(Possibly) First "Review" of Chinese Democracy - Sort of!

[Mr.Intensity]

A. I have no clue if the guy's telling the truth or not.  His story seems plausible, at least.  In addition - none of his other posts were even Guns related on there.  Not like a one post wonder attention whore type, anyway.

B. Just because he didn't give details does NOT mean he's lying.  Of course, it also doesn't mean he's telling the truth.. but it certainly doesn't prove or disprove the guy.

C. Pilferk really does have a brain

D. As the disc gets closer and closer to release - these stories become more and more lkely to be true.. in my opinion.  I'm telling you its only a matter of a few weeks or so until the thing's available online in its entirety.. in my opinion.

-darknemus

in regards to D. do you really think that,and in such a short space in time

The only way D can happen is if/when c.d hits the mastering stage.. at this point there is not a mastered final version of the album. If Chinese Democracy leaks it will happen when the c.d. enters the reproduction stage most likely. When it is officially mastered I am sure only Geffen, Axl, management, and maybe all band members will get a mastered copy.

[Steel_Angel]

i pmed him 4 times and still i dont understand why he cant name one fucking track he heard hes full of shit. soz.

[Mr.Intensity]

#4 He shyed away from all private contact as well which could have possibly verified him.

I exchanged at least 5 PMs with him. 

It all depends how you approach people. 

Did he give you any information regarding tracklisting/lyrics/artwork?? Did the cd have linear notes of all the musicians that featured on certain songs? Or did he basically play pattycake and shy away from any detaill? I didn't approach him as I didn't take time to sign up over there.. although I had a couple people trying to get his contact info of any kind, but he didn't want to give it out......

[leesixxrose]

i pmed him 4 times and still i dont understand why he cant name one fucking track he heard hes full of shit. soz.

he cant name one track coz he didnt hear it... its bullshit... same song and dance as always ....

[Mr.Intensity]

I'd like to know the title/titles of the tracks he considered "filler."

[MR W,AXL ROSE]

A. I have no clue if the guy's telling the truth or not.? His story seems plausible, at least.? In addition - none of his other posts were even Guns related on there.? Not like a one post wonder attention whore type, anyway.

B. Just because he didn't give details does NOT mean he's lying.? Of course, it also doesn't mean he's telling the truth.. but it certainly doesn't prove or disprove the guy.

C. Pilferk really does have a brain

D. As the disc gets closer and closer to release - these stories become more and more lkely to be true.. in my opinion.? I'm telling you its only a matter of a few weeks or so until the thing's available online in its entirety.. in my opinion.

-darknemus

in regards to D. do you really think that,and in such a short space in time

The only way D can happen is if/when c.d hits the mastering stage.. at this point there is not a mastered final version of the album. If Chinese Democracy leaks it will happen when the c.d. enters the reproduction stage most likely. When it is officially mastered I am sure only Geffen, Axl, management, and maybe all band members will get a mastered copy.

im not being an arsehole Mr I but how do you know that CD hasnt been mastered yet,its not like axl will walk the streets shouting "CDs being mastered everyone".and i agree with you that it wont be on the net until the reproduction stage is under way.

[Mr.Intensity]

A. I have no clue if the guy's telling the truth or not.  His story seems plausible, at least.  In addition - none of his other posts were even Guns related on there.  Not like a one post wonder attention whore type, anyway.

B. Just because he didn't give details does NOT mean he's lying.  Of course, it also doesn't mean he's telling the truth.. but it certainly doesn't prove or disprove the guy.

C. Pilferk really does have a brain

D. As the disc gets closer and closer to release - these stories become more and more lkely to be true.. in my opinion.  I'm telling you its only a matter of a few weeks or so until the thing's available online in its entirety.. in my opinion.

-darknemus

in regards to D. do you really think that,and in such a short space in time

The only way D can happen is if/when c.d hits the mastering stage.. at this point there is not a mastered final version of the album. If Chinese Democracy leaks it will happen when the c.d. enters the reproduction stage most likely. When it is officially mastered I am sure only Geffen, Axl, management, and maybe all band members will get a mastered copy.

im not being an arsehole Mr I but how do you know that CD hasnt been mastered yet,its not like axl will walk the streets shouting "CDs being mastered everyone".and i agree with you that it wont be on the net until the reproduction stage is under way.

You'll just have to trust me that it hasn't been mastered yet.. I don't know if a tracklisting has even been determined either.

[MR W,AXL ROSE]

A. I have no clue if the guy's telling the truth or not.? His story seems plausible, at least.? In addition - none of his other posts were even Guns related on there.? Not like a one post wonder attention whore type, anyway.

