterio as we speak, and I am wearing a gnr shirt, but with every song that is released (or leaked) I get more and more discouraged.? Not once has there been a true glimmer of hope for the new album.? ?I hope I am wrong and the cd will rock.. I honestly do.?

The only reason I would ever listen to this song more than once, is that I am a GNR fan.?



I 'll say it once again.

I might very well be in the minority here but it is my opinion that none of the songs we've hears so far (except for perhaps the title track) will be on the album itself.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on April 14, 2005, 10:17:56 PM
Gonna call the President
Gonna call the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

0:11
There?s not anymore that I can do
All the legions said to me, I?ll follow you
When you plead the fifth baby, then anytime is true

0:27
Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last time I should have known
All the rumors I can tell,
Something?s didn't work so well

0:37

With any way it feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the luck gettin out of this wreck
A fact that you've got to hear worst yet
When I need another favorite I take
It means your life will be gone anyway
Can?t believe that I was out there at all
Couldn?t see it coming all along

1:05
Well it?s true...ooh...I am,
But don?t forget ooh ooh
Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a Private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

1:24 (need help with this)
Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna win and I?ll get outta your face
Rearrange it when your morning is noon?
And the police hang together, and their headlines true now
[Finck Solo]




1:55
I've been too sure to offer my help
I set it up again dressed as somebody else
Feel like stumbling along the road
Feel like I'll never get ya out of this song
Well I'm just too sad to kill
Maybe like I just walked in my shit (skin/sin?)
They'll be waiting on me I know
Like a broken record for so long



2:17
What can I do?
Ooh, oh.
I'm Gonna call the President,
I'm gonna call a private eye,
Gonna get the IRS,
Gonna get myself the FBI.

((PS to me it seems here a part of the song has been edited out)

2:33
ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime you now it's true
   
[Bucket solo]

3:10
Gonna call the president
Gonna make myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

3:20
Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna win and I?ll get outta your face
Rearrange it with your morning at noon?
And the police hang out, and their headlines true


3:32
There's not anymore that I can do


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on April 14, 2005, 10:32:39 PM
Here's mine so far...

the lines I can't make out are in italics

"IRS" - Guns N' Roses

0:00
gonna call the president
gonna call that private eye
gonna get the IRS
gonna need the FBI

0:12
There's not anymore that I can do
With all the legions that tell me "I'll follow you"
?So when you see the pictures and the advertisements too?
OR
?will you be the victims and the agonizers too?


0:27
It wouldn't be the first time I've been wrong
It wouldn't be the last, I'm sure, I've found
With all the rumors I can tell
some things didn't work so well

0:38
Well anyway it feels the same
When you first told me you were gone
Somehow I'd known that I'd been here alone
? To all the luck gettin out of this wreck ?
? A fact that you've got to hear the worst yet ?
? When I need another favourite I take ?
? then you made your up mind, and off you went ?

I can't believe, now, how that lingered on
Couldn?t see it coming all along

1:06
"well it's due"
"Oh?", I asked, "My god! It was you?"

1:14
gonna call the president
gonna call myself a private eye
gonna need the IRS
gonna get the FBI

1:24
gonna make this a federal case
gonna wave it, right there, out in your face
? Reinvent it with your ball and his hand ?
? While the police hang him around their head like you now ?


1:34
(guitar solo)
Ooohhh...Aahhhh...

1:56
? I feel like I'm blowing the top of my head ?
? When I sing it, what the hell, like its somebody else ?
? Haven't I somewhere or way to walk ?
? Feeling like I'm crippled inside of this song ?
? You feel like a rhinestone diamond gem ?
? Baby like a sulfur to my skin ?
? You could have been wasted all day long ?
? Like a broken record that doesn't know ?


2:18
And I do... oooooooooo-oohhh!

2:22
gonna call the president
gonna call a private eye
gonna get the IRS
gonna get myself the FBI

2:33
oooo!
What shall I do
? If I gave my heart to you ?
Ohhhh!
? Yes, I can cry, you know it's true ?

2:49
(Guitar Solo)

3:10
gonna call the president
gonna get myself a private eye
ooooo!
gonna need the IRS
gonna get the FBI

3:20
gonna make it a federal case
gonna wave it, right there, out in your face
? Reinvent it when you're bawling at noon ?
? when the piece hang over in their headlines too ?


3:31
Not anymore that I can do


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Hoosier on April 14, 2005, 10:41:58 PM
i just have to say again, this song rocks. the finished version will be amazing and hard as hell im sure. i was very pleased to hear a "rocker" like this. although i really do like the big epics, this reminded me more of AFD.

Buckets solo is awesome, and im sure you 2 "ace" guitarist who were having a pissing contest on the last page should reconize that. "ive been playing guitar for 14 years and i know what im talking about, and thats why Finck sucks" ::) please......calm down and reconize this as a DEMO!!! there will be better things to come


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on April 14, 2005, 10:56:12 PM
I have forced myself to listen to this a few times.. not very good.? The lyrics are just.. cornball.

And whoever compared this to YCBM... tell me you are joking.? There are some promising parts but to compare it to YCBM???

His voice was high pitched and VERY feminine.? The solo was awful.. the scream was ok but not memorable. (yes I know, the quality is horrible.. its just a demo)? But If I heard welcome to the jungle with bad quality, it will still kick ass.

Every time I hear there is a new song (madagascar/chinese dem/Silk Worms/IRS/Rhiad) I am disapointed.? I mean is axl's goal to throw out songs that are not very good.. is that suppose to make us happy?? Not ONE of the songs that was released was a great song.. not one. I wouldnt waste a burnable cd on one of the songs to tell the truth. (I know I know, it must be a part of some master plan) Oh my god was halfway decent, along with The Blues.? But who wants to wait 10 years for a halfway decent song.?

I love GNR.. UYI 1 is in my car sterio as we speak, and I am wearing a gnr shirt, but with every song that is released (or leaked) I get more and more discouraged.? Not once has there been a true glimmer of hope for the new album.? ?I hope I am wrong and the cd will rock.. I honestly do.?

The only reason I would ever listen to this song more than once, is that I am a GNR fan.?




This song does remind me of YCBM why would I be joking? This song is just a DEMO, so take it as that.
The scream was incredible what are  you talking about it was just ok? I have not heard a scream like that in  years for any rock song, and that is just axl singing live in the studio. Wait til he can just do the scream and add it into the song. As for Axls voice being femine I think it sounds amazing, and listen to SCOM off of AFD,  he sounds pretty much the same.

If you were disapointed with a song like madagascar, then you will never be happy and no matter how great a new axl song is you are going to bash it.  Madagascar is one of the best gnr songs ever.

You are an Axl bash and that is fine, I am sure you are not really new to this board and just some one who wants to bash Axl under a different name.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: RyanMFGs on April 14, 2005, 11:19:19 PM
I have forced myself to listen to this a few times.. not very good.  The lyrics are just.. cornball.

And whoever compared this to YCBM... tell me you are joking.  There are some promising parts but to compare it to YCBM?? 

His voice was high pitched and VERY feminine.  The solo was awful.. the scream was ok but not memorable. (yes I know, the quality is horrible.. its just a demo)  But If I heard welcome to the jungle with bad quality, it will still kick ass.

Every time I hear there is a new song (madagascar/chinese dem/Silk Worms/IRS/Rhiad) I am disapointed.  I mean is axl's goal to throw out songs that are not very good.. is that suppose to make us happy?  Not ONE of the songs that was released was a great song.. not one. I wouldnt waste a burnable cd on one of the songs to tell the truth. (I know I know, it must be a part of some master plan) Oh my god was halfway decent, along with The Blues.  But who wants to wait 10 years for a halfway decent song. 

I love GNR.. UYI 1 is in my car sterio as we speak, and I am wearing a gnr shirt, but with every song that is released (or leaked) I get more and more discouraged.  Not once has there been a true glimmer of hope for the new album.   I hope I am wrong and the cd will rock.. I honestly do. 

The only reason I would ever listen to this song more than once, is that I am a GNR fan. 




This song does remind me of YCBM why would I be joking? This song is just a DEMO, so take it as that.
The scream was incredible what are  you talking about it was just ok? I have not heard a scream like that in  years for any rock song, and that is just axl singing live in the studio. Wait til he can just do the scream and add it into the song. As for Axls voice being femine I think it sounds amazing, and listen to SCOM off of AFD,  he sounds pretty much the same.

If you were disapointed with a song like madagascar, then you will never be happy and no matter how great a new axl song is you are going to bash it.  Madagascar is one of the best gnr songs ever.

You are an Axl bash and that is fine, I am sure you are not really new to this board and just some one who wants to bash Axl under a different name.


I thought his post was honest as hell, and extremely fair. Just because he doesn't like the song doesnt mean he's a shit face.

The minute someone doesn't like the song, it's "too advanced" for them or whatever. And "none of these songs will be on the album". Then what the fuck will? Chinese Democracy HAS to be on Chinese Democracy, and it's a 3rd rate rocker.

I like it, I think it's cool, but if I waited 10 years, I want something that blows the other shit away (even if it's completely different. I love different) If not, then just release it, who cares?

I personally do like the song a lot, I think it'll be cool. I like Blues a lot as well, and Oh My God definitely grew on me. But why condem this guy for his opinion? It's just as valid as all yours and mine.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on April 14, 2005, 11:35:28 PM
I have forced myself to listen to this a few times.. not very good.? The lyrics are just.. cornball.

And whoever compared this to YCBM... tell me you are joking.? There are some promising parts but to compare it to YCBM???

His voice was high pitched and VERY feminine.? The solo was awful.. the scream was ok but not memorable. (yes I know, the quality is horrible.. its just a demo)? But If I heard welcome to the jungle with bad quality, it will still kick ass.

Every time I hear there is a new song (madagascar/chinese dem/Silk Worms/IRS/Rhiad) I am disapointed.? I mean is axl's goal to throw out songs that are not very good.. is that suppose to make us happy?? Not ONE of the songs that was released was a great song.. not one. I wouldnt waste a burnable cd on one of the songs to tell the truth. (I know I know, it must be a part of some master plan) Oh my god was halfway decent, along with The Blues.? But who wants to wait 10 years for a halfway decent song.?

I love GNR.. UYI 1 is in my car sterio as we speak, and I am wearing a gnr shirt, but with every song that is released (or leaked) I get more and more discouraged.? Not once has there been a true glimmer of hope for the new album.? ?I hope I am wrong and the cd will rock.. I honestly do.?

The only reason I would ever listen to this song more than once, is that I am a GNR fan.?




This song does remind me of YCBM why would I be joking? This song is just a DEMO, so take it as that.
The scream was incredible what are? you talking about it was just ok? I have not heard a scream like that in? years for any rock song, and that is just axl singing live in the studio. Wait til he can just do the scream and add it into the song. As for Axls voice being femine I think it sounds amazing, and listen to SCOM off of AFD,? he sounds pretty much the same.

If you were disapointed with a song like madagascar, then you will never be happy and no matter how great a new axl song is you are going to bash it.? Madagascar is one of the best gnr songs ever.

You are an Axl bash and that is fine, I am sure you are not really new to this board and just some one who wants to bash Axl under a different name.


I thought his post was honest as hell, and extremely fair. Just because he doesn't like the song doesnt mean he's a shit face.

The minute someone doesn't like the song, it's "too advanced" for them or whatever. And "none of these songs will be on the album". Then what the fuck will? Chinese Democracy HAS to be on Chinese Democracy, and it's a 3rd rate rocker.

I like it, I think it's cool, but if I waited 10 years, I want something that blows the other shit away (even if it's completely different. I love different) If not, then just release it, who cares?

I personally do like the song a lot, I think it'll be cool. I like Blues a lot as well, and Oh My God definitely grew on me. But why condem this guy for his opinion? It's just as valid as all yours and mine.

I would not have said anything if he did say anything about me comparing it to YCMB


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: ClintroN on April 15, 2005, 12:52:48 AM
This fuckin' sucks!!!!

i wanna hear this song more then anythin'!!!!!!



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: D on April 15, 2005, 01:03:42 AM
I dont care who plays guitar on this site, it doesnt take a musician to know that the solo Finck played before SCOM on the 2002 tour was some of the worst fuckin shit ever played from an arena stage.


He is ok but ive said it a million times, u cant replace a legend like Slash with a Robin Finck.

Just like VR couldnt have any old frontman singing for them, they had to go get a Big Gun frontman

Finck would be a nice 2nd guitarist but they still need that Buckethead style type of guitarist to replace Slash with. Bucket was suitable, Finck isnt


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: shaved on April 15, 2005, 01:27:40 AM
Yes yes.. this is all too much for me. ?I nearly passed out reading the lyrics, they were so incredibly deep. ?

dave-gnfnr2k - When I read your post comparing this to YCBM, I could have swore it was about quality. ?I thought you were saying this song was on par with YCBM.. which I think is crazy. ?If I am wrong, and you were not saying that, then I apologize. ?

"the days of welcome to the jungle are over." ?My god... I didn't know that.. I guess the days of Record Sales are over then. ?Are you saying that axl is no longer trying to make hits like Welcome to the jungle? ?Because if Axl is going to stop writing hard edged rock songs.. then why be a fan?

I understand that this is a demo. ?This song simply does not sound that great. ?You can clean it up, edit it a bit, change a few things around... its just not great.  You can't turn shit into apple pie.  I am just stating my opinion, just like you are, but the second someone isn't kissing axls butt, they are an axl basher. ?God forbid I have an opinion that differs from yours. ?Do you know what also makes me fear for the quality of CD? Whenever I crank up "the blues," or "Madagascar", everyone in the room yells at me to turn the crap off. ?These are people that like gnr.. that scares me. ?I get pissed because I want to like the new stuff, but it just isn't that good.

The guitar solo - I will rephrase what I said. ?That Buckethead solo just does not sound good on this song. ?It doesn't fit. ?


I did not just now make this name to bash the song.. I have been around the board and site for a looonnnnng time. ?Nothing that I read makes me want to post. ? I read a lot of stuff. but I dont see a point in putting down a post on "when will CD be released" type threads. ?"ohh I totally think that 2005 is the year" ?Come on people, if I wan to masturbate I will do it in the shower. ? I will post when there is something worthwhile to post. ?When a new song is leaked, I post. ?If it was an amazing song, or even a good song, I would have posted my praise of it. ?

I hope the cd is so hot it burns my flesh when I grab it. ?I have my doubts though, and with every new song that I hear, my doubts are only reinforced.





Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: shaved on April 15, 2005, 01:31:22 AM
used illusions [ aapc ]

After reading your post again, I realize I completely misquoted you on the WTTJ comment.  My apologies.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Buddha_Master on April 15, 2005, 02:29:14 AM
Ummm hmmm....


Alright I just listened to this for the first time 20 minutes ago. And replayed it and replayed it and replayed it.

I'm kinda tripping that maybe I'm crazy (well I know I am) but, this is kicking my ass hard right now. Its the old attacking style that I dig so hard with Axl. Its got this swagger to it, that is so cool.

I think any of you who are brreaking it down and saying some lame negative shit, are fucked. I would almsot be so bold to say that if you dont think this is awesome, then maybe its time to admit that GNR just isnt for you anymore.

...Just took a break and kicked back. Came back and listened to this again, and damn...if this isn't some slick sounding shit. Would dig hearing a sharp version. Chinese D...bring it.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: estranged.1098 on April 15, 2005, 03:23:29 AM
I think any of you who are brreaking it down and saying some lame negative shit, are fucked. I would almsot be so bold to say that if you dont think this is awesome, then maybe its time to admit that GNR just isnt for you anymore.

That's correct. I wish these people would move on to other bands/forums.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: D on April 15, 2005, 04:15:35 AM
I agree Buddha, i cannot stop singing this

all day today while i was playing ball i kept singing this

my friends were like "what the fuck are u singing"

I said NEW GNR song that leaked, they thought it sounded awesome with me singing it, im not a vocal slouch but im not axl

this song kicks fuckin ass! bottom line!

I agree totally

this isnt Appetite GNR

this is something brand fuckin new and either u accept its something new or get out of the GNR world.

I dont agree that someone can only make one Greatest album of all time.

I think the original GNR peaked perhaps but Axl hasnt peaked and I am so confident in CD

just sayin if its true that none of these songs we have heard are Big Guns then its gonna be truly unbelievable.

I agree with Dave only this song is maybe a little catchier than YCBM



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Butch Français on April 15, 2005, 09:43:56 AM
yeah I agree D, definately a cool, catchy song.
I sing it constantly too ;D can't get it outta my head, and I don't want to either!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on April 15, 2005, 09:48:16 AM
An update on my take of the lyrics. (I know I'm obsessed, it's pathetic)

0:00
gonna call the president
gonna call that private eye
gonna get the IRS
gonna need the FBI

0:12
There's not anymore that I can do
all the legions, they tell me, "I follow you"
"when you're cleared of business and the end of time is due"

0:27
It wouldn't be the first time I'd been gone
It wouldn't be the last, I'm sure, I've found
With all the rumors I can tell
some things didn't work so well


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Aero on April 15, 2005, 10:20:54 AM
I am going to say what most of the press and fans will say when they listen to Chinese Democracy, and Axl didn't consider this:

It is a [cool, ok, good, interesting, etc] album, but it is not a 13 millon dollars and 10 years produced album.  Not that great considering all the money, time, tour cancelations, musicans involved, in relation with the album.


Obviously we only did hear an incomplete song with demo quality, and recorded 2 years ago (I belive that the band in 2 years has re-record some songs or parts of them) but what I wrote 2 lines before, is what most of the people will say, no matters if the album is revolutionary or a mediocre one.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Aero on April 15, 2005, 10:22:14 AM
In my personal opinion, I didn't like some rhytm changes al all.. but the chours are COOL.

And it seems that Axl likes the word "gonna"  :hihi: : ok:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on April 15, 2005, 11:08:36 AM
Quote
It is a [cool, ok, good, interesting, etc] album, but it is not a 13 millon dollars and 10 years produced album.? Not that great considering all the money, time, tour cancelations, musicans involved, in relation with the album.

As strange as this may sound...if thats the worst of the reviews regarding this album, then its a good thing.

If thats as bad as it will get then the album will be great. Its impossible and probably unprecedented to review an album with these circumstances mentioned. How do you do it? So if the reviews are not bashing the songs and saying they are actually good but focus on the whole time aspect, then for me thats a good thing.

Then it would be up to the person to decide whether they will like it because its actually good or not like it because its 10 yrs.

A review like that would be a check on GnR's list of uphill battles.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: ppbebe on April 15, 2005, 12:25:36 PM
I don't even understand why ppl compare this one with YCBM? ???
I prefer this DEMO to YCBM.? To be bloody honest, I like this song more than old GNR catalogue.
I'm not a big fan of the blues or Maddy tho. But maybe when I'm older...

Hey, Neemo, this is a bit of my "lady Mondegreen".
0:00
Your gonna pull evidence
Your gone to the private eye
Your gonna get the IRS
Your gonna need the FBI

0:12
It's nogging the heart that I can do
All the regions.. ???.. I never knew
When you plead the fifth,
And in the end of time it's True.

0:27
Wouldn't be the twist and I'd been gone
Would be the last turn should I've known
All the rumours I can tell,
Some thing didn't work so well

:-[ it doesn't work so well. The clip I hear is very poor quality.  :-\
(still that cant hide the quality of the music from me).


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Jim Bob on April 15, 2005, 01:14:40 PM
IRS ROCKS  ;D


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: SLCPUNK on April 15, 2005, 03:22:26 PM
This song kicks major ass. Clean it up....and it'll be a 10. :yes:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: thegoat77 on April 15, 2005, 05:01:54 PM
I think its a good song cant really make out the drumming and Finck's solo could be better, obviously the quality of the recording is poor but I think the studio version will make it alot better.

Its a good song but comparing it to YCBM is stupid, the new GN'R sounds nothing like the old line-up, the personnel on the songs are totally different (stating the obvious there) and Axl's voice is completely different.

Besides YCBM is my favourite song ever and it'll take something amazing to come close it. :peace:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: ppbebe on April 15, 2005, 05:04:52 PM
Quote
be a 10.

10? Strictly it's a 12.5. :P


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: plasmabeam on April 15, 2005, 07:43:52 PM
damn this song is awesome, even with the low quality. now i just can't wait for CD. Axl definitely makes this song amazing. i just hope there's a guitar intro in the final version... it starts too quickly.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: D on April 15, 2005, 08:12:46 PM
the "a band can only make one classic album" comment is so off base.

Look at the Red Hot Chili Peppers "Californication" was every bit as classic as Blood sex sugar magik

Prince's "Sign of the Times" 2 cd set is considered on par with "Purple Rain"

Im sure there have been many bands throughout history that have duplicated their success many times.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: jgfnsr on April 15, 2005, 09:33:44 PM
the "a band can only make one classic album" comment is so off base.

Im sure there have been many bands throughout history that have duplicated their success many times.

