Live 8, reviews of Robbie Williams ( must read for non believers !!)

[Izzy]

He is a good performer, credit where credits due - he can get a crowd going, and though the crowd is full of people who wouldn't know good music if it attacked them, its still an achievement

All the same,

He's just yet another god awful manufactured pop star who gets his fairly straightforward songs written for him.

As a performer he clearly has talent - as a maker of good music he's no better than Destiny's Child, Britney Spears and all the other MTV rubbish.

He does have 'rock' leanings, maybe if he formed a band and released legitimate (i.e written by the band) music it could be intresting

[mnsotapop]

There must be some weird substance in the water in England that makes people there like him.  You could go see a dozen shows in Vegas with people who are as equally entertaining as Robbie.  Just my opinion 

[Mr. Dick Purple]

I think he did a great show and I agree with the dude that said that he shouldn't try to be like bono and Freddie and try to be original, yet again he is a great entertainer 

[Dot]

 There?s no way he?s in the same floor as Freddy Mercury, no way!

[D]

He was the most applauded performer thats for sure.

i saw the "Angels' performance and it was amazing!

he truly is a great performer, one of the best ive seen

Pink Floyd didnt really get the crowd involved

Robbie was all over the crowd.

[Kujo]

I saw the re-run of his performance this weekend. He certainly had alot of energy which was lacking from alot of the other performances. He does have a good voice but as has been previously stated the songs were standard pop fare, in my opinion. However there was a sea of humanity that was responding as if they just witnessed the second coming of the messiah. I dont think I would go out of my way to see him perform live but he did put on one of the best performances that night.