Not to mention we're talking about a completely different group of muscians!!!

So "a band can make only one classic album" theory holds no water in this case.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Mr Cowbell ? on April 16, 2005, 12:37:01 AM
I guess I am the only one still trying to surf the net and actually find the song to listen to. They should just release the official song on itunes so they can get $ for the files and have a good song out rather then making nothing off a bad demo. Afteral we all love GnR I just want to hear something.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Buddha_Master on April 16, 2005, 03:43:36 AM
"a band can make only one classic album"


Who said this? And, was this said pre or post Beatles? Because if this was said post Beatles, whoever said that is a FuckHead.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: madagas on April 16, 2005, 07:22:52 AM
I like it. Axl seems to have some of the old swagger and the song has a potentially great groove to it. It is clearly a demo. Question: I have only listened to this on my laptop. Are those acoustic guitars in the organ/solo/slowed down section in the middle? I can' hear it enough to discern. Song should sound really good as a finished product.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Sakib on April 16, 2005, 07:41:12 AM
I'D giv it between 7-9 out a 10. gr8 tune 4 crap quality sound dusnt seem fayk.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Oddy on April 16, 2005, 09:16:40 AM
ok the version i have is really really crappy. and is it just me or does the volume rise or the quality get better at around 2:30?

apart from this, the song sounds really really good.

i really love axl's voice. there's vintage axl but theres also some really really cool vocals, higher pitched, clearer. D will hate me for making this reference but i hear a lot of Robert Plant style vocals in some parts of the song. The similarity is striking. Since im a big fan of Robert Plant, i love it. I can't get over how great the vocals sound. The scream over bucketheads solo is orgasmic. :hihi:

I really like both solos. Its like at 2 sides of the spectrum. Fink with his volume swells and ambient style, then Buckethead totally ripping.

I've lost all faith in this album ever seeing the light of day. But as long as we get leaks like this everyonce in a while it'll be cool. It'll keep me happy : ok:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: anarchy on April 16, 2005, 10:37:30 AM
"a band can make only one classic album"


Who said this? And, was this said pre or post Beatles? Because if this was said post Beatles, whoever said that is a FuckHead.

There was music before the Beatles?  ???


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: yourolympichero on April 16, 2005, 11:04:37 AM
edit


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Mr Cowbell ? on April 16, 2005, 11:11:36 AM
After listening to it I think it has some great potential, all that is needed now is to make the vocals louder then the guitars so you can hear his voice the loudest.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: SADIS on April 16, 2005, 06:02:42 PM
Damn, I can't stop listening to IRS...... I love this song....it's high quality songwriting. It definitly should be the first single..... and I am one of the people who always said the old band was the original GNR. Well, if this is what Axl's vision is and this is only a demo....then Chinese Democracy will be the biggest bomb to be dropped since AFD.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Boner on April 16, 2005, 06:48:06 PM
Damn, I can't stop listening to IRS...... I love this song....it's high quality songwriting. It definitly should be the first single..... and I am one of the people who always said the old band was the original GNR. Well, if this is what Axl's vision is and this is only a demo....then Chinese Democracy will be the biggest bomb to be dropped since AFD.

I love this song too! It's one of them songs you can never get tired listening too....it's definitely a single material, if it's released as a single!

I heard this is not on top 10 songs Axl has on his best list   :o 

Cant wait for the BIG GUNS Axl has for us!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: estranged.1098 on April 16, 2005, 07:33:48 PM
I love this song. I think it could be in the top ten in any album Guns N' Roses released so far (by my ratings anyway), that makes me even more excited to hear the new album.

The tempo changes is an amazing thing in the song, it's what makes it special. In between the angry ripping blocks of music there are the slow, very emotional parts. Axl singing with a lot of emotion in his voice blows me way; the music (guitars, and drum machine?) behind does justice to that.

The two guitar solos also relate to the song this way; the first one is more emotional and melodic (reminds me of Estranged in the beginning). It's beautiful. Axl sings an "Oh Oh..", fitting the solo with the more emotional parts of the song. The second is introduced by his amazing scream, fitting with the ripping parts of the song.

Like I said, it's amazing. It's like two songs in one, and that makes ONE helluva song! If this one doesn't make the final track list I'm going to be very disapointed and happy at the same time, if you know what I mean.



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: jazjme on April 16, 2005, 07:56:56 PM
I absolutly know exactly what you mean:D : ok:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on April 16, 2005, 07:59:36 PM
has any1 else picked up on the background vocals on this track? It sounds like its coming from a group of women or maybe kids...

I think they are repeating the chorus{president,pE,irs,fbi...etc}...

listen carefully at the 156 -215 mark...they are definately saying something...hard to hear though...but theres something in the background you have to listen real carefully


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Hoosier on April 16, 2005, 09:56:43 PM
I love this song. I think it could be in the top ten in any album Guns N' Roses released so far (by my ratings anyway), that makes me even more excited to hear the new album.

The tempo changes is an amazing thing in the song, it's what makes it special. In between the angry ripping blocks of music there are the slow, very emotional parts. Axl singing with a lot of emotion in his voice blows me way; the music (guitars, and drum machine?) behind does justice to that.

The two guitar solos also relate to the song this way; the first one is more emotional and melodic (reminds me of Estranged in the beginning). It's beautiful. Axl sings an "Oh Oh..", fitting the solo with the more emotional parts of the song. The second is introduced by his amazing scream, fitting with the ripping parts of the song.

Like I said, it's amazing. It's like two songs in one, and that makes ONE helluva song! If this one doesn't make the final track list I'm going to be very disapointed and happy at the same time, if you know what I mean.



now this is someone who gets it! i thought i was the only one who liked the guitars. the way you described them is right on. IRS rocks!!!!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: AxlStaleyWeiland on April 16, 2005, 11:00:08 PM
this demo kicks my ass in all areas but the slow solo. It just wanders slowly and goes nowhere. Very weak attempt by Finck. 2nd solo kicks ass. Im a diehard Slash fan, havent heard much Buckethead, but I love his solo in THE Blues and now this song. He can really wail. BTW I saw GNR in 02' in Hartford Conn, Axl's voice live sounded nothing like this. I was dissapointed after seeing him live thinking his best singing was behind him. This song completely erased that. I know the studio(ProTools) could be somewhat responsible for his sound, but I really don't care. Even on this demo, his vocals are so raw sounding, I love it.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: reynics22 on April 16, 2005, 11:09:46 PM
this demo kicks my ass in all areas but the slow solo. It just wanders slowly and goes nowhere. Very weak attempt by Finck. 2nd solo kicks ass. Im a diehard Slash fan, havent heard much Buckethead, but I love his solo in THE Blues and now this song. He can really wail. BTW I saw GNR in 02' in Hartford Conn, Axl's voice live sounded nothing like this. I was dissapointed after seeing him live thinking his best singing was behind him. This song completely erased that. I know the studio(ProTools) could be somewhat responsible for his sound, but I really don't care. Even on this demo, his vocals are so raw sounding, I love it.

Buckethead doesn't play the Blues solo.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Goddamn_Electric on April 17, 2005, 05:57:04 AM
Amazing song.  Axl's vocals are better than they've ever been...and that scream going into the solo-was nearly orgasmic.  I've been trying to figure out a way to master this song and clean it up a bit-but I've had no luck so far.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: kyrie on April 17, 2005, 12:31:52 PM
I have forced myself to listen to this a few times.. not very good.? The lyrics are just.. cornball.

And whoever compared this to YCBM... tell me you are joking.? There are some promising parts but to compare it to YCBM???

His voice was high pitched and VERY feminine.? The solo was awful.. the scream was ok but not memorable. (yes I know, the quality is horrible.. its just a demo)? But If I heard welcome to the jungle with bad quality, it will still kick ass.

Every time I hear there is a new song (madagascar/chinese dem/Silk Worms/IRS/Rhiad) I am disapointed.? I mean is axl's goal to throw out songs that are not very good.. is that suppose to make us happy?? Not ONE of the songs that was released was a great song.. not one. I wouldnt waste a burnable cd on one of the songs to tell the truth. (I know I know, it must be a part of some master plan) Oh my god was halfway decent, along with The Blues.? But who wants to wait 10 years for a halfway decent song.?

I love GNR.. UYI 1 is in my car sterio as we speak, and I am wearing a gnr shirt, but with every song that is released (or leaked) I get more and more discouraged.? Not once has there been a true glimmer of hope for the new album.? ?I hope I am wrong and the cd will rock.. I honestly do.?

The only reason I would ever listen to this song more than once, is that I am a GNR fan.?



I know it's personal opinion, but I'd say you're in a SMALL minority in calling Madagascar disappointing. That's far more than a halfway decent song. I've heard almost nothing but positive comments from die-hard fans, casual fans, and non-fans alike. IMO it stands up to anything on UYI I.

Now, that's opinion and you're entitled to yours. But the other comment about Axl "throwing out songs" as if he's leaking them is pretty ignorant considering how hard the band's management worked to PREVENT IRS from leaking. I mean, lawyers went right after Trunk, collected the CD, and he removed the song from his repeat broadcast, which is why it didn't leak for so bloody long. It's a low-quality demo - Axl isn't trying to leak shit. The other songs were played live and it’s pretty much a given that they’re not going to be singles.

And I don’t believe that you'd enjoy Jungle in poor quality... think about that comment. There's a big difference between hearing a song you know and love in poor quality, and hearing a song for the FIRST TIME in poor quality. Apples and oranges.


When you hear a demo, you look for potential. "Axl sounds feminine" is an asinine statement since this is a demo and not a finished track - meaning the vocals were/will be recorded again, and likely enhanced etc. with Pro Tools or some shit just like every other CD. Same goes with the solo etc.

I’m not in the group that claims IRS is a 10. But it’s a song with potential. Madagascar, IRS, Chinese Democracy, and The Blues have me excited for CD. Silkworms and Rhiad and the Bedouins I could do without (and since Oh My God was released commercially already I don’t expect it on CD).


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: plasmabeam on April 17, 2005, 03:34:40 PM
After listening to it I think it has some great potential, all that is needed now is to make the vocals louder then the guitars so you can hear his voice the loudest.

i agree. if the vocals get louder, this song could be phenominal. the guitarring is awesome as well, however


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: ppbebe on April 17, 2005, 03:39:29 PM
Use your equalizer. Pump up the levels around 2 kHz. Then, Move the equalizer sliders for the bands of under 600khz and over 3khz to low levels.

younggunner, you must have a very clean clip. :'(


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 17, 2005, 03:50:35 PM
For me the demo is far and away the best rock song that we have heard from Nu GNR....Oh my god had some great powerful industrial style guitar but terrible production and poor vocal melody, Rhiad for me is just plain crap, CD has some nice guitar and Axls singing is cool but the song as a whole is very average....IRS with some work could be a great song on every aspect.



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: don_adam on April 17, 2005, 04:05:51 PM

Just a quick, small post from me ...

I think that the vocal sounds a bit like some old Iron Maiden ... but hey ... the sound is very poor!

Stay rose'ed!

/Adam

Denmark


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on April 17, 2005, 04:06:52 PM
Gonna call the President
Gonna call the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

0:11
There?s not anymore that I can do
All the legions said to me, I?ll follow you
When you plead the fifth, that?d be the end of time, it?s true

0:27
Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last time should have known
All the rumors I can tell,
Something?s didn't work so well

0:37

With any way it feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the luck gettin out of this wreck
A fact that you've got to hear worst yet
When I need another favorite I take
It means you might have been caught anyway
Can?t believe that I was out there at all
Couldn?t see it coming all along

1:05
Well it?s true...ooh...I am,
But don?t forget ooh ooh
Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a Private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

1:24
Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna wave it right there out in your face
Reinvent it with your morning anew
With Police, hang over, and their headlines true now
[Finck Solo]




1:55
I've been too sure to offer my help
I set it up again dressed as somebody else
If I?m stumbling along the road (wall)
Feel like I'll never get ya out of this song
Well I'm just too sad to kill
Maybe like I just walked in my shit (skin/sin?)
They'll be waiting on me I know
Like a broken record for so long



2:17
What can I do?
Ooh, oh.
I'm Gonna call the President,
I'm gonna call a private eye,
Gonna get the IRS,
Gonna get myself the FBI.

((PS to me it seems here a part of the song has been edited out)

2:33
ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime you now it's true
? ? ? ?
[Bucket solo]

3:10
Gonna call the president
Gonna make myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

3:20
Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna wave it right there out in your face
Reinvent it with your morning anew
And the police, hang over, and their headlines true


3:32
There's not anymore that I can do


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Jim on April 17, 2005, 04:38:57 PM
I'd say...

....That the lyrics are a mile out. Great job and all, a thousand times better than I could have done...

...But, remember how off the first version of lyrics for Chinese Democracy and Madagascar was?  ;D

(Oh My God was studio, Silkworms easy, and Rhiad just unaudible, so let's not count it)

Not only is it just not wasy to distinguish the words, but D's right. Read through what's been done so far, and there are huge parts that just don't make sense.

All the same, great job. But don't try too hard. You won't be able to get it 100%.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dead N' Bloated on April 18, 2005, 03:35:08 AM
You frightened the shit outta me jarmo I thought its was the start of the end of HTGTH.

I.R.S is a fuckin awesome song Axl sounds so good. the guitar sounded great and the drums sounded very bassy (but that could also be the quality of recording)

Who leaked it? Does anyone know?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: marcelinomichael on April 18, 2005, 11:07:33 AM
I am scared... and frightened... for I am listening to, and posses the new GN'R hit "IRS"! It is horrible quality but It sounds UNBELIEVABLE!! :D I can't hear anything he says....OMG HE IS SCREAMING!!!!!!!!! :nervous:LIKE A MOTHER!!!a solo??? 8)HOOLY SHYT!!!Something FBI! :o... April 27 behind the music...The Guns are RESURECTING very soon! :crying:
- WE BELIEVE! -


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Thorazine Shuffle on April 18, 2005, 11:21:31 AM
Oh man I don't even know where to start.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: chiense69democracy on April 18, 2005, 11:29:09 AM
The parts with ?????? next to the lines are the parts I am not sure about.
Gonna call the president
Gonna call with my private eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

Theres not anymore that I can do
With all the reasons that you gave
I followed you

When you plead the fith
And scream at me half the times to

Wouldn?t be the first time I?ve been wrong
Will it be the last
I?m sure I?m wrong

With all the rumors
I can tell somethings didn?t work so well
Well anyway
It feals the same

When you first told me you were gone
Well I don?t know
But I?m still hanging on

You are a fucking lunatic
And that?s the suite of hands you were dealt
Why do you mouth everything that I think
I thank you god
I think god that you will
And it?s a new dawn backing it on
And it will keep us coming along
 well it?s true
oh I am I?m a dog with you

Gonna call the president
Gonna call him through my private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna waive it right down in your face
Reinvented with your morning news ???????
with a peace hangover ????????
and a head like you now ?????

OH

OH

I?ll see if we can do it all for my heaven
I send it with a gift
And with somebody else

If I don?t wanna ruin the world
Feeling like I drift inside of this song

If I give you sedative
Baby just like I walked through shit

I have been waiting on you all night long
Like a fucking wreck it?s all you know

And I do

OH

Gonna call the president
Gonna call a private eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna get myself the FBI

What can I do if I gave my all to you oh
It?s such a crime you knows it?s true

Gonna call the president
Gonna get myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna waive it right down in your face
Reinvented with your morning news???????   
with a peace hangover ????????
and a head like you ???????????
NOT ANYMORE THAT I CAN DO.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: DRUNK on April 18, 2005, 12:53:18 PM
I have got to hear this song.  Someone PM me and give it.  :love:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Pandora on April 18, 2005, 01:09:42 PM
Everyone, stop begging for someone to send you the song. This is not the right place for that.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: DRUNK on April 18, 2005, 01:17:52 PM
Ok, then what is the right place for that? I've looked all over, and haven't seen it.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Pandora on April 18, 2005, 01:51:41 PM
That's your problem, not mine. Just do it outside this board.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: DRUNK on April 18, 2005, 01:52:42 PM
I got it, and Axl sounds awesome.  From what I can hear, Axl is also shredding his voice a lot, which would make a lot of you happy.  But he sounds clear and powerful, cutting through the music.

The studio version will be great for sure.

I'm digging it.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: grog mug on April 18, 2005, 03:05:30 PM
I'll say it again...very great song.  I've been listening to it through my car speakers and it's distorting the hell out of them.  But I have to turn it up full blast with that 10 second scream Axl lets out...!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Sillything on April 18, 2005, 03:19:04 PM
Well cool for you who have it and won't share. Hard to concentrate  on the song with Axls dick in your mouth? Watcha gonna do? Ban me? That would sure be chinese democracy...oh what ever...blame it on the Falun Gong


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: yourolympichero on April 18, 2005, 04:02:05 PM
edit


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Captain P?l on April 18, 2005, 04:50:16 PM
just a little pointer, i think he is actualy saying "Gonna call the Private I. "
like a P.I (Private Detective)
that made more sence for me... but i dunno :p


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: yourolympichero on April 18, 2005, 05:04:18 PM
just a little pointer, i think he is actualy saying "Gonna call the Private I. "
like a P.I (Private Detective)
that made more sence for me... but i dunno :p

P.I. = Private Investigator.

"Private Eye" is slang, but correct.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: ppbebe on April 18, 2005, 05:55:49 PM
Sillything, The absurdity lies here is that we are discussing something shouldn't be known. :hihi:

Each transcription sounds right to me.
 :D the quote in olympichero's post seems re inventive.

lady mondegreens. I sometimes hear it like
3:10
Your gone
You'll never live a private life
Ooh, Gonna need the IRS
go and get the FBI

3:20
Your making it a federal case
Your waving it right out of your face


But I cant hear "if I gave my heart to you..." line :-\


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Twisted Nerve 85 on April 18, 2005, 06:48:15 PM
Okay Folks am I the only one who thinks this whole thing is a publicity stunt. Ya know planned by Mr. Rose js to give the fans a tiny little speck to keep em from losing interest. Keep their mouths watering for that album and their brains repeating those two words, Chinese Democracy. Plus its also partial evidence that he js hasnt been sitting in the studio with his thumb up his ass with his headphones on full blast with November Rain playing while he says to himself, "Shit, I gotta make another one of these...........Maybe a whole album full of em?"

Axl has been in the spotlight for a long time so he knows how to get ppls attention  :peace:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on April 18, 2005, 06:59:38 PM
Okay Folks am I the only one who thinks this whole thing is a publicity stunt. Ya know planned by Mr. Rose js to give the fans a tiny little speck to keep em from losing interest. Keep their mouths watering for that album and their brains repeating those two words, Chinese Democracy. Plus its also partial evidence that he js hasnt been sitting in the studio with his thumb up his ass with his headphones on full blast with November Rain playing while he says to himself, "Shit, I gotta make another one of these...........Maybe a whole album full of em?"

Axl has been in the spotlight for a long time so he knows how to get ppls attention? :peace:
No because he would have leaked a g ood quality version.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: SINSHINE on April 19, 2005, 09:14:38 AM
sorry if this has already been discussed, but has anyone brought up the reasoning behind the title, "I.R.S."?

Axl mentions all these government intelligence agencies, but does he choose to name the entire song I.R.S.?

I wonder if the liner notes will show I.R.S. standing for an acronym for something else (along similar lines as to the Locomotive spelling and "The Perils of Rock & Roll Decadence" subtitle). Anyone have any thoughts on this?

Again, sorry if it's already been discussed.  8)



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: sg4eva on April 19, 2005, 09:20:19 AM
I was a little weary of getting Chinese Democracy, but if the whole album is like this, it'll be fantastic, I love the song, regardless of the quality.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: MetaSouL on April 19, 2005, 09:39:03 AM
For GNR fans, no sales or opinions are to be dominated by this little demo, so let us all stop pretending that we are agents of the band playing an "important" role in slowing an inevitability (AFD demos for example) all the while huming along to the song as we type detering words to others. ?

Anyone hanging on coat-tails saying "don't share the song" when they themselves participated in "receiving" the song, thus "sharing", is nothing but a hypocrite. ?"It's ok for me but not for you"....it is like telling your sister that her snickers bar is piece of poop while peanuts and carmel are hangin' from your lips. ?Think about it....that little word, "hypocrisy"....says a lot. ?Their gonna have to change the title of the album to Chinese Hypocrisy in memory of the fans who have misrepresented the band by not practicing what they preach. ?What's the difference between listening to the song against the will of management and... listening to the song against the will of management while lying through your teeth and attempting to control others with the very same lies? ?I'll tell you what the difference is, one person is true to themselves (reminds me of Axl) and the other person is neither true to themselves nor others (reminds me of Ashley Simpson ?:rofl: ). ?

It's simply a demo that management doesn't want people judging the band by, nothing more. ?Read the release.? :smoking:

~M


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: jarmo on April 19, 2005, 09:47:56 AM
Whatever.....

This board isn't the tool that should be used to spread material the band doesn't want spread. Easy as that.

Same thing with home addresses of past and present band members, or the picture of an unmasked Buckethead.


I call that respect, you seem to disagree and that's your problem. Not mine.




/jarmo


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: yourolympichero on April 19, 2005, 12:02:46 PM
or the picture of an unmasked Buckethead.

Seeing he's not in the band anymore and the picture was from 20 years ago...

Who cares?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: jarmo on April 19, 2005, 12:16:34 PM
or the picture of an unmasked Buckethead.

Seeing he's not in the band anymore and the picture was from 20 years ago...

Who cares?


He seems to care since it's not on his web site.



/jarmo


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 19, 2005, 12:44:35 PM
Again...the whole persona thing is beyond lame and childish....ooooh im a comic character rock star, take me seriously. I will only record from a chicken coup.


Gimme a break , why respect someome who is either .
a.   a pretentious TWAT

or

B..  mentally disturbed

the guy isnt in the band anymore who cares.

I dont even wanna see his face......why would I???....why would anyone????


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: AdZ on April 19, 2005, 01:54:26 PM
What has that got to do with the topic? Talk about the IRS leak or shut up.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 19, 2005, 02:17:24 PM
What has that got to do with the topic? Talk about the IRS leak or shut up.

I apologise oh great one for not sticking 100% to topic and getting distracted by the previuos threads.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: SINSHINE on April 19, 2005, 02:39:39 PM
sorry if this has already been discussed, but has anyone brought up the reasoning behind the title, "I.R.S."?

Axl mentions all these government intelligence agencies, but does he choose to name the entire song I.R.S.?

I wonder if the liner notes will show I.R.S. standing for an acronym for something else (along similar lines as to the Locomotive spelling and "The Perils of Rock & Roll Decadence" subtitle). Anyone have any thoughts on this?

Again, sorry if it's already been discussed.? 8)




I NEVER bump myself like this, but I feel like the topic began straying from the path the last page or so of posts...just didn't want my original post to be mashed in with all that 'privacy' and 'respect' tangeant.

Thanks  :peace:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Captain Obvious on April 19, 2005, 10:43:44 PM
I think this song can be very awesome if it ever gets properly released........






.......which won't happen because Axl will probably lose his mind after finding out about the leak and burning all his life's work.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Axl4Prez2004 on April 20, 2005, 08:06:23 AM
I think this song can be very awesome if it ever gets properly released........

.......which won't happen because Axl will probably lose his mind after finding out about the leak and burning all his life's work.
[/color]


Captain Obvious, please don't give Axl ideas like this!!!   :'(


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Beholder on April 20, 2005, 12:59:44 PM
My Points on IRS:

1- Amazing riffs
2- Amazing solos
3- Amazing voice
4- Amazing lyrics
5- Amazing drums
6- Amazing bass

If it comes to be a single, i would put in the same level of YCBM...and talking about YCBM , i think IRS perfectly fits in a action movie like YCBM did... Imagine a car chasing scene with IRS...

Just my points...


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 20, 2005, 01:06:54 PM
My Points on IRS:

1- Amazing riffs
2- Amazing solos
3- Amazing voice
4- Amazing lyrics
5- Amazing drums
6- Amazing bass

If it comes to be a single, i would put in the same level of YCBM...and talking about YCBM , i think IRS perfectly fits in a action movie like YCBM did... Imagine a car chasing scene with IRS...


honestly its impossible to say amazing about half of those considering u can barely hear the guitars and the drums are inaudible and sound like a drum machine for the most part.

I love IRS i think it'll be great...but relax on the amazing drums etc

Just my points...



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: ppbebe on April 20, 2005, 01:20:16 PM
My Points on IRS:

1- Amazing riffs
2- Amazing solos
3- Amazing voice
4- Amazing lyrics
5- Amazing drums
6- Amazing bass

If it comes to be a single, i would put in the same level of YCBM...and talking about YCBM , i think IRS perfectly fits in a action movie like YCBM did... Imagine a car chasing scene with IRS...

Just my points...

I wouldn't put this in the same level of YCBM. To me, this demo is better than YCBM.
And I don't want it with some car chasing scene.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 20, 2005, 01:25:36 PM
I personally am very interested in hearing non GNR fans opinion...I feel that that is much more relevant as fans have a vested interest.

Has anyone played it to friends???...and the views expressed by non GNR fans??   what the verdict??


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Lilljon on April 20, 2005, 01:29:11 PM
When i listen to this, my hope is slowly fading back. This is good, the new Guns N' Roses is good. Please release the album with Bucketheads part still on and please play in Sweden!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 20, 2005, 01:33:47 PM
Sad to say I for one am a bit over GNR's style...I am putting  a  band togerher and working on music more interesting to myself....BUT I am a huge fan Of Axls lyrics and voice...and I for one feel that after listening to IRS that the idea of CD pumping VERY loud in my car stereo on a long trip...is a VERY appealing idea.....hey AXL...if you have the songs....release it.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: madagas on April 20, 2005, 01:36:01 PM
Disco, when Eddie Trunk played it on his show, he said he received thousands of calls requesting it. It got a good reaction. That is as good of an opinion as you are going to get. He also said the fourth track that was on the disc he had was better than IRS. Who knows...


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 20, 2005, 01:44:33 PM
Disco, when Eddie Trunk played it on his show, he said he received thousands of calls requesting it. It got a good reaction. That is as good of an opinion as you are going to get. He also said the fourth track that was on the disc he had was better than IRS. Who knows...


thats cool...but in the end it;s ' he said , she said' stuff

Im a guns fan....and I would love to hear non Guns fans opinions....this board is perfect to share non fans opinions.

I have a 15 yr old sis...mainly into top R n B......stuff ud expect...she thinks it is great...a friend and former GNR fan...a  musician...thinks Axls voice is awesome, and that the melody ' has something special'...but says the music is 'crap'....no hook or style, with the chords being boring and solos derivativ en predictable....but for a demo....cool

P. S

Asked my sis if the thought kids her age would like it....she looked suprised and said .? ? fuck yeh...its pretty cool
Ill start....


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Axl8302 on April 20, 2005, 02:01:36 PM
I personally am very interested in hearing non GNR fans opinion...I feel that that is much more relevant as fans have a vested interest.

Has anyone played it to friends???...and the views expressed by non GNR fans??? ?what the verdict??



i played it to my friend he said it was ok, but really like madagascar so i'l let him off.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on April 20, 2005, 02:33:35 PM
Most of my friends didnt liek the new songs we have heard that much.
When I played IRS they were pleasantly surprised. They liked it and 1 even asked me to burn him a copy.

I guess its because IRS is probably the most "radio friendly" song of all the songs we have heard so far. Its got a catchy chorus, great vocals, and cool tempo and vibe...

That was the only thing that really worried me regarding the new material. The stuff we have heard is great imo, but not radio friendly. IRS convinces me that they also got those types of songs as well.


I really wish Axl would just release the album. Especially now. SPring/Summer is the best time to fukin release stuff. The weather and everything...gnr blasting on my radio with the windows down...cmon Axl now is the fukin time...tour when u want to but release the album.....IRS has rejuvenated me in a big way. Now blow me away with the monsters.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: discobiscuit1 on April 20, 2005, 02:37:34 PM
Most of my friends didnt liek the new songs we have heard that much.
When I played IRS they were pleasantly surprised. They liked it and 1 even asked me to burn him a copy.

I guess its because IRS is probably the most "radio friendly" song of all the songs we have heard so far. I



more likely that IRS and the blues are damned good songs...the rest are average  (mad being too indulgent)...or crap....these 2 songs are undeniably good songs


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Captain Obvious on April 20, 2005, 03:28:47 PM
Around the 2 minute and 48 second mark, my jaw dropped, eyes widened and I almost had a musical erection. Did anybody  catch that note? If that's his real live voice, there ashould be no more threads about Axl losing his voice.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Chandler on April 20, 2005, 03:46:13 PM
I just listened to it for the first time.  I think it is pretty good.  Axl sounded good.  I did not like the guitar solo very much though.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Lord Kayoss on April 20, 2005, 04:24:14 PM
I have forced myself to listen to this a few times.. not very good.? The lyrics are just.. cornball.

And whoever compared this to YCBM... tell me you are joking.? There are some promising parts but to compare it to YCBM???

His voice was high pitched and VERY feminine.? The solo was awful.. the scream was ok but not memorable. (yes I know, the quality is horrible.. its just a demo)? But If I heard welcome to the jungle with bad quality, it will still kick ass.

Every time I hear there is a new song (madagascar/chinese dem/Silk Worms/IRS/Rhiad) I am disapointed.? I mean is axl's goal to throw out songs that are not very good.. is that suppose to make us happy?? Not ONE of the songs that was released was a great song.. not one. I wouldnt waste a burnable cd on one of the songs to tell the truth. (I know I know, it must be a part of some master plan) Oh my god was halfway decent, along with The Blues.? But who wants to wait 10 years for a halfway decent song.?

I love GNR.. UYI 1 is in my car sterio as we speak, and I am wearing a gnr shirt, but with every song that is released (or leaked) I get more and more discouraged.? Not once has there been a true glimmer of hope for the new album.? ?I hope I am wrong and the cd will rock.. I honestly do.?

The only reason I would ever listen to this song more than once, is that I am a GNR fan.?




I agree with alot of what you have to say.?

I reserved judgment on the track to really give it a few listens and to keep in mind that it is only a demo.? But, with that being said the song still isn't very impressive to me.? Especially when considering all the time that's been devoted to the project.? Millions of dollars and 8 to 10 years of dissecting and revamping this material seems ridiculous.? "Chinese Democracy" should've been released back in '99 when the album title was finally revealed and Axl was calling into MTV and discussing it.? Six years later most casual fans (and alot of die-hards) are expecting a monstrous, ground-breaking juggernaut that will set astronomical standards for all genres of music.? Of course I think we all know that ain't happening.? But even still, we do expect a GREAT album that's totally been worth waiting for.? And although I've remained very positive about it over the years (and still am) I can't say this song helps that philosophical optimism.

PS:? A very special thanx again to the person who sent me the track - you know who you are.? : ok:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: damnthehaters on April 20, 2005, 04:53:55 PM
can someone send me the track?

mhollod@yahoo.com


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: DRUNK on April 20, 2005, 05:03:29 PM
I've been listening to it over and over and I'm not getting sick of it.  It's really catchy.  The thing with Buckethead though, is his solos all sound very similiar.  This song is no exception.  He's good and all, but if he really isn't coming back to the band, it won't be that huge of a loss (except for the cool image obviously).


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: damnthehaters on April 22, 2005, 02:36:49 AM
Anybody?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on April 22, 2005, 09:26:06 PM
Gonna call the President
Gonna call in the Private I
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

0:11
There?s not anymore that I can do
All the legions said to me
I?ll follow you
When you plead the fifth, that?d be anytime it?s true

0:27
Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last time should I?m gone
All the rumors I can tell,
Something?s didn't work so well

0:37

With any way, it feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the luck gettin out of the debt (wreck)
A fact that you've got to hear worst yet
When I need another favorite I take
It means you might have been caught anyway
Can?t believe that I was out there at all
Couldn?t see it coming all along

1:05
Well it?s true...ooh...I am,
But don?t forget
Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a Private I
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

1:24
Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna wave it right there out in your face
Repeat it with your morning anew
With Police, hang over, and their headlines true now
[Finck Solo]




1:55
I've been too sure to offer my help
I set it up again dressed as somebody else
If I?m stumbling along the wall (road)
Feel like I'll never get ya out of this song
Well I'm just too sad to kill
Maybe like I just walked in my skin (shit/sin?)
They'll be waiting on me I know
Like a broken record for so long



2:17
What can I do?
Ooh, oh.
I'm Gonna call the President,
I'm gonna call a private I
Gonna get the IRS,
Gonna get myself the FBI.

((PS to me it seems here a part of the song has been edited out)

2:33
ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime you now it's true (it too)
   
[Bucket solo]

3:10
Gonna call the president
Gonna make myself a private I
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

3:20
Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna wave it right there out in your face
Repeat it with your morning anew
And the police, hang over, and their headlines true


3:32
There's not anymore that I can do


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Jim on April 23, 2005, 10:01:55 AM
Quote
Wouldn't be the last time should I?m gone

Did you read that before posting it? That just makes hella no sense.

Regarding your PS, me too.

Or at least, it sounds like two different recordings put together.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: ClintroN on May 07, 2005, 10:57:32 PM
A freind at my tafe school just found IRS for me a few days ago, i was willing to not listen to it for obvious reasons but i jumped at it and let me tell ya, it's givin' me total new hope and excitment for Chinese Democracy.

 The song just kicks arse man, big time, it's got the (song) Chinese Democracy and It's So Easy feel to me all the way n' i once again i have this fuckin' massive high about the whole thing. I've always had the hype, but hearing this poor quality song is enough for me to be excited about.

The riffs in it are just mean n'  dirty, i have the basic idea of the song and only just prooves again what were in for...

Just fucking imagin when we get this bloody album......i think all basic functions will be cut off to any other band or music that will be out for a long long time :yes: :hihi:

Has anyone found new hope or what have you in hearing this demo??


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: geographicaloddity on May 08, 2005, 12:09:26 AM
am I the only one who hasn't heard it?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Wingman17 on May 08, 2005, 05:28:36 AM
am I the only one who hasn't heard it?

Negative.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dust N Rose on May 08, 2005, 06:15:10 AM
I haven't too. I had the chance but I don't want to.
Imagine Chinese Democracy, having 4 or 5 songs inside that we've already heard.
Like spoilers in the movies.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: nesquick on August 12, 2005, 09:03:15 AM
Something I noticed about the rythm guitar style playing/ it sounds as "dirty" and raw as Appetite. I was listening to "My michelle", then I put I.R.S, and I noticed the rythmic section's style is quite similar: Both raw, aggressive, "dirty" and groovy, melodious. I also noticed guitar parts along vocal parts, when the guitar follow and does the same note as Axl's vocals, it's really cool.

There is an Appetite vibe on IRS. Can't wait to hear the studio version.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: jameslofton29 on August 12, 2005, 09:41:46 AM
nesquick, cool review of IRS. I'll have to take another listen to see if I notice that. Everytime I hear it, I'm concentrating on the insane lyrics.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: nesquick on August 12, 2005, 09:45:02 AM
Well I'm a non-english native language person so I don't really understand the lyrics, i don't pay attention to them, I just listen to the melody and the vocal lines.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on August 12, 2005, 10:54:39 AM

Updated




Gonna call the President
Gonna call in the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

0:11
There?s not anymore that I can do
All the legions said to me
I?ll follow you
When you plead the fifth, that?d be anytime it?s true (the end of time, its true)

0:27
Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last time should have gone???
All the rumors I can tell,
Something?s didn't work so well

0:37

Well anyway, it feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the luck gettin out of the wreck (debt)
A fact that you've got to hear worst yet
When I need another favorite I take
It means you might have been caught anyway
Can?t believe that I was out there at all***
Couldn?t see it coming all along

1:05
Well it?s true...ooh...I am,

Forgotten yeah***
Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a Private Eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

1:24
Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna win and I?ll get outta your face
Readmitted with your morning anew***
With Police, hang over, and their headlines true now***
[Finck Solo]




1:55
I've been too sure to offer my help,
I set it up again dressed as somebody else
If I?m stumbling along the wall (road)***
Feel like I'll never get ya out of this song
Well I'm just too sad to kill
Maybe like I just walked in my skin
They'll be waiting on me I know
Like a broken record for so long



2:17
What can I do?
Ooh, oh.
I'm Gonna call the President,
I'm gonna call a private Eye
Gonna get the IRS,
Gonna get myself the FBI.
 
2:33
ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime you now it's true (it too)
       
[Bucket solo]

3:10
Gonna call the president
Gonna make myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

3:20
Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna win and I?ll get outta your face
Readmitted with your morning anew***
With Police, hang over, and their headlines true
3:32
There's not anymore that I can do


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Buddha_Master on August 12, 2005, 05:16:49 PM
I love this track. This track is a bad mother. Hard fucking attitude with some fucking substance. Makes me fucking hurt bad for this shit.

...and speaking of substance...


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Captain Obvious on August 13, 2005, 12:02:35 AM
this song is yum


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Billo on August 13, 2005, 07:12:46 AM
What i think are the correct lyrics in CAPS?? Tell me if u agree..
0:27
Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last time should have KNOWN
All the rumors I can tell,
Something?s didn't work so well

0:37

Well anyway, it feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the luck gettin out of THIS WRECK
A fact that you've got to hear worst yet
When I need another favorite I take
It means youR LIFE WILL BE GONE ANYWAY
Can?t believe that I was out there at all***
Couldn?t see it coming all along

1:05
Well it?s true...ooh...I am,

BUT DONT FORGET OOH OOH
Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a Private Eye
Gonna need the IRS

1:24
Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna win and I?ll get outta your face
REARRANGE IT WHEN YOUR MORNING IS NOON
AND THE POLICE HANG TOGETHER , AND THEIR HEADLINES TRUE NOW
[Finck Solo]

1:55
I've been too sure to offer my help,
I set it up again dressed as somebody else
FEEL LIKE stumbling along the ROAD
Feel like I'll never get ya out of this song
Well I'm just too sad to kill
Maybe like I just walked in my SHIT??
They'll be waiting on me I know
Like a broken record for so long


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: axlsalinger on August 13, 2005, 11:20:13 PM
Dave, a couple of suggestions ... and DAMN, I want to hear a studio version of these songs!

I would probably go with this:

"When you plead the fifth, that?d be THE END OF TIME, IT'S TRUE"

I am sure about this one:

"Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last, I SHOULD HAVE KNOWN"

I think this is:

"When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
TOOK ALL I HAD gettin out of this wreck
 IN FACT YOU HAVEN'T HEARD THE WORST YET
WOMAN YOU NEVER SAID THAT I (garbled)
IT MEANS YOU'RE NOT COMING HOME ANYWAY
Can?t believe that I was out there SO LONG
Couldn?t see it coming all along"

Not 100% sure about this one:

1:05
"Well it?s true, oh ... I HAVE FORGOTTEN YOU"

I think this is right:

"Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna win and I?ll get outta your face
REACQUAINTED WITH YOUR MORNING NEWS
A POLICE hangover, and THE headlines true now"

A couple more:

"If I?m stumbling along the wall
Feels like I'LL NEVER GET OUT OF THIS SONG"

"If I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime, YOU KNOW IT'S TRUE"



Title: I ummm...just had another real moment with IRS
Post by: Buddha_Master on August 28, 2005, 03:10:13 AM
I had a moment with IRS just now. I am pretty sure I have had this a couple times with this song before.

...waasn't looking at anything but this tripped out visualizer that is in sync with the song playing, and I put IRS on...and was just chilling. Shit is cool right now.

but fuck. something crazy. I think this is in my top few favorite GNR tracks. The whole catalog. I love that shit...all of it. But I can't think of another song that is cooler to me right now. IRS is owning my soul. It is kicking my ass hard, and I get all caught up in it. IRS is damn cool. All rock music for the last 15+ years sucks IRS's Dick. For real. I think this even laughs at most of what GNR has ever done too.

Yea I am saying it.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: spacebrain5000 on August 28, 2005, 10:35:40 AM
i also love IRS. it's shit banging brain jammin' shit   : ok:  : ok:
i can't fucking wait for the album to come out, i love madagascar, the blues, and irs. i don't even care what else is on the album, as long as there's those three it will rock.
as to whether it's better than the old catalogue is hard to say, for some reason it's totally different shit, it actually sounds modern in some aspects, and it doesn't suck. Au contraire. It's fucking jammin'. i will say i like axl singing over buckethead's solos just as much (if not more) than him singing over slash's. too damn bad all this leaving shit. hopefully robin or whoever can step up
and they can make some fucking beautiful music  :peace:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on August 28, 2005, 10:57:11 AM
dont forget we still havnt even heard the intro to the song...

also am i the only 1 who hears background vocals in parts of the song. like a female singer???


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Nytunz on August 28, 2005, 12:18:50 PM
te song is damn great! But i want quality sound!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Axl4Prez2004 on August 28, 2005, 04:55:48 PM
dont forget we still havnt even heard the intro to the song...

also am i the only 1 who hears background vocals in parts of the song. like a female singer???

Younggunner,
  Any particular part?  I'm having trouble picking that up...do you mean around 2:00 to 2:18?  Please let me know where you're hearing it.  I think it may be a little echo, or another guitar...
-Axl4prez2004  :beer:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on August 28, 2005, 06:48:47 PM
Quote
Younggunner,
  Any particular part?  I'm having trouble picking that up...do you mean around 2:00 to 2:18?  Please let me know where you're hearing it.  I think it may be a little echo, or another guitar...
Take a close listen at the 156 - 215 and then 259- 308 during the bucket solo i hear girls signing the chorus of the song very faintly.
 Im almost positive i Hear women background vocals during th ebucket solo and pretty sure during the 156-215 but not sure....but almost positive during th ebucket solo


I can def hear it otherwise im goin nuts. listen very carefully


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Axl4Prez2004 on August 28, 2005, 11:55:53 PM
Younggunner,

  I've tried several times, but I can't make out any other voices.  You're hearing voices, another person's seeing images (on 18th century art no less), others are seeing riddles...this wait is driving us all insane! 

 :beer:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: nesquick on August 29, 2005, 08:55:36 AM
I do think it's one of the "four Appetite rocker type song" of the album.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: inho on August 29, 2005, 02:54:23 PM
I do think it's one of the "four Appetite rocker type song" of the album.
I hope so becuase the song is the business! : ok:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dust N Rose on August 30, 2005, 05:37:52 PM
I think the whole Chinese Democracy will be great but there are times I'm thinking: Axl puts the best in Chinese Democracy and there might be 10 leftovers, (great songs as well)that we'll never find out about.

Let's see, perhaps the 4 rockers are: Chinese Democracy, I.R.S. and This I love (Axl said in an interview that this is the heaviest song he ever written though it's still a ballad or a really power ballad perhaps  :confused:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: shaun on August 31, 2005, 11:45:33 AM
When i first listned to IRS, i did quite like it. Now i think it's great!. Can't wait to hear the proper clear version  : ok:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Buddha_Master on August 31, 2005, 11:53:36 AM
you and me both brother.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on August 31, 2005, 01:14:47 PM
I think the whole Chinese Democracy will be great but there are times I'm thinking: Axl puts the best in Chinese Democracy and there might be 10 leftovers, (great songs as well)that we'll never find out about.

Let's see, perhaps the 4 rockers are: Chinese Democracy, I.R.S. and This I love (Axl said in an interview that this is the heaviest song he ever written though it's still a ballad or a really power ballad perhaps? :confused:


Three of the rockers are IRS, CD and prositute. The other has not been named yet.

Just think CD would be like an album full of Comas, estrangeds, nov rains, breakdowns, locomotives etc etc.



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dust N Rose on August 31, 2005, 07:37:51 PM
I think the whole Chinese Democracy will be great but there are times I'm thinking: Axl puts the best in Chinese Democracy and there might be 10 leftovers, (great songs as well)that we'll never find out about.

Let's see, perhaps the 4 rockers are: Chinese Democracy, I.R.S. and This I love (Axl said in an interview that this is the heaviest song he ever written though it's still a ballad or a really power ballad perhaps? :confused:


Three of the rockers are IRS, CD and prositute. The other has not been named yet.

Just think CD would be like an album full of Comas, estrangeds, nov rains, breakdowns, locomotives etc etc.



according to Sp1at? Gimme a break...


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on August 31, 2005, 08:53:41 PM
I think the whole Chinese Democracy will be great but there are times I'm thinking: Axl puts the best in Chinese Democracy and there might be 10 leftovers, (great songs as well)that we'll never find out about.

Let's see, perhaps the 4 rockers are: Chinese Democracy, I.R.S. and This I love (Axl said in an interview that this is the heaviest song he ever written though it's still a ballad or a really power ballad perhaps? :confused:


Three of the rockers are IRS, CD and prositute. The other has not been named yet.

Just think CD would be like an album full of Comas, estrangeds, nov rains, breakdowns, locomotives etc etc.



according to Sp1at? Gimme a break...

Splat didnt say this that guys blog did who talked to Merk. He said there were 4 rockers. So what three rockes have we heard so far? We have heard, CD and IRS, Prostitute was talked about by bucketmaster and he said it was a rocker. So where did spat come from? I didnt mention their name.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: jimmythegent on August 31, 2005, 11:10:09 PM
I think the whole Chinese Democracy will be great but there are times I'm thinking: Axl puts the best in Chinese Democracy and there might be 10 leftovers, (great songs as well)that we'll never find out about.

Let's see, perhaps the 4 rockers are: Chinese Democracy, I.R.S. and This I love (Axl said in an interview that this is the heaviest song he ever written though it's still a ballad or a really power ballad perhaps? :confused:


Three of the rockers are IRS, CD and prositute. The other has not been named yet.

Just think CD would be like an album full of Comas, estrangeds, nov rains, breakdowns, locomotives etc etc.



according to Sp1at? Gimme a break...

Splat didnt say this that guys blog did who talked to Merk. He said there were 4 rockers. So what three rockes have we heard so far? We have heard, CD and IRS, Prostitute was talked about by bucketmaster and he said it was a rocker. So where did spat come from? I didnt mention their name.

Ive defended sp1at on occasion on this board. I think ive changed my opinion of them now though
some of the rumours circulating there nothing short of pathetic


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on September 01, 2005, 12:21:50 AM
Like I said splat never said this. I got the 4 rockers from that picture guys blog.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Sillything on September 20, 2005, 04:05:17 PM
"I?m just too sad to kill " What does he mean? He is too sad to kill someone or is he too sad to be killed?

Oh and I want to thank htgt for providing the service of distributing the demo


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on September 20, 2005, 06:35:09 PM
"I?m just too sad to kill " What does he mean? He is too sad to kill someone or is he too sad to be killed?

Oh and I want to thank htgt for providing the service of distributing the demo

After hearing it in the car the other day, i now think its "im just too sad to give" not kill.

After a few tweaks
Gonna call the President
Gonna call in the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

0:11
There?s not anymore that I can do
All the legions said to me
I?ll follow you
When you plead the fifth, in the end the charge is true (thanks dark you rock)

0:27
Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last time I should have known
All the rumors I can tell,
Something?s didn't work so well

0:37

Well anyway, it feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the luck gettin out of the wreck (debt)
A fact that you've got to hear worst yet
When I need another favor I make
It means you might have been gone anyway
Can?t believe that I was out there at all***
Couldn?t see it coming all along

1:05
Well it?s true...ooh...I had forgotten, yeah

Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a Private Eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

1:24
Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna win if get outta your face
Read a minute with your morning anew***
With Police, hang over, and their headlines true now***
[Finck Solo]




1:55
I've been too sure to offer my help,
Shouldn?t have to hear it from somebody else
If I?m stumbling along the wall (road)***
Feel like I'll never get ya out of this song
Well I'm just too sad to give
Maybe like I just walked in my skin
They'll be waiting on me I know
Like a broken record for so long



2:17
What can I do?
Ooh, oh.
I'm Gonna call the President,
I'm gonna call a private Eye
Gonna get the IRS,
Gonna get myself the FBI.
 
2:33
ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime you now it's true (it too)
       
[Bucket solo]

3:10
Gonna call the president
Gonna make myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

3:20
Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna win and if I get outta your face
Read a minute with your morning anew***
With Police, hang over, and their headlines true
3:32
There's not anymore that I can do


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: darknemus on September 20, 2005, 06:54:18 PM
Dave,

I'm almost positive its "When you plead the fifth and in the end the charge is true"

-darknemus


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on September 20, 2005, 07:05:50 PM
i think its ..."when u plead the fifth that will be the end of time if its true."



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Civil Attitude on September 20, 2005, 07:13:32 PM
...OMG..i just finally got to hear the song for the first time....im gonna admit ive been drifting further and further away from caring weather or not this fuckin monster comes out from under neath its  bed...but after hearing this demo....it kinda stoked the fire back up for me....ive honestly kinda rekindled a sort of hope for this fuckin dream to come true...please dear god i dont ask  4 much, but just make that lil red headed fucker release this damn thing!!!!! :yes: :peace: :beer:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on September 20, 2005, 08:20:12 PM
i think its ..."when u plead the fifth that will be the end of time if its true."


If it is that does not make any sense.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on September 20, 2005, 08:21:02 PM
Dave,

I'm almost positive its "When you plead the fifth and in the end the charge is true"

-darknemus


Ohh I like that. Ill fix it now


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: darknemus on September 20, 2005, 08:56:39 PM
Dave, it could also be "And in the end the charges true" - which doesn't really make much sense, sentence wise - unless you view it more as a poem and less as a declarative statement.

I'm just pretty damn certain I'm hearing 'charge is (or charges) true.

-darknemus


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: jimmythegent on September 20, 2005, 09:06:55 PM
Dave, it could also be "And in the end the charges true" - which doesn't really make much sense, sentence wise - unless you view it more as a poem and less as a declarative statement.

I'm just pretty damn certain I'm hearing 'charge is (or charges) true.

-darknemus


Perhaps your copy is clearer huh?  ;)


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: darknemus on September 20, 2005, 09:09:01 PM
Perhaps  ;)

-darknemus


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: GnR-NOW on September 20, 2005, 09:10:38 PM
does anyone think IRS has a similar rhythm to coma


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: AxlsMainMan on September 20, 2005, 09:26:27 PM
Dave, it could also be "And in the end the charges true" - which doesn't really make much sense, sentence wise - unless you view it more as a poem and less as a declarative statement.

I'm just pretty damn certain I'm hearing 'charge is (or charges) true.

-darknemus


I agree with that lyrical interpretation, it sounds almost spot on, or how about "in the end, the change is true"/"in the end you know its true"? I do view the verses more as poetic stanzas than just song lyrics, while the chorus is an all out outcry.

does anyone think IRS has a similar rhythm to coma

Not quite Coma-esque, but I definately picked up a "Ramble On" vibe from this song..first Axl borrowing the Stairway bassline for Madagascar, and now IRS..I definately am seeing how this record could be contrasted as Zeppelin-esque like Brain has mentioned before.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on September 20, 2005, 11:17:18 PM
Quote
If it is that does not make any sense.
Actually I think it does because hes saying if choose not to talk{pleading the 5th} then that will be the end of that relationship or whatver{that will be the end of time} because by u not talking is indirectly confessing

when u plead the 5th, that'll be the end of time, its true or if its true

Quote
I definately am seeing how this record could be contrasted as Zeppelin-esque like Brain has mentioned before.
Yes Madagascar and IRS both have Zep vibes. Theres nothing I need to ehar from this band anymore. No more "proving". If Cd has songs as good or better than the songs we have heard, they have knocked it out of the dam park.
IRS has proved this band can come up with a catchy rocker. Love the tempo changes and Axls vibe. Great song.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on September 20, 2005, 11:36:29 PM
Dave, it could also be "And in the end the charges true" - which doesn't really make much sense, sentence wise - unless you view it more as a poem and less as a declarative statement.

I'm just pretty damn certain I'm hearing 'charge is (or charges) true.

-darknemus


I think its


When you plead the fifth, in the end the charge is true


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on September 20, 2005, 11:38:30 PM
Quote
If it is that does not make any sense.
Actually I think it does because hes saying if choose not to talk{pleading the 5th} then that will be the end of that relationship or whatver{that will be the end of time} because by u not talking is indirectly confessing

when u plead the 5th, that'll be the end of time, its true or if its true

Quote
I definately am seeing how this record could be contrasted as Zeppelin-esque like Brain has mentioned before.
Yes Madagascar and IRS both have Zep vibes. Theres nothing I need to ehar from this band anymore. No more "proving". If Cd has songs as good or better than the songs we have heard, they have knocked it out of the dam park.
IRS has proved this band can come up with a catchy rocker. Love the tempo changes and Axls vibe. Great song.

End of time does not make sense in the song or lyric. Why would pleading the fifth mean the end of time? Anytime its true or in the end the charge is true makes sense.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on September 20, 2005, 11:49:45 PM
Quote
Why would pleading the fifth mean the end of time?
makes plenty of sense

hes saying by you not talking your implying that its true....therefore hes done with u..end of time


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on September 20, 2005, 11:51:08 PM
Quote
Why would pleading the fifth mean the end of time?
makes plenty of sense

hes saying by you not talking your implying that its true....therefore hes done with u..end of time

Axl does not write like that. I am not even going to argue the lryic since this thread is not about lyrics but the end of time its true is wrong.? It doesnt even make sense as a metaphore. It could be in the end? you'll find its true.
That makes sense and sounds like what? you think it is. Actually now that I listen again, it just me be that.



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on September 21, 2005, 12:26:51 AM
i still think he says time in there....too hard to tell


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: appetite_for_paul on September 21, 2005, 12:41:12 AM
"But when you plead the fifth it'll be the end, the charge is true"

makes sense really


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Sillything on September 21, 2005, 03:20:09 PM
 What if it's like this?: "When you plead the fifth, that?d be the end of time it?s true "
If it's like an irony meaning when you choose to shut up it will be the end of time before that happens? It's about someone who can't stop talkin shit? Considering what's come next in the story abour all the rumours gone wrong


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on September 21, 2005, 03:53:06 PM
"When you plead the fifth, that?d be the end of time it?s true "

you know what? we've been trying to figure out this fucking line for 6 months.

we ain't gonna get it till we see the lyrics booklet.

one thing is for sure.? the line above doesn't make sense

here's what i can make out of it

gonna call the president
gonna call that private eye
gonna get the IRS
gonna need the FBI

There's not anymore that I can do
With all the legions that tell me "I'll follow you"
?So when you see the pictures and the advertisements too?
or
?will you be the victims and the agonizers too?
or
?will you be the buisiness and the advertisers too??
or
?When you plead to bitches and the advertisers too?
or
?Will you be a witness and the prosecuter too?
or
?when you're cleared of business and the end of time is due?
or
?So when you 'blah blu-blah bluh bla-blah" and the "blah bu-bla-bu-blue"?

personally i think the last one is the right one? :hihi:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on September 21, 2005, 04:20:12 PM
I really think "when you plead the 5th, that'll be the end of time it's true..or {if its true.}" makes the most sense


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on September 21, 2005, 04:24:26 PM
I really think "when you plead the 5th, that'll be the end of time it's true..or {if its true.}" makes the most sense

i refuse to agree younggunner, to me, what everyone says is 5th is clearly a 2-syllable word.

but, like i said before i don't think we'll get it right 'til the lyrics are published in the CD booklet, or until we get a better version of the song.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Sillything on September 21, 2005, 04:25:20 PM
"When you plead the fifth, that?d be the end of time it?s true "


or
?So when you 'blah blu-blah bluh bla-blah" and the "blah bu-bla-bu-blue"?

personally i think the last one is the right one? :hihi:


Fuck!!! That's some deep shit!! Far out duuude :hihi:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: ppbebe on September 21, 2005, 04:41:41 PM
I really think "when you plead the 5th, that'll be the end of time it's true..or {if its true.}" makes the most sense
Me too am keep hearing a diphthong of "ai" as in time, life, dime or such there.
I can't catch the word "charge".

at first I thought it was
"But when you plead the fifth And in the end it's like the truth".(meaning = note that silence gives consent)
Then "And to the end of time it's True"
Or     "And that'll be the end of the line, as if it's true" :confused:

Quote
?So when you 'blah blu-blah bluh bla-blah" and the "blah bu-bla-bu-blue"?

 :hihi: getting warmer!!!!

Yeah,
I'm not even sure about that "I follow you" line.
With the noises and such, the words are too hard to catch.
Dave's work is amazing, considering.. :yes:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: darknemus on September 21, 2005, 04:49:34 PM
5th isn't a two syllable word, its actually two separate words. 

'So when you plead the fifth AND in the end the charge is (or charges) true'
 
It wouldn't be the first time I've been wrong (as in, I believed you, I'm an idiot)

But it'll be the last I'm sure I'm gone

And all the movers I can tell, some things didn't go so well.

That kind of makes sense.. come to think of it.

-darknemus





Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on September 21, 2005, 04:56:45 PM
5th isn't a two syllable word, its actually two separate words.?

'So when you plead the fifth AND in the end the charge is (or charges) true'
?
It wouldn't be the first time I've been wrong (as in, I believed you, I'm an idiot)

But it'll be the last I'm sure I'm gone

And all the movers I can tell, some things didn't go so well.

That kind of makes sense.. come to think of it.

-darknemus





I know fifth isn't 2 syllables whatever... i really don't want to argue about it any more it's pointless. Fifth has been there so long i think people just want to believe that's what Axl says

As for the next part, I'd bet money on these lyrics

"It wouldn't be the first time I've been wrong"
"It wouldn't be the last, I'm sure, I've found"
"With all the rumors, I can tell, some things didn't work so well"


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: darknemus on September 21, 2005, 04:59:16 PM
Here's to hoping a cleaner version shows up somewhere soon so that we can find other things to debate about :)   :beer:

And by soon, I mean the real meaning of the word ;)

-darknemus


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on September 21, 2005, 05:33:25 PM
do you have more info on that fron darknemus?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on September 21, 2005, 06:01:39 PM
Quote
Fifth has been there so long i think people just want to believe that's what Axl says

he is clearly saying 5th.

Quote
5th isn't a two syllable word, its actually two separate words. 

'So when you plead the fifth AND in the end the charge is (or charges) true'
 
It wouldn't be the first time I've been wrong (as in, I believed you, I'm an idiot)

But it'll be the last I'm sure I'm gone

And all the movers I can tell, some things didn't go so well.

That kind of makes sense.. come to think of it.

thats basically my interpretation


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: darknemus on September 21, 2005, 06:17:27 PM
do you have more info on that fron darknemus?
On a better quality version of the song showing up somewhere? Not at the moment.. but the situation is.. fluid.  If it does somehow show up, don't worry, it will show up for everyone.  No hoarding will take place - at least, not by me.

-darknemus


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on September 21, 2005, 06:50:35 PM
do you have more info on that fron darknemus?
On a better quality version of the song showing up somewhere? Not at the moment.. but the situation is.. fluid.? If it does somehow show up, don't worry, it will show up for everyone.? No hoarding will take place - at least, not by me.

-darknemus


I doubt I'll get it before you, but I won't hoard it either  :beer:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on September 21, 2005, 07:29:23 PM
When you plead the fifth, in the end you?ll find it?s true

That makes the most sense and fits.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on September 21, 2005, 07:39:54 PM
When you plead the fifth, in the end you?ll find it?s true

That makes the most sense and fits.

that's it Dave!!! : ok:, i really think you found the last part of that line,

How 'bout this?

There's not anymore that i can do
all the legions, they tell me, "I'll Follow You"
Then you'll be the victim,
in the end, you'll find it's true

Wouldn't be the first time I've been wrong
it wouldn't be the last, I'm sure, I've found
With all the rumors i can tell
somethings didn't work so well

to me that sounds like it's getting closer. I can't be sure i don't have the song on this computer


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on September 21, 2005, 08:07:08 PM
Quote
Then you'll be the victim,
its .."when you plead the 5th"

as for daves addition. It might work...its either that or mine.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: appetite_for_paul on September 22, 2005, 04:53:57 AM
Gonna call the President
Gonna call in the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the F.B.I

There's not anymore that i can do...

All belligerence at the gate, i'll follow you
But when you plead the fifth it'll be the end, the charge is true

Wouldn't be the first time i've been down
Wouldn't be the last, i'm sure im gone

All the rumours!
i can tell some things didn't work so well


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Buddha_Master on September 22, 2005, 11:58:08 AM
Fuck this shit rules.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on September 22, 2005, 12:15:14 PM

so i think we have that first part nailed down...

Gonna call the President
Gonna call? the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the F.B.I

There's not anymore that i can do...

All the legions/religions, I'll follow you
But when you plead the fifth it'll be the end, the charge is true

Wouldn't be the first time i've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last, I should have known
All the rumours, I can tell
Some things didn't work so well or So I did it myself
And you wonder why I feel you can take me
---cant really make out what he says before "you can take me"


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on September 22, 2005, 02:07:48 PM
Gonna call the President
Gonna call in the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

There?s not anymore that I can do
All the legions said to me
I?ll follow you
When you plead the fifth, in the end you?ll find it?s true


Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last time I should have known
All the rumors I can tell,
Something?s didn't work so well
Well anyway, it feels the same



YG that is what the first part is.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: ppbebe on September 22, 2005, 04:20:56 PM
Could be Dave's is the closest.

We don't necessarily need to settle on one version for the ultimate yet, do we?
Till we hear cleaner one or better yet, from the author himself,
Everyone is free to show their own comprehension.

I can't say what but I still hear little differently here and there.?.

the last line of the part doesn't sound to me exactly like either
"Well anyway, it feels the same"
or
"And you wonder why I feel you can take me"


But somewhere in between.



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on September 22, 2005, 04:28:04 PM
Could be Dave's is the closest but

We don't necessarily need to settle on one version for the ultimate yet, do we?
Till we hear cleaner one or better yet, from the author himself,
Everyone is free to show their own comprehension.

I can't say what but I still hear little differently here and there.?.

the last line of the part doesn't sound to me exactly like either
"Well anyway, it feels the same"
or
"And you wonder why I feel you can take me"

But somewhere in between.



It wont matter when CD drops because he may have changed the lyrics.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: ppbebe on September 22, 2005, 04:42:23 PM
Well, Either way I like to see various interpretations for now. :peace:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: ppbebe on September 22, 2005, 05:22:18 PM
"All the rumors I can tell,
Something didn't work so well"

tried hard this bit can't be heard otherwise by me either. :P
But who knows.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: nesquick on September 29, 2005, 05:53:46 PM
Just to add I found an IRS clean version on free download on the internet. I won't give the website, but it exists. This is not a GN'R website. This is the version we all have, but with a cleaner sound. 256 kbps. It fucking rocks? 8)

EDIT: I start to receive PM's. Guys, there's nothing revolutionary, it's just a cleaner version, but i repeat it it's the same exact version, 3.41 mn. So Stop PM me.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Skeletor on September 29, 2005, 06:55:11 PM
First you brag about how much it rocks, and then it's suddenly "nothing revolutionary".. gimme a break. That's not the point whether it's something new, of course people want the best possible version. Get it?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Voodoochild on September 29, 2005, 07:01:11 PM
Is this version that Bloody Roses remix?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: DunkinDave on September 29, 2005, 10:07:25 PM
The "Bloody Roses Masters" isn't anything more than the original 128 kbs track upsampled with increased volume. It sounds awful, really.

And the echo at the end made me? :hihi:.

I did my own remaster of the 128 kbs track that's superior to anything else available - not sure if I can post it here, though.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on September 29, 2005, 11:25:46 PM
The "Bloody Roses Masters" isn't anything more than the original 128 kbs track upsampled with increased volume. It sounds awful, really.

And the echo at the end made me? :hihi:.

I did my own remaster of the 128 kbs track that's superior to anything else available - not sure if I can post it here, though.

He did not uptempo anything and he didnt increase the volume. All he did was take the track, take out some hissing and put the music in both speakers since the leaked version only played from one speaker.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: DunkinDave on September 29, 2005, 11:36:21 PM
The "Bloody Roses Masters" isn't anything more than the original 128 kbs track upsampled with increased volume. It sounds awful, really.

And the echo at the end made me? :hihi:.

I did my own remaster of the 128 kbs track that's superior to anything else available - not sure if I can post it here, though.

He did not uptempo anything and he didnt increase the volume. All he did was take the track, take out some hissing and put the music in both speakers since the leaked version only played from one speaker.

Not uptempo, upsample - it's when you save something in a higher bitrate.

The original MP3 had a bitrate of 128 kbs and the Bloody Roses Master was 256 kbs for no apparent reason. The only time you should save a file you worked on in a higher bitrate is to preserve quality after messing with the EQ.

The Bloody Roses Master is laughably bad because all the guy did was run it through some filters (that he didn't use properly) and increase the volume.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on September 30, 2005, 12:21:08 AM
The "Bloody Roses Masters" isn't anything more than the original 128 kbs track upsampled with increased volume. It sounds awful, really.

And the echo at the end made me? :hihi:.

I did my own remaster of the 128 kbs track that's superior to anything else available - not sure if I can post it here, though.

He did not uptempo anything and he didnt increase the volume. All he did was take the track, take out some hissing and put the music in both speakers since the leaked version only played from one speaker.

Not uptempo, upsample - it's when you save something in a higher bitrate.

The original MP3 had a bitrate of 128 kbs and the Bloody Roses Master was 256 kbs for no apparent reason. The only time you should save a file you worked on in a higher bitrate is to preserve quality after messing with the EQ.

The Bloody Roses Master is laughably bad because all the guy did was run it through some filters (that he didn't use properly) and increase the volume.

so u can PM me ur version then please


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: nesquick on September 30, 2005, 04:12:01 AM
Yes it's the bloody roses version. Well, it sounds better than the one I have. You might know the version or maybe you have a better one. Everybody seems to have a different version of the song (I mean with a different sound). However there is a little too much echo. That's why I said "nothing revolutionary", it's the same exact version, it's just it's a cleaner one compared to the one I had before. But maybe you have even a cleaner one I don't know.
The version is on free download on the internet however. That what surprises me.


Title: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Thorned Rose on February 16, 2006, 02:06:05 AM
Well it's good to hear Gn'R. We know there actually are songs. I wouldn't mind hearing a demo or studio version of Madagascar... etc...

This is probably the version we'll hear on CD.

PEace and Love to all... I like it. I think it's equivleant to "It's So Easy" or "My Michelle" it isn't no "Paradise City" or "November Rain" or "YCBM" but it's something like "My Michelle" as far as how good it is.

I do like it, and it is a good song.

I give it a 7.5/10 and I'm a strict rater!!!!!


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Genesis on February 16, 2006, 02:08:53 AM
I think it's equivleant to "It's So Easy"

Sorry, doesn't even come close to that classic.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Midnight Gunner on February 16, 2006, 02:39:42 AM
I think all the new stuff I've heard blows the old stuff away by miles...IRS and even the short clip of "Better" blows nearly half of Use Your Illusion II away...and that's cause most of that album was filler besides "Civil War, Yesterdays, YCBM, KOHD, and Estranged.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Eclipsed107 on February 16, 2006, 02:43:00 AM
wow, it's pretty hard to say. ?I mean it's really good, but it's hard to say how good it is..

It's like, to fully know how good it is I'm going to have to hear the album fully because it's hard to take this song and compaire it to the old band. ?It's a new direction and it's competley different.

You can't judge a band on one song.

I know we've heard CD, Maddy, Blues, R&B, SW, and OMG already but none of those were studio...

I'm really liking this song a lot, and it's got my hopes high for C.D., after hearing this I'm positive that I'll love this album, I'm just not sure how much.

My hopes for Gn'R are so much higher than they've been at any point since 2002. ?Wow.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Thorned Rose on February 16, 2006, 02:43:48 AM
I wouldn't say that... IRS is a strong track... somethign that I could see being a single possibly... I don't know that yet. I've listened to it about 9 times straight through. I like it.

It isn't better then some of the older Gn'R songs, but similair to It's So Easy, My Michelle, So Fine, Coma,

The closest song it could be up with is maybe something like "DOn't Cry" or Live and Let Die.

It's good though. I like it!!! Rock on!! I want to hear the "Catcher in the RYe" song


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: jameslofton29 on February 16, 2006, 02:46:36 AM
Its great to actually be able to hear IRS. I didnt listen to the old one very much because it sounded so horrible. I cant wait to share this with friends. I gave the old IRS to this one guy a few months ago, and I told him its kinda rare and hard to find. He called me back about 20 minutes later and said, "Its rare because it sucks". I highly doubt he will have the same opinion now. That old shitty clip should have never been leaked. Thank God none of you guys sent that clip to radio stations. :hihi:


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Flyguy_1ca on February 16, 2006, 02:49:59 AM
Surprisingly, this seems to be going over pretty well over at "The Velvet Rope"...they have a history of trashing GNR at mention.  But virtualy no negative comments towards this song.  We'll see what they say about "Better"....it's an interesting time in GNR land.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Megaguns on February 16, 2006, 03:02:53 AM
I love it, That second solo rules very majorly : ok:


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Spirit on February 16, 2006, 03:04:07 AM
I love the intro! ;D


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Midnight Gunner on February 16, 2006, 03:28:51 AM
I love the intro! ;D

How can ya not?!?


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: JustWckd on February 16, 2006, 03:29:01 AM
This song rocks

I was worried that it would be either two things

1) trying to sound like old GNR

or

2) Techno


Its neither.  Im not going to comapre it to the old GNR cuz its two different bands.....but this song is kick  ass!!!


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: jameslofton29 on February 16, 2006, 03:34:11 AM
.? Im not going to comapre it to the old GNR
I agree. I think any and all comparisons to 'old' GNR need to be thrown out the window. Its like trying to compare De Niro to Pacino. Just no fucking point in doing it.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Thorned Rose on February 16, 2006, 03:34:22 AM
You can compare it. It's the same name, just 4 different people which makes it different, but ti's the same name, and vision... just 11 years from the last active thing from the old band (I'm talking about SFTD in 1995)

ANyways, you can compare them, and I like this band thus far better. I hope they push this album, I'll be there... at midnight, I"ll probably end up buying 2 or 3 copies.

Peace!


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Jizzo on February 16, 2006, 03:38:53 AM
i still havent heard it


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: SLCPUNK on February 16, 2006, 03:48:50 AM
I think all the new stuff I've heard blows the old stuff away by miles...IRS and even the short clip of "Better" blows nearly half of Use Your Illusion II away...and that's cause most of that album was filler besides "Civil War, Yesterdays, YCBM, KOHD, and Estranged.

Oh gawd.........not at all, no way dude.

I must disagree.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: DunkinDave on February 16, 2006, 03:49:40 AM
This is probably the version we'll hear on CD.

Doubtful.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: metallex78 on February 16, 2006, 03:55:42 AM
I think it sounds cool, I don't know if it's a classic, but Axl sounds great and it's more modern rock than anything on AFD or UYI.

Anyway, I like it and I really like the Better clip too, wish I had the full song though!


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Midnight Gunner on February 16, 2006, 03:56:52 AM
I think all the new stuff I've heard blows the old stuff away by miles...IRS and even the short clip of "Better" blows nearly half of Use Your Illusion II away...and that's cause most of that album was filler besides "Civil War, Yesterdays, YCBM, KOHD, and Estranged.

Oh gawd.........not at all, no way dude.

I must disagree.

Now, it will never beat UYI I but II...oh yea, exclduing the songs I mentiond earlier.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: You Gonna Eat That? on February 16, 2006, 04:04:50 AM
I don't really like the first 23 seconds, but once it gets goin... fuck I love it.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: speed-stone on February 16, 2006, 04:06:48 AM
this will, like i have always thought, be more than up to par with the past gnr material :smoking:
like i always say, quality takes time to build : ok:


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: HoldenCaulfield on February 16, 2006, 04:07:25 AM
Back when we heard the first leak, I was so curious as to what the intro would sound like, and I'm pleasantly surprised. Parts of it sound somewhat exotic, flaminco even? When it kicks in, the guitars just sound huge...


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: JustWckd on February 16, 2006, 04:07:43 AM
HOLY SHIT GUYS IM LIKE FREAKING THE FUCK OUT HERE

WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: metallex78 on February 16, 2006, 04:11:27 AM
Back when we heard the first leak, I was so curious as to what the intro would sound like, and I'm pleasantly surprised. Parts of it sound somewhat exotic, flaminco even? When it kicks in, the guitars just sound huge...

Definitely trippy stuff : ok:


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Dead N' Bloated on February 16, 2006, 04:16:20 AM
Is this just the old version cleaned up or is it a new one? It sounds like the old one but a fucking lot better. Its a fuckin awesome song I love it. He sounds like old Axl for most of it but his scream is alot cleaner then it used to be.


 :peace:


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Voodoochild on February 16, 2006, 04:19:06 AM
This is probably the version we'll hear on CD.

Doubtful.
Yeah, this is the demo yet. Just listen to the heavy guitar on the right channel. It stops suddenly when the slow part comes. There's a keyboard on the track, but it's though to hear it. The mix is rough yet.

Is this just the old version cleaned up or is it a new one? It sounds like the old one but a fucking lot better. Its a fuckin awesome song I love it. He sounds like old Axl for most of it but his scream is alot cleaner then it used to be.
It's same version, but this is the master source and that one was just a record of a record of radio broadcast. I'm 100% sure of this.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: SADIS on February 16, 2006, 04:50:18 AM
This is definitly NOT the final version. There are no vocal overdubs......

I love the song but the only thing I dont' like is the "computerized" drums....but I don't like them in general...


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Gaymo, the Hobbit on February 16, 2006, 07:13:18 AM
omfg i have goose bumps

the wait was worth it


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: CAFC Nick on February 16, 2006, 07:17:20 AM
Yeah this is absolutely fantastic news.

Chinese Democracy starts now? Fucking hope so!


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: makane on February 16, 2006, 09:12:54 AM
Really great song, expect the solo was quite a letdown from Guns. No slash no solo  :-\


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: jmapelian on February 16, 2006, 09:23:32 AM
I thought it was the best of the new stuff I've heard.....but comparing it to songs from AFD and UYI is a stretch


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Sakib on February 16, 2006, 09:38:57 AM
i really liked the new I.R.S.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: JohnnyMcGunsFan on February 16, 2006, 09:53:20 AM
I thought it was the best of the new stuff I've heard.....but comparing it to songs from AFD and UYI is a stretch

Yes, it's a cool track but Axl's voice is missing something.  It's a little forced and not very scratchy.  Still, I'll take an album full of music like this any day.  Good stuff, and good to hear that they actually have been doing something all this time.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: VRslash on February 16, 2006, 10:00:47 AM
Just a thought, what if Axl is releaseing this material. these songs might not be on the CD but in my head after 10 years you have to no people are dieing. wouldnt you give them a little treat to keep them interested. thats just what i think. Axl the kind of person that could do somthing about this anyway. i dont think its a leak. but thats just me


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Miggy on February 16, 2006, 10:03:42 AM
I hope this a demo version. ?If it's not I don't understand why Axl needed so much time to make this. ?It's not a bad song, but I'm not blown away by it. ?It's just an average rock-song and I hope the rest of the album will be a lot better.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Thorned Rose on February 16, 2006, 01:49:22 PM
This may be the final version, I wouldn't doubt it. Who else thinks so.

The song is solid.

I love it.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: RichardNixon on February 16, 2006, 01:53:17 PM
Wow, I freakin' love this song. What the hell is Axl doing sittiing on it? Release the fucker! Great, Great song. Axl is Back!


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Progress on February 16, 2006, 02:03:14 PM
I'm not to thrilled about the song..I don't know what it,but it just doesn't do anything for me.
It might grow after a while though..
I really liked Better though!Can't wait to hear the whole song! :beer:
It sounds promising!


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: ARC on February 16, 2006, 02:04:28 PM
I missed all the chaos.

Is Buckethead on this IRS...?


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: colma on February 16, 2006, 02:05:16 PM
yes


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Thorned Rose on February 16, 2006, 02:09:09 PM
I'm working on it man, sending it to you and 2 others now. I'm going to post 1 last link to it. I downloaded it....

Gn'R rules!!!!


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Saul on February 16, 2006, 02:11:53 PM
I'd talk about I.R.S and Better but to my knowledge they dont exist. Figments of our imagination. I have no memory of them and allthough I thought I had them on my PC they dont seem to be there anymore. Scary.  :nervous:



Thank God none of you guys sent that clip to radio stations. :hihi:

Who came up with that silly idea last nite to send IRS to radio stations anyways?  Ohhhhhh , wait....  :confused:


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Wooody on February 16, 2006, 02:21:11 PM
 :peace: :peace: :peace:


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: ppbebe on February 16, 2006, 02:28:07 PM
What is it called...co illusion? ;D

@ thorned No. Seemingly The GNR camp doesn't think so. Myeteron confirmed this before

I think all the new stuff I've heard blows the old stuff away by miles...

Yay 21st century boy! :peace:


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: ARC on February 16, 2006, 02:44:54 PM
well, I just heard both the new leaks. awesome.

better is... better.

can't wait for the album.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Olorin on February 16, 2006, 02:50:04 PM
Dunno, whats with the drum machine? The drums sound really weak.

Its missing something. No more fancy layers or effects, its missing a raw guitar component.
And where the fucks the bass?


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Saul on February 16, 2006, 02:56:03 PM
Dunno, whats with the drum machine? The drums sound really weak.

Its missing something. No more fancy layers or effects, its missing a raw guitar component.
And where the fucks the bass?

Are you listening to it on a good stereo system?


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Olorin on February 16, 2006, 02:58:05 PM
Yeah man, the dogs bollocks


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: killingvector on February 16, 2006, 02:58:41 PM
I'd talk about I.R.S and Better but to my knowledge they dont exist. Figments of our imagination. I have no memory of them and allthough I thought I had them on my PC they dont seem to be there anymore. Scary.  :nervous:



Thank God none of you guys sent that clip to radio stations. :hihi:

Who came up with that silly idea last nite to send IRS to radio stations anyways?  Ohhhhhh , wait....  :confused:

Where these the two songs with vocals that Slash talked about?


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Saul on February 16, 2006, 03:02:10 PM
I'd talk about I.R.S and Better but to my knowledge they dont exist. Figments of our imagination. I have no memory of them and allthough I thought I had them on my PC they dont seem to be there anymore. Scary.  :nervous:



Thank God none of you guys sent that clip to radio stations. :hihi:

Who came up with that silly idea last nite to send IRS to radio stations anyways?  Ohhhhhh , wait....  :confused:

Where these the two songs with vocals that Slash talked about?

Hahaha , you never know man!! Never fucking know!


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: WARose on February 16, 2006, 03:07:44 PM
great song!!!   but i think the final version will blow this away though....  there?s still something missin      it`s the mix i guess

but helll.........   CHINESE DEMOCRACY STARTS NOW!!!


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: killingvector on February 16, 2006, 03:09:07 PM
great song!!!   but i think the final version will blow this away though....  there?s still something missin      it`s the mix i guess

but helll.........   CHINESE DEMOCRACY STARTS NOW!!!

more like

Chinese Democracy idles for a bit then sputters again to a restart !!!


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: RancidPunx on February 16, 2006, 03:17:26 PM
Wow, you mean on this forum we can actually discuss the song/lyrics? We don't have to pretend that this demo does not exist? I think it kicks ass, but as a single? I would have to say no. It would be a strong album track though.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: layne on February 16, 2006, 03:21:47 PM
I think IRS misses rawness...it's too clean and too slow. I expected it was faster and rougher


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: WARose on February 16, 2006, 03:27:52 PM
iff this is an equivalent to dust n`bones we`ll get the best record ever :hihi:

keep in mind that this isn`t in the "top ten".... : ok:


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: nesquick on February 16, 2006, 03:38:53 PM
I think IRS misses rawness...it's too clean and too slow. I expected it was faster and rougher
yeah, should be faster and more "dirty".


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Thorned Rose on February 16, 2006, 03:58:26 PM
I think the song is fine.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Mr.Intensity on February 16, 2006, 03:59:16 PM
I'd like it to be a bit faster.. and a bit more edgy sounding... but I still like it.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Gizmo on February 16, 2006, 04:13:27 PM
good buts needs to be faster!!!!

 :rofl:


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: WARose on February 16, 2006, 04:21:56 PM
i just put it on my mp3 player and listenened to it on headphones..

it blows everything i ever heard away!! : ok:    that way it really sound how it`s supposed to be. TRY IT!!


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Olorin on February 16, 2006, 04:55:37 PM
Yeah, a little faster, more raw and dirty and it would be a bad mutha.

Actually the raw, original clip got me more excited than this clean one. Although it is a demo. Hopefully. They claimed Oh My God was a demo.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Evolution on February 16, 2006, 05:08:17 PM
It's like a classic song, but modern at the same time. Fucking amazing day  ;)


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: The Dog on February 16, 2006, 05:12:14 PM
The intro is sooooooo good....I love how layered this whole song is. 


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Lilljon on February 16, 2006, 05:59:48 PM
I love it... GNR is coming babies!


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Buddha_Master on February 16, 2006, 06:04:57 PM
I hope no one said this before. But after listening to IRS again just now (fuck I have heard this a lot since last night), the intro...it sounds or has traces of, the Garden. Maybe its just me...but that trippy ass sound to it seems familiar. I love it...all of it. Just an observation.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: WARose on February 16, 2006, 06:06:59 PM
yeah it`s similar to the garden in the beginning....  but not too much actually :hihi:


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: mikegiuliana on February 16, 2006, 06:36:16 PM
to me the best part of that song is the solo near the end.. The song itself is OK..


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Communist China on February 16, 2006, 06:48:11 PM
Does Axl just mail you guys music from time to time? Where are these leaks at, me and my other GN'R pals can't seem to find actual pieces of music, just people talking about it.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Saul on February 16, 2006, 07:04:30 PM
both these songs need to be listened to with good headphones. seriously ... theres lil details you wont hear over pc speakers and whatnot.

sweeeet


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: pilferk on February 16, 2006, 07:05:39 PM
Love the song.

Not fond of the mix (which I'm sure isn't final), but the song just rocks.

If there are 10 better songs than this on CD...oh my shit.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: D on February 16, 2006, 07:06:45 PM
A big thing thats gonna hinder Chinese Democracy is people's love for the old shit.

I dont care if Axl has the greatest song ever written, there will be people who refuse to say its better than WTTJ, or PC etc etc etc.

I dont think u can compare songs.

Personally Im so burnt out on Old GNR that I m gonna love anything new better, but as far as an all time ranking, i think thats probably impossible to do that.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Communist China on February 16, 2006, 09:18:36 PM
If you know my posts you know I'm very critical of new GN'R. But I got to admit, I.R.S was really good. If the album has all songs up to that level, with finished studio work, I'm gonna love it. I hope Axl doesn't let us down again.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: BLS-Pride on February 16, 2006, 09:19:27 PM
I'm happy with it.. Worth all this time waiting? No.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: The Dog on February 16, 2006, 09:22:40 PM
A big thing thats gonna hinder Chinese Democracy is people's love for the old shit.

I dont care if Axl has the greatest song ever written, there will be people who refuse to say its better than WTTJ, or PC etc etc etc.

I dont think u can compare songs.

Personally Im so burnt out on Old GNR that I m gonna love anything new better, but as far as an all time ranking, i think thats probably impossible to do that.

I disagree.  Its been over 15 years since a GNR album has come out....anyone still clinging to the idea that CD is goin to be AFD part 2 is a douche.  Correct me if I'm wrong, but nobody compared VR to STP or GNR right? 

The critics will make or break this album if you ask me.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Evolution on February 16, 2006, 09:24:20 PM
The whole way the song just drifts between bluesy solos and Axl spitting out the verses grabs me wholeheartedly.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: WhosGilby? on February 16, 2006, 09:26:31 PM
IRS Sounds pretty sick but I doubt if we see it on Chinese Democracy that will be the version that appears and as cool as IRS is from what I heard better is going to be a better song


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: KIKO2K6 on February 16, 2006, 09:28:24 PM
Just Rocks! love this song  ?amazing  :D

Its just the demo ....


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: jameslofton29 on February 16, 2006, 09:33:39 PM
to me the best part of that song is the solo near the end.. The song itself is OK..
I totally agree. That solo makes the song. Without it, Irs becomes very average/mediocre, or at least average in comparison to the other good new songs.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: misterID on February 16, 2006, 09:44:24 PM
I just heard IRS (thanks to my Bud) I have to say, without being mixed or mastered it sounded amazing. His voice sounds good, though it sounds excellent on Better.

I was a little nervous when I read the lyrics, but he sings it very well. Great chorus. I know its a rough cut but it reminds me a lot of Rush.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: killingvector on February 16, 2006, 09:44:47 PM
The mix isn't the greatest, but given that, IRS is strong and Better is simply breathtaking.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: RitzWalker8 on February 16, 2006, 09:58:20 PM
Where can you hear it?


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Syd Vega on February 16, 2006, 10:14:01 PM
I'm not impressed. Both of the new clips ain't too cool. These are clearly demos, so the final thing may be better, but esp. I.R.S. is not a good song...just imagine you heard a demo of Sweet Child...see the difference?

Thanx to Evo btw !  8)


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: ShotgunBlues1978 on February 16, 2006, 10:15:31 PM
What is the difference between the new version and the old version besides the sound quality?  I haven't heard the new version. 

Is it longer?  Different solos?  What's different from the last one we heard?


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: RitzWalker8 on February 16, 2006, 10:20:33 PM
help!!!!! me!!!!


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Bubba St. Rose on February 16, 2006, 11:03:02 PM
This song is all right but nothing special. The lyrics are subpar, the song construction is kind of jumpy and I'm not that impressed with the buckethead solo. I've been a fan since I was 17 in 1987 and to say this is better than anything on AFD is wrong. It's about as good as the weaker stuff on UYI I and II. Good but it took 15 years for this? The blues is much better. I like the 1:20 of "Better" that I managed to download. This is a much "better" tune than IRS from what i've heard of it. Just my opinion.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: killingvector on February 17, 2006, 12:19:02 AM
The old Slashguard weighing in..... ::)


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: W 23 AXL II on February 17, 2006, 12:25:52 AM
IRS is cool. i dig it.


"Better" is breath-taking. "Better" is perfection for 75 seconds!


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: icpillusions on February 17, 2006, 12:28:34 AM
Didn't hear them either, wish I could hear IRS.  The first leak was amazing.

Probably won't listen to Better. I haven't heard it and rather hear it from the album.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: sergejg on February 17, 2006, 01:03:08 AM
This is exactly the way I wished the new GNR would be. Its like a great mix of diferent music styles and it sounds totally like nothing we have heard before.

My favorite part was when Axl makes that high long pitch while the solo goes on, I can already visualize the whole thing in a live gig, its going to be amazing.

I cant stop listening to these two songs. They are SO AMAZING! I can't wait to hear the final version on the album, I bet its gonna sound very diferet with a lot of new fill riffs and maybe diferent lyrics (the lyrics where in my opinion the weakest part but the sound of the voice is great).


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Minneapolisnewsman on February 17, 2006, 01:06:19 AM
The old Slashguard weighing in..... ::)

One should note, nothing wrong with the Slashguard.? I know many, and they know music.? I think IRS is about Slash!? Ironically, Slash may lay a lick or two down on this one by the time we get the album version.? ?;)  LMFAO, you guy's, confidant's insist we are in for a great ride--soon!!  Slash and Axl--well?


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Axl4Prez2004 on February 17, 2006, 03:23:21 AM
Is it just me, but does the very beginning 0:03 to 0:07 remind you of The Garden off of UYI I? 

Wow, just awesome stuff.  What a great day/night.    :beer:  :beer:  :beer:   :beer: 


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: badapple81 on February 17, 2006, 07:11:20 AM
I actually like IRS over Better at the moment!


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Olorin on February 17, 2006, 09:12:47 AM
Had IRS on my minidisc player when I was at the gym earlier, it really got me going - man I was an animal!!

Thinking about the tempo of the song:

When you listen to the demo's from appetite all of them are slower than the final cut. Jungle sounds weird slow.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: badapple81 on February 17, 2006, 09:15:41 AM
Had IRS on my minidisc player when I was at the gym earlier, it really got me going - man I was an animal!!

Thinking about the tempo of the song:

When you listen to the demo's from appetite all of them are slower than the final cut. Jungle sounds weird slow.

I love the tempo of the song too. This is exactly my kinda rock song. The tempo of The Blues was also slower in 02 than the Vegas and Rio gigs and I much preferred the Vegas/Rio version.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Mr.Intensity on February 17, 2006, 09:27:43 AM
I.R.S is decent... for some reason it just leaves something to be desired... I wish it were a bit more faster.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Lord Kayoss on February 17, 2006, 10:06:11 AM
I must say I didn't care for the song.  I'd like to hear a better version before making any final judgments, but my initial reaction to the demo was *thumbs down*.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Mr.Intensity on February 17, 2006, 10:09:25 AM
What do you think the meaning of the song is...

I think he is talking about calling all those people/organizations before he decides to ever love a woman again...


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: masterdan on February 17, 2006, 10:20:36 AM
IRS is awesome....but "better" is better.  :)


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: mikegiuliana on February 17, 2006, 11:36:58 AM
maybe you have to have special ear phones to hear it perfectly but it does have lots of way to pitchy vocals that kind of blend in way to much, his vocals are powerfull at times but more in the annoying way... (A) on the guitar solo the only bright spot..


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Mr.Intensity on February 17, 2006, 12:25:07 PM
I guess I'm the only one that thinks that solo doesn't fit............but the more I listen to it I hear more cool effects going on in the backround.

Maybe it will keep growing on me.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: rgr1607 on February 17, 2006, 12:32:55 PM
I think I.R.S. is a great rock song. When comparing it to the rock songs from the old band, I only rank it behind Paradise City, You Could Be Mine, and Welcome To The Jungle. That's how good it sounds to me.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: lianne on February 17, 2006, 01:26:36 PM
Oh my god, I have just wasted years of my life waiting for this album. What I have heard so far has failed on every level! I think if Axl just has a 3 min track of him having sex some of u would say it is amazing. To even comapare 'I.R.S.' to 'Its So Easy' is a joke.

People that like Guns but don't visit forums and have been out of touch of current GN'R news will hate this. In my honest opinon this album will bomb and bomb big. I know it is a demo, but listen to the Illision demos they are pretty much the finished product.

I know I will get flamed for my post, but it is just my opinion.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: GNRBABY on February 17, 2006, 01:32:18 PM
The new album is going to kick ass IMO. These songs aren't done yet obviously, but they do sound "complex" as Axl mentioned. I am re-excited about CD now!


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: SLCPUNK on February 17, 2006, 01:34:10 PM
Oh my god, I have just wasted years of my life waiting for this album. What I have heard so far has failed on every level! I think if Axl just has a 3 min track of him having sex some of u would say it is amazing. To even comapare 'I.R.S.' to 'Its So Easy' is a joke.


Funny you say that.

I burned IRS to CD last night and back it up with it's so easy. The two were world's apart. I take into consideration that it is only a demo. But really the new stuff from GnR I have heard I like, but am not floored by. The blues, maddy etc are good, but not at the level of any of the stuff prior.

I will take the album for what it is worth: probably be a good album. If it is great, then that is even better. But I am not holding my breath for a masterpiece. I do agree that Axl could fart in a mic and posters here would go crazy for it though.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: fieldsy on February 17, 2006, 01:35:08 PM
These tracks have whetted my appetite no end.  His voice sounds fucking great.  And I love the guitar on 'Better'


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Mr.Intensity on February 17, 2006, 01:37:59 PM
Oh my god, I have just wasted years of my life waiting for this album. What I have heard so far has failed on every level! I think if Axl just has a 3 min track of him having sex some of u would say it is amazing. To even comapare 'I.R.S.' to 'Its So Easy' is a joke.

People that like Guns but don't visit forums and have been out of touch of current GN'R news will hate this. In my honest opinon this album will bomb and bomb big. I know it is a demo, but listen to the Illision demos they are pretty much the finished product.

I know I will get flamed for my post, but it is just my opinion.

I respect it, but disagree, these new songs are good in my opinion.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: WARose on February 17, 2006, 02:13:54 PM
Oh my god, I have just wasted years of my life waiting for this album. What I have heard so far has failed on every level! I think if Axl just has a 3 min track of him having sex some of u would say it is amazing. To even comapare 'I.R.S.' to 'Its So Easy' is a joke.

People that like Guns but don't visit forums and have been out of touch of current GN'R news will hate this. In my honest opinon this album will bomb and bomb big. I know it is a demo, but listen to the Illision demos they are pretty much the finished product.

I know I will get flamed for my post, but it is just my opinion.

you`re free to stop wasting your life at any time you want to : ok:


i love IRS, but i want a better version....     and i just noticed some keyboards or synthesizers in the mix... sound really cool


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: Lesty on February 17, 2006, 02:21:04 PM
Oh my god, I have just wasted years of my life waiting for this album. What I have heard so far has failed on every level! I think if Axl just has a 3 min track of him having sex some of u would say it is amazing. To even comapare 'I.R.S.' to 'Its So Easy' is a joke.

People that like Guns but don't visit forums and have been out of touch of current GN'R news will hate this. In my honest opinon this album will bomb and bomb big. I know it is a demo, but listen to the Illision demos they are pretty much the finished product.

I know I will get flamed for my post, but it is just my opinion.

I'm not going to flame you. Personally, I think these songs will be "filler" compared to what I expect the rest of the CD to be. These both just seem like good rock songs, nothing extremely memorable. People are going "apeshit" over these, and I think it's mainly because they have been so desperate to hear new GnR music.
I dig the tunes, but will reserve judgement until I hear the complete CD in it's finished form.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on February 22, 2006, 01:58:47 AM
still working on this

Im still working on this


IRS

Love
Is it true
What they say of you(?)

Gonna call the President
Gonna call in the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

There?s not anymore that I can do
All the leeches said to me
I?ll follow you
When you plead the fifth, that be anytime it?s true


Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last time I should have known
All the rumors I can tell,
Something?s didn't work so well



Well anyway, it feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the luck gettin out of the debt
That?s the truth and here?s the worst yet
When I need another favor I make
You?ve mind up your mind at home anyway
Can?t believe that I was out there alone
Couldn?t see it coming all along


Well it?s true...ooh...I had forgotten,
Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a Private Eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI


Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna win and rip it outta your face
Read a minute with your morning news
With a cheap hang over, and their headlines true now
[
Finck Solo]




I've been too sure to offer my help,
Shouldn?t have to hear it from somebody else
If i'm done with all the wrong
Feel like I'll never get ya out of this song
Well I'm just too tired to care
Maybe like I just walked in my shit
They'll be waiting on me I know
Like a broken record for so long




What can I do?
Ooh, oh.
I'm Gonna call the President,
I'm gonna call a private Eye
Gonna get the IRS,
Gonna get myself the FBI.
 

ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime you know it too         
[Bucket solo]




Gonna call the president
Gonna make myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna win and rip it outta your face
Read a minute with your morning news
With a cheap hang over, and their headlines true now

There's not anymore that I can do


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: WARose on February 22, 2006, 02:52:36 AM
i don`t agree with those lyrics........


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on February 22, 2006, 02:39:24 PM
What parts dont you agree with?

Im 99% sure this is right now.

Read a minute with your morning news
With a cheap hang over, and their headlines true now


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Jim on February 22, 2006, 02:46:18 PM
No point quoting the entire post above you, eh eh?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: axe on February 22, 2006, 03:25:05 PM
I don't agree with those lyrics, either. My main and only argument against them is that they just don't make any sense. They're just a bunch of mixed words and lines that sound similar to what Axl is singing. I know it's hard to transcribe a song, and this song particularly, and I appreciate what you people have done, but no, these are only about 50% correct.

I'll add that I don't have any suggestions what the correct lyrics might be in those parts that don't make sense. I just know that those printed can't be right.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Breakdown on February 22, 2006, 03:33:47 PM
I agree...those lyrics make no sense....good try, I know I wouldnt have wasted my time, but if those lyrics are 99 percent correct...then Axl has definitely lost his writing skills.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on February 22, 2006, 03:43:20 PM
I agree...those lyrics make no sense....good try, I know I wouldnt have wasted my time, but if those lyrics are 99 percent correct...then Axl has definitely lost his writing skills.

No I said im 99% sure of the one line i posted. I cant make out a lot of what axl is singing on the demo.
This line "Read a minute with your morning news
With a cheap hang over, and their headlines true now"

The lyrics we have are about 75% correct.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: nonlinear on February 22, 2006, 04:00:40 PM
OK I took a crack at the lyrics, they're not 100% correct (at work and don't have headphones) but they're getting closer.  my changes are in bold:

Love
Is it true
What they say of you(?)

Gonna call the President
Gonna call a Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

There?s not anymore that I can do
All the legions that you give (need, lead?)
I?ll follow you
So when you plead the fifth, that?d be the end of time it?s true


Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last I?m sure I?m on
Through all the rumors I can tell,
Some things didn't work so well



Well anyway, it feels the same

cause when you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here alone
Through all the motions and all of the debt (shit?)
And that?s the truth and here?s the worst yet
when I need another the favorite I pray (inaudible)
You?ve mind up your mind and gone anyway
And there?s no use now, imagine it on
Should?ve seen it coming all along


Well it?s true...ooh...I had forgotten, yea
Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a Private Eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

I?m gonna make this a federal case
Gonna wave it right down in your face
Read a minute with your morning news
With a cheap hang over, and their headlines true now

[Finck Solo]




I bet you think I?m doing this all for my health
I should?ve looked back in then at
somebody else
Feels as like I?ve done way more than wrong
Feeling like I'll never get tired of this sound
Feeling like I'm just too tired to care (give?)
Feeling like I?ve done more than my share
Could?ve been the weight that I?ve carried on

Like a broken record for so long




and I do
Ooh, oh.
I'm Gonna call the President,
Gonna call a private Eye
Gonna get the IRS,
Gonna need myself the FBI.
 

ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime you know it?s true

[Bucket solo]




Gonna call the president
Gonna get myself a private eye
ooh I?m Gonna need the IRS
I?m Gonna get the FBI

I?m
Gonna make it a federal case
I?m Gonna wave it right down in your face
Read a minute with your morning news
With a cheap hang over, and their headlines true

There's not anymore that I can do


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: ppbebe on February 22, 2006, 04:13:18 PM
i don`t agree with those lyrics........

Many parts I hear differently...Polly it's because I'm not used to hearing american english.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: nonlinear on February 22, 2006, 04:44:33 PM
i wish there was a special thread for the lyric of IRS (there's 2 seperate threads for TWAT).  the lyric is harder to hear than TWAT.

would jarmo delete it if I started one ?  ;D


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: jarmo on February 22, 2006, 04:46:13 PM
i wish there was a special thread for the lyric of IRS (there's 2 seperate threads for TWAT).? the lyric is harder to hear than TWAT.

would jarmo delete it if I started one ?? ;D


Yes I would. Why not try the SEARCH for once?

You might find something interesting (http://www.heretodaygonetohell.com/board/index.php?topic=25423.0).




/jarmo


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: nonlinear on February 22, 2006, 04:56:54 PM
yay thanks jarmo

i just saw the lyrics in this post and started thinking about them, I didn't know there was another post about it


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: D on February 22, 2006, 07:40:04 PM
still working on this

Im still working on this


IRS

Love
Is it true
What they say of you(?)

Gonna call the President
Gonna call in the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

There?s not anymore that I can do
All the leeches said to me
I?ll follow you
When you plead the fifth, that be anytime it?s true


Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last time I should have known
All the rumors I can tell,
Something?s didn't work so well



Well anyway, it feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the luck gettin out of the debt
That?s the truth and here?s the worst yet
When I need another favor I make
You?ve mind up your mind at home anyway
Can?t believe that I was out there alone
Couldn?t see it coming all along


Well it?s true...ooh...I had forgotten,
Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a Private Eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI


Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna win and rip it outta your face
Read a minute with your morning news
With a cheap hang over, and their headlines true now
[
Finck Solo]




I've been too sure to offer my help,
Shouldn?t have to hear it from somebody else
If i'm done with all the wrong
Feel like I'll never get ya out of this song
Well I'm just too tired to care
Maybe like I just walked in my shit
They'll be waiting on me I know
Like a broken record for so long




What can I do?
Ooh, oh.
I'm Gonna call the President,
I'm gonna call a private Eye
Gonna get the IRS,
Gonna get myself the FBI.
 

ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime you know it too         
[Bucket solo]




Gonna call the president
Gonna make myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna win and rip it outta your face
Read a minute with your morning news
With a cheap hang over, and their headlines true now

There's not anymore that I can do



Great job Dave, I love this fuckin song so much. its probably  my fav song so far, Madagascar is right up there and so is the Blues.

Im gonna put this on my MP3 player tonight and Ill double check the lyrics from my point of view and give my opinion but they look great Dave! : ok:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: jameslofton29 on February 22, 2006, 10:14:17 PM
I don't agree with those lyrics, either. My main and only argument against them is that they just don't make any sense. .
Dont blame Dave for that. Blame the person that wrote them. :hihi:


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: AxlsMainMan on February 22, 2006, 10:59:21 PM
I wasn't as excited to hear that IRS has leaked as I was Better or TWAT, since this track obviously leaked last year..but after many,many listens I can can it is a gem as far as "rockers" go, and I truly doubt its even one of the "Big Guns" Uncle Axl has in store for us...

The solo is absolutely insane..but like many others, I fear to wonder how poor Robin could even hope of duplicating that live, even with Richard's assistance...

The rhtyhm riff is really catchy in itself, but needs to be more agressive/dominate in my opinion..

Also Axl's vocals really need to be reworked in great length although I can tell even through the quality of this demo, he's gunna have a crazy pitch ala "You're Crazy" : ok:


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: SWINGTRADER on February 22, 2006, 11:45:11 PM
If Axl would stop sounding like a woman on these new tunes  (" better"  was recorded in the early 90's  so that doesn't count)  people would probablyaccept them a little more. One of the main complaints  I have heard is that Axl doesn't have the uniquehard kick ass voice he once had.  They say he sounds like a whiny bitch.   I have somewhat the same opinion ,  listen to the 2002 mp3's  he sounds like wayne newton at times .  A badass rocker  should never sound like this.


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: -Jack- on February 23, 2006, 12:43:37 AM
If Axl would stop sounding like a woman on these new tunes  (" better"  was recorded in the early 90's  so that doesn't count)  people would probablyaccept them a little more. One of the main complaints  I have heard is that Axl doesn't have the uniquehard kick ass voice he once had.  They say he sounds like a whiny bitch.   I have somewhat the same opinion ,  listen to the 2002 mp3's  he sounds like wayne newton at times .  A badass rocker  should never sound like this.

Lol bro.. you really KNOW everything dont you!? You were the in the early 90's when they recorded better right?

 :hihi:


Title: Re: I.R.S. Thoughts
Post by: killingvector on February 23, 2006, 01:18:09 AM
The old Slashguard weighing in..... ::)

One should note, nothing wrong with the Slashguard.  I know many, and they know music.  I think IRS is about Slash!  Ironically, Slash may lay a lick or two down on this one by the time we get the album version.   ;)  LMFAO, you guy's, confidant's insist we are in for a great ride--soon!!  Slash and Axl--well?

I think it is about Slash too. I can hear that now.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: pilferk on March 03, 2006, 08:44:14 AM
Havent seen this mentioned (but will admit I haven't read all 25 pages), but...

Does anyone else think that perhaps IRS is "Oklahoma"?

I know Axl talked about the fact "Oklahoma" was a song he concieved of while disucssing the particulars of his divorce while the Oklahmoa city bombing was going on.

Sure sounds very similar in theme to IRS to me.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: WhatIsItMan on March 04, 2006, 03:20:39 AM
Why would Axl want the IRS?  Wouldn't he rather have the CIA?  He's already asking for the President, a PI, & the FBI.  You would think he would want the CIA in the mix too, huh?  I guess nothing rhymed with CIA.  I was just doing laundry, and started to think about that.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: loser666 on March 04, 2006, 04:35:45 AM
BECAUSE THE I.R.S. ARE THE PEOPLE THAT CAN FUCK YOU BEHIND YOUR BACK. YOU DON'T EVEN KNOW WHAT HAPPENED TO YOU.  IT'S THE SNEAK APPROACH.  MY DAD IS SNEAKY, SO AM I.  IT'S A WAY OF GETTING EVEN WHEN NO ONE KNOWS WHAT HAPPENED TO THEM.  BUILT UP AGGRESSION WILL KILL SOMEONE.  YOU'RE COOL, YOU HAVE MY RESPECT AND LOVE...IT'S ALL ABOUT THE, "FUCK YOU ATTITUDE" 


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Lipfel on March 04, 2006, 04:39:44 AM
Havent seen this mentioned (but will admit I haven't read all 25 pages), but...

Does anyone else think that perhaps IRS is "Oklahoma"?

I know Axl talked about the fact "Oklahoma" was a song he concieved of while disucssing the particulars of his divorce while the Oklahmoa city bombing was going on.

Sure sounds very similar in theme to IRS to me.

No, IRS and Oklahoma were both mentioned in the Rolling Stone Interview


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: KillYourIdols on March 18, 2006, 06:53:58 PM
Here's my interpretation of the lyrics. Mostly changed the middle verse a bit. You guys all did a great job.

-------------------------

Love, is it true?
What they say of you?

Gonna call the President
Gonna call a Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

There?s not anymore that I can do
All the legions that you give
I?ll follow you
So when you plead the fifth that?d be the end of time it?s true

Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last I?m sure I?ve known
Through all the rumors I can tell
Some things didn't work so well

Well anyway it feels the same

Cause when you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here alone
Through all the emotions that I?ll ever felt
And that?s the truth and here?s the worst yet
Would it even matter the things that I say?
You?ve made your mind up and gone anyway
And there?s no use now in draggin? it on
Should?ve seen it coming all along

Well it?s true, I had forgotten, yea
Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a Private Eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

I?m gonna make this a federal case
Gonna wave it right down in your face
Read a minute with your morning news
With a cheap hang over, and their headlines true now

I bet you think I?m doing this all for my health
I should?ve looked back in then at somebody else
Feels as like I?ve done way more than wrong
Feeling like I'll never get tired of this song
Feeling like I'm just too tired to care
Feeling like I?ve done more than my share
Could?ve been the weight that I?ve carried on
Like a broken record for so long

And I do

Ooh, oh.
I'm Gonna call the President,
Gonna call a private Eye
Gonna get the IRS,
Gonna need myself the FBI.
 

Ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime you know it?s true

Gonna call the president
Gonna get myself a private eye
Ooh I?m gonna need the IRS
I?m gonna get the FBI

I?m gonna make it a federal case
I?m gonna wave it right down in your face
Read a minute with your morning news
With a cheap hang over, and their headlines true

It's not anymore that I can do...


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Jim on March 18, 2006, 07:51:04 PM
I bet you think I?m doing this all for my health
I should?ve looked back in then at somebody else
Feels as like I?ve done way more than wrong
Feeling like I'll never get tired of this song
Feeling like I'm just too tired to care
Feeling like I?ve done more than my share
Could?ve been the weight that I?ve carried on
Like a broken record for so long

I don't know who was the first to crack that part, but they did a great fucking job!

My interpretation was pretty much what we had back in the beggining, but that is completly different. Lyricaly, compared to what I thought it was before, it is endlesly better.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: awolgnr on March 19, 2006, 02:20:22 AM
Is this demo old enough to have Paul Tobias on it?  The rhythm guitar doesn't sound fluid enough to be Fortus, unless its designed to be that way...


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: KillYourIdols on March 19, 2006, 12:12:16 PM
I bet you think I?m doing this all for my health
I should?ve looked back in then at somebody else
Feels as like I?ve done way more than wrong
Feeling like I'll never get tired of this song
Feeling like I'm just too tired to care
Feeling like I?ve done more than my share
Could?ve been the weight that I?ve carried on
Like a broken record for so long

I don't know who was the first to crack that part, but they did a great fucking job!

My interpretation was pretty much what we had back in the beggining, but that is completly different. Lyricaly, compared to what I thought it was before, it is endlesly better.

I can't take credit for that. It was Nimbus IIRC.



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 19, 2006, 12:22:33 PM
I bet you think I?m doing this all for my health
I should?ve looked back in then at somebody else
Feels as like I?ve done way more than wrong
Feeling like I'll never get tired of this song
Feeling like I'm just too tired to care
Feeling like I?ve done more than my share
Could?ve been the weight that I?ve carried on
Like a broken record for so long

I don't know who was the first to crack that part, but they did a great fucking job!

My interpretation was pretty much what we had back in the beggining, but that is completly different. Lyricaly, compared to what I thought it was before, it is endlesly better.

That is pretty close but this is what I hear.


I bet your doing this all for my health,
I should've looked again then at somebody else
Feel like I done way more than wrong
Feelin like I never gonna get ya outta this song
Feelin like I'm just too tired to care
Feelin like I done more than my share
Could it be the weight that I've carried on
Like a broken record for so long


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 19, 2006, 12:25:05 PM
Is this demo old enough to have Paul Tobias on it?? The rhythm guitar doesn't sound fluid enough to be Fortus, unless its designed to be that way...

I think the only song Fortus is on that has been leaked is Better, the rest have Tobais, and CITR doesnt even have BH or Brain, its Freese on Drums.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: oneway23 on March 19, 2006, 06:27:10 PM
I'm not even certain that Fortus is on Better


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: KillYourIdols on March 19, 2006, 08:33:43 PM
 ::) No one is certain that anyone is on anything on these demos. I'm sure once CD comes out all the questions will be answered.

Until then everything else is speculation.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: kunzerd on March 19, 2006, 08:40:11 PM
I bet you think I?m doing this all for my health


i always thought that line was clear as day, and i could never understand how everyone was getting it wrong. but here is what i got:

I bet you think I?m doing this all for my health
I should?ve looked back in then at somebody else
Feeling like I?ve done way more than wrong
Feeling like I'm living inside of this song
Feeling like I'm just too tired to care
Feeling like I just want to get  my share
Could?ve been the weight that I?ve carried on
Like a broken record for so long


i feel really confident in that (i dont agree with feels because 1) it breaks the pattern and 2) it seriously sounds like feeling), but well never really know until we get a lyrics sheet.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 19, 2006, 08:43:04 PM
I bet you think I?m doing this all for my health


i always thought that line was clear as day, and i could never understand how everyone was getting it wrong. but here is what i got:

I bet you think I?m doing this all for my health


He does not say that many words. That is clear as day.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: kunzerd on March 19, 2006, 08:48:53 PM
your right, i was lazy and just copy pasted.

he does not say the word I.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Ellroy on March 19, 2006, 08:56:00 PM
Am I the only person that hears "sound" instead of "song" in the line:
Feelin' like I'm living inside of this(never get ya outta this) song(sound)

I hear a clear "ow" sound as opposed to a "aw" sound present in the word song. Also, the "n" sound is definiately not nasal like it would be if the word was song. I hear a slight "d" at the edn as well, but this is not as clear as the rest. I know sound doesn't rhyme with wrong, but this is what I strongly hear. Anyone want to give it a few more listens and see if they hear the same as me?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: kunzerd on March 19, 2006, 08:58:20 PM
im playing it back and i clearly hear song.

i also recant my previous statement and the "i bet you think..." line still holds up in my book.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 19, 2006, 09:11:55 PM
im playing it back and i clearly hear song.

i also recant my previous statement and the "i bet you think..." line still holds up in my book.

YOU THINK is not said. Like I said you are saying way too many words


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: kunzerd on March 19, 2006, 09:14:21 PM
i dont know man, i really really do think i hear it.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Ellroy on March 19, 2006, 09:37:00 PM
I'm pretty sure I hear the "you think" as well. He definately says two words (or a two syllable word) but they are real fast and a little distorted. The "you" is not emphasized though. Sounds like its being pronounced like a schwa connected to "think". Of course, everything we're saying will probably end up to be completely wrong when we finally get official lyrics for this song.  : ok:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 19, 2006, 10:29:21 PM
I hope he sings it clearer on the studio version LOL


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 19, 2006, 10:38:24 PM
I dont know how anyone is hearing the word THINK its not there.


IRS

Love
Is it true?
What they say of you

Gonna call the President
Gonna call up the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

There?s not anymore that I can do
All the reasons that you gave
I'll follow you
To when you plead the fifth, that?d be the end of time, its true

Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last I should have known
Through all the rumors I can tell,
Some things didn't work so well

Well anyway, it feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the luck getting outta the debt
That's the truth and here's the worst yet
Wouldn't even matter the things I say
You made your mind up ad hoc anyway
There's no use now in dragging it on
Could've seen it coming all along

Well it?s true...ooh...I had
My doubts of you

Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a Private Eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna wave it right down in your face (??)
Read it daily with your morning news
With a cheap hangover, and the headlines true now

[Finck Solo]

I bet your doing this all for my health,
I should've looked again then at somebody else
Feel like I done way more than wrong
Feelin like I never gonna get ya outta this song
Feelin like I'm just too tired to care
Feelin like I done more than my share
Could it be the weight that I've carried on
Like a broken record for so long

And I do
Ooh, oh.
I'm Gonna call the President,
I'm gonna call a private eye
Gonna get the IRS,
Gonna need myself the FBI

Ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime you know it?s true

[Bucket solo]

Gonna call the president
Gonna get myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna wave it right down in your face(??)
Read it daily with your morning news
With a cheap hangover, and the headlines true

There's not anymore that I can do


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Jim on March 20, 2006, 04:55:58 AM
I dont know how anyone is hearing the word THINK its not there.

Dude, 'think' is as clear as day!

What you've got down doesn't scan with what Axl is singing, even if he isn't saying 'think.'


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 20, 2006, 08:37:00 AM
I dont know how anyone is hearing the word THINK its not there.

Dude, 'think' is as clear as day!

What you've got down doesn't scan with what Axl is singing, even if he isn't saying 'think.'

He isnt saying think at all. The lyric the other person has is way too many words. I am not saying the other way doesnt fit bettr because it would but that is not what Axl is singing. He does not say Think in the IRS demo.  I am not sure what you are hearing but its clear as day Axl is saying "I bet your doing this all for my health"


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Jim on March 20, 2006, 09:03:18 AM
No way dude! You're so wrong!

We'll have to agree to disagree, and then agree to agree that I'm right.

He says it like... I bet youthink... As if it were one word.

But I guess we'll just have to wait until we have the booklet for the new album. And if it isn't on it? Well. Then I guess we'll just have to do battle until the end of time.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Steel_Angel on March 20, 2006, 09:11:41 AM
No way dude! You're so wrong!

We'll have to agree to disagree, and then agree to agree that I'm right.

He says it like... I bet youthink... As if it were one word.

But I guess we'll just have to wait until we have the booklet for the new album. And if it isn't on it? Well. Then I guess we'll just have to do battle until the end of time.
^^^ hes right. listen to him hes sooo smart and dreamy :love: .. *sigh*


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: axe on March 20, 2006, 09:27:31 AM
I'm hearing "think" in that line too. Very clearly.

But then again, it is or it is not only one word on one line. There's another 10 or so lines on that version of the lyrics that just aren't right. Once again, I can't get what the right lyrics are but I'm only saying that those people with good ears and who has enough language skills shouldn't be satisfied with those ones but should just keep on working... or wait until the song comes out in a product with a lyric sheet.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: killingvector on March 20, 2006, 11:18:34 AM
I don't hear think......sorry.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on March 20, 2006, 12:18:10 PM
IRS

Love
If true?
What they say of you

Gonna call the President
Gonna call up the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

There?s not anymore that I can do
All the reasons that you gave
I'll follow you
To when you plead the fifth, that?d be the end of time, its true

Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last I should have known
All the rumors I can tell,
Some things didn't work so well

Well anyway, it feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the luck getting outta the debt
That's the truth and here's the worst yet
Wouldn't even matter the things I say
You made your mind up and walked anyway
There's no use now in dragging it on
Could've seen it coming all along

Well it?s true...ooh...I had
My doubts of you

Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a Private Eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna wave it right down in your face
Read it baby with your morning news
With a cheap hangover, and the headlines true now

[Finck Solo]

I feel your doing this all for my health,
I should've looked again then at somebody else
Feel like I done way more than wrong
Feelin like I never gonna get ya outta this song
Feelin like I'm just too tired to care
Feelin like I done more than my share
Could it be the weight that I've carried on
Like a broken record for so long

What can I do?
Ooh, oh.
I'm Gonna call the President,
I'm gonna call a private eye
Gonna get the IRS,
Gonna need myself the FBI

Ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime you know it?s true

[Bucket solo]

Gonna call the president
Gonna get myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna wave it right down in your face
Read it baby with your morning news
With a cheap hangover, and the headlines true

There's not anymore that I can do


everythign looks good i think i hear a few different things in some spots


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: KillYourIdols on March 20, 2006, 02:10:45 PM
I hear I bet you think...

he just says it really fast...like..."Ibetyathink I'm doing all this for my health"


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Sparksry on March 20, 2006, 05:53:22 PM
I agree with killyour idols it sounds like i bet you think really quick


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 20, 2006, 05:58:45 PM
Young Gunner is right. He sings I feel? your doing this all for my health.



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 20, 2006, 06:02:25 PM
I'm hearing "think" in that line too. Very clearly.

But then again, it is or it is not only one word on one line. There's another 10 or so lines on that version of the lyrics that just aren't right. Once again, I can't get what the right lyrics are but I'm only saying that those people with good ears and who has enough language skills shouldn't be satisfied with those ones but should just keep on working... or wait until the song comes out in a product with a lyric sheet.

This is the line no one has gotten 100% correct yet

Gonna wave it right down in your face (??)
Read it daily with your morning news


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Sparksry on March 20, 2006, 06:31:37 PM
well you know it could be feel it sounds like both really i cant decide .... the other one sounds cooler though


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: BabyGorilla on March 20, 2006, 07:19:50 PM
This is the best transcription I have found:

I.R.S.

Is it true what they say of you?

Gonna call the President
Gonna call a private eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

There?s not any more that I can do
All the reasons that you give
I follow you
to where you believin' if they'll be in
the end of time.
It?s true.

Wouldn't be the first time I've been wrong.
Wouldn't be the last I'm sure I'll go
through all the rumours.
I could tell some things didn?t work so well.
Well, anyway it feels the same.

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago but I still held on
Through all the motions that I?ve had to set
And that?s the truth and here?s the worst yet:

Wouldn?t even matter the things that I?d say.
You made your mind up and lost anyway.
It ain?t no use now we've ended in odds.
Never seen it coming all along.

Well, it?s true.
I had my doubts with you.

Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

I?m gonna make this a federal case
I?m gonna wave it right down in your face
Read it baby with your morning news
With a sweet hangover and your headlines too, now.

I bet you think I'm doing this all for my health
I said it's what I get giving somebody help
Feeling like I?ve done way more than wrong
Feeling like a river get-cha out of this song?
Feeling like I?m just too tired to care
Feeling like I just walked in my shit
Could it be the weight that I carried on
Like a broken record for so long
And I do

Gonna call the President
Gonna call a private eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need myself the FBI

What shall I do
if I gave my heart to you?
It?s a crime you know it?s true.

Gonna call the President
Gonna get myself a private eye
Oh, gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI
Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna wave it right down in your face
Read it baby with your morning news
With a sweet hangover and your headlines too.

There?s not any more that I can do.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 20, 2006, 08:50:05 PM
This is the best transcription I have found:

I.R.S.

Is it true what they say of you?

Gonna call the President
Gonna call a private eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

There?s not any more that I can do
All the reasons that you give
I follow you
to where you believin' if they'll be in
the end of time.
It?s true.

Wouldn't be the first time I've been wrong.
Wouldn't be the last I'm sure I'll go
through all the rumours.
I could tell some things didn?t work so well.
Well, anyway it feels the same.

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago but I still held on
Through all the motions that I?ve had to set
And that?s the truth and here?s the worst yet:

Wouldn?t even matter the things that I?d say.
You made your mind up and lost anyway.
It ain?t no use now we've ended in odds.
Never seen it coming all along.

Well, it?s true.
I had my doubts with you.

Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

I?m gonna make this a federal case
I?m gonna wave it right down in your face
Read it baby with your morning news
With a sweet hangover and your headlines too, now.

I bet you think I'm doing this all for my health
I said it's what I get giving somebody help
Feeling like I?ve done way more than wrong
Feeling like a river get-cha out of this song?
Feeling like I?m just too tired to care
Feeling like I just walked in my shit
Could it be the weight that I carried on
Like a broken record for so long
And I do

Gonna call the President
Gonna call a private eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need myself the FBI

What shall I do
if I gave my heart to you?
It?s a crime you know it?s true.

Gonna call the President
Gonna get myself a private eye
Oh, gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI
Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna wave it right down in your face
Read it baby with your morning news
With a sweet hangover and your headlines too.

There?s not any more that I can do.

Those are not even close


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Sparksry on March 20, 2006, 08:57:54 PM
Then what are they then... thisis the closest we have now unless you have confirmation from the band members


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: BabyGorilla on March 20, 2006, 09:03:26 PM
You can use Windows Sound Recorder to slow down the song by 100%. The lyrics I posted above are pretty accurate to what I hear when I listen to the slowed down version. He definitely does not say "Plead the fifth" in the fourth line of the first verse.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Sparksry on March 20, 2006, 09:05:21 PM
I forgot about that wow thxx ;D : ok:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: killingvector on March 20, 2006, 09:08:48 PM
Quote
Love
If true?

I don't hear that, sorry


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Sparksry on March 20, 2006, 09:14:55 PM
Alot of the thing stheir saying are just what they think is on it . :peace:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: BabyGorilla on March 20, 2006, 09:21:16 PM
I don't think this argument will ever be resolved. These are probably just scratch lyrics that Axl laid down for the tracks just to get an idea of how he wants to vocals to flow. Hopefully he writes something better for the final version. I'm a bit disappointed with Axl's new lyrics with the exception of The Blues and Madagascar. There is no real cohesion in the lyrics and a lot of grammatical errors (example: It don't really matter. Gonna find out for yourself).


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 20, 2006, 10:04:32 PM
I don't think this argument will ever be resolved. These are probably just scratch lyrics that Axl laid down for the tracks just to get an idea of how he wants to vocals to flow. Hopefully he writes something better for the final version. I'm a bit disappointed with Axl's new lyrics with the exception of The Blues and Madagascar. There is no real cohesion in the lyrics and a lot of grammatical errors (example: It don't really matter. Gonna find out for yourself).

You dont think CITR are good lyrics? What are you talking about? As for his grammar/slang who cares, the AFD and UYI songs are just the same.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 20, 2006, 10:06:48 PM
You can use Windows Sound Recorder to slow down the song by 100%. The lyrics I posted above are pretty accurate to what I hear when I listen to the slowed down version. He definitely does not say "Plead the fifth" in the fourth line of the first verse.

Like I said that verison is not even close. The ones we have are 95% correct save a few lines. Some of your lyrics dont even make sense.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: BabyGorilla on March 20, 2006, 10:14:43 PM
No, I don't care much for the lyrics on CITR. It lacks direction and cohesion. Axl jumps from one thought to another. If I wasn't told that the song was about John Lennon, I would have no clue what Axl was talking about in the song.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 20, 2006, 10:16:01 PM
No, I don't care much for the lyrics on CITR. It lacks direction and cohesion. Axl jumps from one thought to another. If I wasn't told that the song was about John Lennon, I would have no clue what Axl was talking about in the song.

What are you talking about? How can you not follow the lyrics? He doesnt jump around at all. I guess the lyrics are just over your head


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: BabyGorilla on March 20, 2006, 10:20:08 PM
Ya, I'm just too stupid to figure them out.   ::)

Since you claim to be knowledgeable enough to interpret the lyrics, can you break them done for me so my feeble little mind could comprehend them?


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 20, 2006, 10:21:04 PM
Ya, I'm just too stupid to figure them out.? ?::)

Since you claim to be knowledge enough to interpret the lyrics, can you break them done for me so my feeble little mind could comprehend them?

Lets take this to the CITR Therad, where its on topic


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: KeVoRkIaN on March 20, 2006, 10:23:45 PM
IRS

Love
If true?
What they say of you

Gonna call the President
Gonna call up the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

There?s not anymore that I can do
All the reasons that you gave
I'll follow you
To when you plead the fifth, that?d be the end of time, its true

Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last I should have known
All the rumors I can tell,
Some things didn't work so well

Well anyway, it feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the luck getting outta the debt
That's the truth and here's the worst yet
Wouldn't even matter the things I say
You made your mind up and walked anyway
There's no use now in dragging it on
Could've seen it coming all along

Well it?s true...ooh...I had
My doubts of you

Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a Private Eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna wave it right down in your face
Read it baby with your morning news
With a cheap hangover, and the headlines true now

[Finck Solo]

I feel your doing this all for my health,
I should've looked again then at somebody else
Feel like I done way more than wrong
Feelin like I'm living inside of this song
Feelin like I'm just too tired to care
Feelin like I done more than my share
Could it be the weight that I've carried on
Like a broken record for so long

What can I do?
Ooh, oh.
I'm Gonna call the President,
I'm gonna call a private eye
Gonna get the IRS,
Gonna need myself the FBI

Ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime you know it?s true

[Bucket solo]

Gonna call the president
Gonna get myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna wave it right down in your face
Read it baby with your morning news
With a cheap hangover, and the headlines true

There's not anymore that I can do


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 20, 2006, 10:24:45 PM
He doesnt say living inside this song. Its clear as day. Its never gonna get you out of this song


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: KeVoRkIaN on March 20, 2006, 10:27:52 PM
He doesnt say living inside this song. Its clear as day. Its never gonna get you out of this song

Not as clear as day to me for some reason - i can't hear never gonna get you out of this song at all - or even close


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 20, 2006, 10:30:22 PM
He doesnt say living inside this song. Its clear as day. Its never gonna get you out of this song

Not as clear as day to me for some reason - i can't hear never gonna get you out of this song at all - or even close

That is why 99% of the people who have transcribed this song have it how I do right? No one but you has it your way.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: KeVoRkIaN on March 20, 2006, 11:12:29 PM
He doesnt say living inside this song. Its clear as day. Its never gonna get you out of this song

Not as clear as day to me for some reason - i can't hear never gonna get you out of this song at all - or even close

That is why 99% of the people who have transcribed this song have it how I do right? No one but you has it your way.

Hey - I'm just hearing it a different way man - no need to get personal - I transcribed a few lines in this song


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 20, 2006, 11:29:41 PM
He doesnt say living inside this song. Its clear as day. Its never gonna get you out of this song

Not as clear as day to me for some reason - i can't hear never gonna get you out of this song at all - or even close

That is why 99% of the people who have transcribed this song have it how I do right? No one but you has it your way.

Hey - I'm just hearing it a different way man - no need to get personal - I transcribed a few lines in this song

I didnt, I was making a point.  I am not like some people (not saying you)who feel their lyrics have to be right. I just take the lyrics that sound correct and go with that. I have changed the lyrics i did llike 5 times the past week.  I just want us to get all the lyrics right.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: BabyGorilla on March 20, 2006, 11:31:15 PM
He doesnt say living inside this song. Its clear as day. Its never gonna get you out of this song

Not as clear as day to me for some reason - i can't hear never gonna get you out of this song at all - or even close

That is why 99% of the people who have transcribed this song have it how I do right? No one but you has it your way.

Hey - I'm just hearing it a different way man - no need to get personal - I transcribed a few lines in this song

That line isn't as clear as day for me either. I uploaded a slowed down version of that particular line. Sounds like the fourth word starts with an "ri" and ends with an "er" which makes me think the word is "river."

Here is the clip: http://s17.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=0W550VUOEIUTS23HXQOEQDTRI0


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 20, 2006, 11:32:11 PM
He doesnt say living inside this song. Its clear as day. Its never gonna get you out of this song

Not as clear as day to me for some reason - i can't hear never gonna get you out of this song at all - or even close

That is why 99% of the people who have transcribed this song have it how I do right? No one but you has it your way.

Hey - I'm just hearing it a different way man - no need to get personal - I transcribed a few lines in this song

That line isn't as clear as day for me either. I uploaded a slowed down version of that particular line. Sounds like the fourth word starts with an "ri" and ends with an "er" which makes me think the word is "river."

Here is the clip: http://s17.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=0W550VUOEIUTS23HXQOEQDTRI0

River makes no sense but never gonna get you out of this song and livin inside this song are both dumb lyrics too


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: BabyGorilla on March 20, 2006, 11:38:19 PM
I think the lyric is "Feelin' like a river get-cha out of this song?" As if to say the person who Axl is directing the insults to is looking for a last resort or something drastic to escape Axl's wrath.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dellorto on March 22, 2006, 01:44:06 PM
What IRS means?  abreviation of what?

Sorry if it was posted before... :smoking:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: ROSE22 on March 22, 2006, 01:51:17 PM
He doesnt say living inside this song. Its clear as day. Its never gonna get you out of this song

Not as clear as day to me for some reason - i can't hear never gonna get you out of this song at all - or even close

That is why 99% of the people who have transcribed this song have it how I do right? No one but you has it your way.

Hey - I'm just hearing it a different way man - no need to get personal - I transcribed a few lines in this song

That line isn't as clear as day for me either. I uploaded a slowed down version of that particular line. Sounds like the fourth word starts with an "ri" and ends with an "er" which makes me think the word is "river."

Here is the clip: http://s17.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=0W550VUOEIUTS23HXQOEQDTRI0

River makes no sense but never gonna get you out of this song and livin inside this song are both dumb lyrics too
go take a nap and give it a rest. you are whining like a baby and now you are bashing the lyrics regardless of what they might be ? you need a time out. :crying:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: oldgunsfan on March 22, 2006, 01:53:27 PM
What IRS means?? abreviation of what?

Sorry if it was posted before... :smoking:

Internal Revenue Service, the gov agency responsible for collecting american taxes

Personally I think this song is directed at former band members, most notably Slash, but that may prove wrong


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on March 22, 2006, 02:37:38 PM
What IRS means?? abreviation of what?

Sorry if it was posted before... :smoking:

Internal Revenue Service, the gov agency responsible for collecting american taxes

Personally I think this song is directed at former band members, most notably Slash, but that may prove wrong

I agree, I think it has to do with slash and duff


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Sparksry on March 22, 2006, 02:38:01 PM
What IRS means?? abreviation of what?

Sorry if it was posted before... :smoking:

Internal Revenue Service, the gov agency responsible for collecting american taxes

Personally I think this song is directed at former band members, most notably Slash, but that may prove wrong
Or in otherwords the worst people in the world ?:nervous: :confused: :crying:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: SlashDelonge on March 22, 2006, 03:01:12 PM
ur the man /jarmo


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Dellorto on March 22, 2006, 03:16:44 PM
What IRS means?  abreviation of what?

Sorry if it was posted before... :smoking:

Internal Revenue Service, the gov agency responsible for collecting american taxes

Personally I think this song is directed at former band members, most notably Slash, but that may prove wrong
Or in otherwords the worst people in the world  :nervous: :confused: :crying:

worst people.... :hihi: like in Brazil, but here we have worst...thanks


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Sparksry on March 22, 2006, 03:17:24 PM
lol brazil thats pretty bad whats worse then irs lol


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: speed-stone on April 30, 2006, 07:23:22 PM
i can't praise this song enough! it's just perfect, i honestly haven't gotten the warm gnr feeling inside this song gives me since the UYI days! if chinese democracy is loaded with this kind of stuff, it will surpass even my expectations! :drool:
way to go axl, you're truly the heart and soul of guns n' roses! : ok:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Steel_Angel on April 30, 2006, 07:27:30 PM
i got goosbumps the first time i hard this song  : ok:
Axl is the main ingredient of gnr.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: speed-stone on April 30, 2006, 07:36:51 PM
i got goosbumps the first time i hard this song? : ok:
Axl is the main ingredient of gnr.

and always was : ok:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Woooo! on April 30, 2006, 07:43:28 PM
I'm thinkin' what to do is offer my help,
I should've looked again there for somebody else

Feel like I done way more than wrong
Feelin like I'm living inside of this song
Feelin like I'm just too tired to care
Feelin like I done more than my share
Could it be the weight that I've carried on
Like a broken record for so long

Damn good effort there, but I just adjusted that part slightly lol. Once again, damn fine stuff. Damn fine song. All about Slash if you ask me.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: speed-stone on April 30, 2006, 07:44:39 PM
or stephanie.
that's what i think.
who knows though. only axl and his friends. :peace:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: speed-stone on May 09, 2006, 09:54:03 AM
this song just keeps growing and growing on me! what a fucking masterpiece it is!
chinese democracy will no doubt exceed everyone's expectations with stuff like this.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: oldgunsfan on May 09, 2006, 10:47:14 AM
I'm thinkin' what to do is offer my help,
I should've looked again there for somebody else

Feel like I done way more than wrong
Feelin like I'm living inside of this song
Feelin like I'm just too tired to care
Feelin like I done more than my share
Could it be the weight that I've carried on
Like a broken record for so long

Damn good effort there, but I just adjusted that part slightly lol. Once again, damn fine stuff. Damn fine song. All about Slash if you ask me.

I always thought it was about his ex-band members as well....not so much about Stephanie


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: speed-stone on May 09, 2006, 10:53:57 AM
i'm simply addicted to this song! ;D
gives me fucking chills and butterflies!
axl = gnr for sure! that old gnr feelin'!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: younggunner on May 09, 2006, 11:06:24 AM
irs has really grown on me


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Where is Hassan Nasrallah ? on May 09, 2006, 12:10:55 PM
THE SONG IS AMAZING
just needs to be a little more punch and heavy

like these lines
Quote
[Finck Solo]

I'm thinkin' what to do is offer my help,
I should've looked again there for somebody else
Feel like I done way more than wrong
Feelin like I'm living inside of this song
Feelin like I'm just too tired to care
Feelin like I done more than my share
Could it be the weight that I've carried on
Like a broken record for so long

after the solo, they just burst the hell out of your speakers, so powerfull.

the rest of the songs needs to have that energy, just raw anger.


man these concerts are just gonna be inhuman !


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on May 22, 2006, 03:51:20 PM
I still cant figure out that one line
but i fixed the other errors


IRS

Oh oh
Is it true?
What they say of you

Gonna call the President
Gonna call up the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

There?s not anymore that I can do
All the reasons that you gave
I'd follow you
To when you plead and if that?d be the end of time, its true

Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last I should have known
All the rumors I can tell,
Some things didn't work so well

Well anyway, it feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the motions ???
That's the truth and here's the worst yet
Wouldn't even matter the things I say
You made your mind up and gone anyway
There's no use now in dragging it on
Could've seen it coming all along

Well it?s true...ooh...I had
My doubts with you

Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a Private Eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna wave it right down in your face (??)
Read a minute with your morning news
With a cheap hangover, and the headlines true now

[Finck Solo]

I feel your doing this all for my health
I should've looked again then at somebody else
Feel like I done way more than wrong
Feelin like I'm livin inside this song
Feelin like I'm just too tired to care
Feelin like I done more than my share
Could it be the weight that I've carried on
Like a broken record for so long

And I do
Ooh, oh.
I'm Gonna call the President,
I'm gonna call a private eye
Gonna get the IRS,
Gonna need myself the FBI

Ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime you know it?s true

[Bucket solo]

Gonna call the president
Gonna get myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna wave it right down in your face(??)
Read a minute with your morning news
With a cheap hangover, and the headlines true

There's not anymore that I can do


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: darknemus on May 22, 2006, 03:55:05 PM
Umm, you guys still have the 'plead' line wrong.

Its 'when you plead the fifth and in the end the charge is true'

-darknemus


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on May 22, 2006, 04:02:36 PM
Umm, you guys still have the 'plead' line wrong.

Its 'when you plead the fifth and in the end the charge is true'

-darknemus


No its not. Its When you plead and if that be the end of time its true. Listen to one of the live versions.
Plus I heard the other version over razz radio and its clearly when you plead and if that be the end of time its true.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: gnrkid03 on May 22, 2006, 05:03:54 PM
All i know is that IRS kicks much more ass with that new solo from the live performance.  To me the song was very boring and sustained this boringness too long, but the new solo breaks it up and I really dig it.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: mr. moustache on May 22, 2006, 05:16:02 PM
He doesnt say living inside this song. Its clear as day. Its never gonna get you out of this song
uhhh, he says "feelin like I'm living inside of this song" the guy was right, it clearly doesn't say never in the line


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on May 22, 2006, 05:21:04 PM
He doesnt say living inside this song. Its clear as day. Its never gonna get you out of this song
uhhh, he says "feelin like I'm living inside of this song" the guy was right, it clearly doesn't say never in the line

Damn now I hear both LOL. My ears are playing tricks on me. You might  be right, i think its feel like in living inside this song now. Let me go fix it.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: nesquick on May 22, 2006, 05:31:54 PM
I think IRS would sound absolutely GIANT if they made a hard-Rock version with a speed-up tempo and a louder guitar riff. I want them to play it hard.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: WARose on May 22, 2006, 05:33:48 PM
this song was my favourite before, but after listening to dankrass recording it has grwon on me even further :beer:

the new solo and intro kick ass. and the beginning in general sounds .... different  and different drumming.

i definitely need this CD :hihi:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: andypa1 on May 22, 2006, 05:51:46 PM
really getting into IRS now, hmm my guess is its about Stephanie.
the song is really appropiate to me at the mo, i keep hearing all these rumors about the girl i really like. "ooh is it true what they say about you.." etc

It really expresses my paranoia very well.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on May 22, 2006, 06:14:57 PM
really getting into IRS now, hmm my guess is its about Stephanie.
the song is really appropiate to me at the mo, i keep hearing all these rumors about the girl i really like. "ooh is it true what they say about you.." etc

It really expresses my paranoia very well.

My guess is the song is about Slash and him suing Axl


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: darknemus on May 22, 2006, 07:25:12 PM
In regards to that lyric about "when you plead"

I was like, literally, about 5 feet away from Axl when he sang it - I read the dude's lips.  "So when you plead the fifth and in the end the charge is true" - In addition, the lyric you're filling in there doesn't even make much sense, contextually.

Not trying to argue or anything - just sharing my observations.

-darknemus




Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: darknemus on May 22, 2006, 07:33:00 PM
Slight modification.  It could also be "so when you plead the fifth, babe, and in the end the charge is true.  (or possibly 'charges true' could fit there as well)

The thing is, the word 'babe' does sound like its in there - but the way that line is sung is just.. weird.  Love the f'n song, though.

-darknemus


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Neemo on May 22, 2006, 07:40:40 PM
but even on the clean one i cn't make out everything....I've given up and am waiting for the official liner notes : ok:


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: ZRO on May 22, 2006, 07:45:33 PM
Ok, here's my take on the lyrics, tell me what you think..


Oh oh
Is it true?
What they say of you

Gonna call the President
Gonna call up the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

There?s not anymore that I can do
All the reasons that you gave
I'll follow you
So when you plead the fifth and in the end the charge is true.

Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last I should have known
All the rumors I can tell,
Some things didn't work so well

Well anyway, it feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I still held on.
Through all the bullshit that I've had to take
I've found the truth and heard the worst yet
Wouldn't even matter the things I say
You made your mind up and gone on your way
There's no use now in dragging it on
Should've seen it coming all along

Well it?s true...ooh...I asked
My god it was you

Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a Private Eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna win and take it out on your face
Read a minute with your morning news
With a sweet hangover, and the headlines true now

[Solo]

I bet you think I'm doing this all for my health
I'd set it up again dressed as somebody else
Feel like I've done way more than wrong
Feelin like I'm livin inside this song
Feelin like I'm just too tired to kill
Feelin like I just walked in my shit
Could've been waitin' out here alone
Like a broken record for so long

And I do
Ooh, oh.
I'm Gonna call the President,
I'm gonna call a Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS.
Gonna need myself the FBI

Ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you
It'sa crime you know it?s trueeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

[solo]

Gonna call the president
Gonna get myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna win and take it out on your face
Read a minute with your morning news
With a sweet hangover, and the headlines true

There's not anymore that I can do


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Axl8302 on May 22, 2006, 10:03:45 PM
i hear ' could it be the way that i've carried on, like a broken record all day long'.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: HoldenCaulfield on May 22, 2006, 10:28:16 PM
My interpretation:

Love, is it true?
What they say of you?

Gonna call the President,
gonna call with the private eye,
gonna get the IRS,
gonna need the FBI.
There's not anymore that I can do.

All the reasons that you give,
I'll follow you.
So when you plead the fifth and in the end the target's true.
Wouldn't be the first time I've been robbed,
wouldn't be the last I'm sure I've gone
through all the rumors I can tell,
some things didn't work so well.

Well anyway it feels the same,
as when you first told me you were wrong,
so long ago but I feel led on.
Though all the bullshit and I'm in this wreck,
that's the truth now here's the worse yet,
wouldn't even amount to the things that I've paid,
you'd bend your mind, I'd be gone anyway.
And there's no use knowing that you've done lost,
you'd have seen it comin' all along.

Well it's true, oh,
I had, but that was you, oh oh!

Gonna call the President,
gonna call myself a private eye,
gonna need the IRS,
gonna get the FBI.
Gonna make it a federal case,
gonna wave it right back out in your face,
re-invent with your morning news with a
sweet hangover and your headlines, too now.

I bet you think I'm doin' this all for my health,
say this like I did now it's somebody else,
feeling like I've done way more than wrong,
feeling like I'm living inside of this song,
feeling like I'm just too tired to care,
feeling like I've done more than my share,
could it be the wait that I've carried on,
like a broken record for so long?
Am I doomed? Uh, oh!

Gonna call the President,
gonna call a private eye,
gonna get the IRS,
gonna need myself the FBI.

Ooh, what shall I do?
If I gave my heart freely? Oh.
It's like a crime you know it's true!

Gonna call the President,
gonna get myself a private eye,
ooh gonna need the IRS,
gonna get the FBI.

Gonna make it a federal case,
gonna wave it right back out in your face,
re-invent it with your morning news with
a sweet hangover and your headlines too now.
It's not anymore that I can do...



Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on May 22, 2006, 10:32:18 PM
but even on the clean one i cn't make out everything....I've given up and am waiting for the official liner notes : ok:

If you heard the other  version you can make out most of the lyrics


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Cowboy Buddha on May 24, 2006, 04:33:01 AM
What I think...


Oh oh
Is it true?
What they say of you

Gonna call the President
Gonna call up the Private Eye
Gonna get the IRS
Gonna need the FBI

There?s not anymore that I can do
All the reasons that you gave
I'll follow you
To when you plead the fifth, that?d be the end of time, its true

Wouldn?t be the first time I've been wrong
Wouldn't be the last I should have known
All the rumors I can tell,
Some things didn't work so well

Well anyway, it feels the same

When you first told me you were gone
So long ago, but I've been here long
To all the motions that I had to see
That's the truth and here's the worst yet
Wouldn't even matter the things I say
You made your mind up and gone anyway
There's no use now in dragging it on
Could've seen it coming all along

Well it?s true...ooh...I had
but don?t forget

Gonna call the President
Gonna call myself a Private Eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

Gonna make this a federal case
Gonna wave it right down in your face
Read it baby with your morning news
With a sweet hangover, and the headlines too now

[Robin Fuckin' Finck Solo]

I been doing this all for my health,
I should've looked again then at somebody else
Feel like I done way more than wrong
Feelin like I'm living inside of this song
Feelin like I'm just too tired to care
Feelin like I done more than my share
Could it be the weight that I've carried on
Like a broken record for so long

And I do?
Ooh, oh.
I'm Gonna call the President,
I'm gonna call a private eye
Gonna get the IRS,
Gonna need myself the FBI

Ooh, what shall I do
If I gave my heart to you
It's such a crime you know it?s true

[Bucket/Bumble solo]

Gonna call the president
Gonna get myself a private eye
Gonna need the IRS
Gonna get the FBI

Gonna make it a federal case
Gonna wave it right down in your face
Read it baby with your morning news
With a sweet hangover and the headlines too

There's not anymore that I can do


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Jhestas on May 24, 2006, 04:33:35 AM
cool song


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: The Catcher on November 17, 2008, 02:44:32 AM
I'm very eager to hear what the album version of this song sounds like.
It's been one of my favourites for quite some time now! I'm very happy it's on the album! 8)


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: w.axl.rose on November 17, 2008, 02:45:19 AM
i thought this thread was gone till the album drops.


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: Layne Staley's Sunglasses on November 17, 2008, 02:49:03 AM
i thought this thread was gone till the album drops.

Obviously not. 

It's good that what's-his-face above you found the thread.  Sure beats searching for something for a long time.

That, and by this time next week we can talk about it!


Title: Re: The IRS discussion thread
Post by: benfolds4980 on November 17, 2008, 11:07:53 AM
i always thought the beginning was

There?s not anymore that I can do
All the reasons that you gave
I'll follow you
To Where you'd lead, and if that'd be the end of time its true