B. Just because he didn't give details does NOT mean he's lying.? Of course, it also doesn't mean he's telling the truth.. but it certainly doesn't prove or disprove the guy.

C. Pilferk really does have a brain

D. As the disc gets closer and closer to release - these stories become more and more lkely to be true.. in my opinion.? I'm telling you its only a matter of a few weeks or so until the thing's available online in its entirety.. in my opinion.

-darknemus

in regards to D. do you really think that,and in such a short space in time

The only way D can happen is if/when c.d hits the mastering stage.. at this point there is not a mastered final version of the album. If Chinese Democracy leaks it will happen when the c.d. enters the reproduction stage most likely. When it is officially mastered I am sure only Geffen, Axl, management, and maybe all band members will get a mastered copy.

im not being an arsehole Mr I but how do you know that CD hasnt been mastered yet,its not like axl will walk the streets shouting "CDs being mastered everyone".and i agree with you that it wont be on the net until the reproduction stage is under way.

You'll just have to trust me that it hasn't been mastered yet.. I don't know if a tracklisting has even been determined either.

nah,soz,i go with alot of other poeple on here and doubt you coz you sound too certain with nothing to prove you.i cant see how it would harm you to tell us how you know it aint been mastered yet.

[Steel_Angel]

A. I have no clue if the guy's telling the truth or not.? His story seems plausible, at least.? In addition - none of his other posts were even Guns related on there.? Not like a one post wonder attention whore type, anyway.

B. Just because he didn't give details does NOT mean he's lying.? Of course, it also doesn't mean he's telling the truth.. but it certainly doesn't prove or disprove the guy.

C. Pilferk really does have a brain

D. As the disc gets closer and closer to release - these stories become more and more lkely to be true.. in my opinion.? I'm telling you its only a matter of a few weeks or so until the thing's available online in its entirety.. in my opinion.

-darknemus

in regards to D. do you really think that,and in such a short space in time

The only way D can happen is if/when c.d hits the mastering stage.. at this point there is not a mastered final version of the album. If Chinese Democracy leaks it will happen when the c.d. enters the reproduction stage most likely. When it is officially mastered I am sure only Geffen, Axl, management, and maybe all band members will get a mastered copy.

im not being an arsehole Mr I but how do you know that CD hasnt been mastered yet,its not like axl will walk the streets shouting "CDs being mastered everyone".and i agree with you that it wont be on the net until the reproduction stage is under way.

You'll just have to trust me that it hasn't been mastered yet.. I don't know if a tracklisting has even been determined either.

nah,soz,i go with alot of other poeple on here and doubt you coz you sound too certain with nothing to prove you.i cant see how it would harm you to tell us how you know it aint been mastered yet.

just imagine hes got sources?

[MR W,AXL ROSE]

A. I have no clue if the guy's telling the truth or not.? His story seems plausible, at least.? In addition - none of his other posts were even Guns related on there.? Not like a one post wonder attention whore type, anyway.

B. Just because he didn't give details does NOT mean he's lying.? Of course, it also doesn't mean he's telling the truth.. but it certainly doesn't prove or disprove the guy.

C. Pilferk really does have a brain

D. As the disc gets closer and closer to release - these stories become more and more lkely to be true.. in my opinion.? I'm telling you its only a matter of a few weeks or so until the thing's available online in its entirety.. in my opinion.

-darknemus

in regards to D. do you really think that,and in such a short space in time

The only way D can happen is if/when c.d hits the mastering stage.. at this point there is not a mastered final version of the album. If Chinese Democracy leaks it will happen when the c.d. enters the reproduction stage most likely. When it is officially mastered I am sure only Geffen, Axl, management, and maybe all band members will get a mastered copy.

im not being an arsehole Mr I but how do you know that CD hasnt been mastered yet,its not like axl will walk the streets shouting "CDs being mastered everyone".and i agree with you that it wont be on the net until the reproduction stage is under way.

You'll just have to trust me that it hasn't been mastered yet.. I don't know if a tracklisting has even been determined either.

nah,soz,i go with alot of other poeple on here and doubt you coz you sound too certain with nothing to prove you.i cant see how it would harm you to tell us how you know it aint been mastered yet.

just imagine hes got sources?

the only sources i can imagine him having is ketchup and burger relish 

[Mr.Intensity]

Anyway,  I signed up and sent Logan5 a pm, I'll see if I can get him to give even the slightest detail about some stuff. If he truly only heard the disc, then there is really no way to verify him as completely false or completely true..

Hopefully, Tommy gives us some new info on that show tonight.

[kaddisonmoore]

Anyway,? I signed up and sent Logan5 a pm, I'll see if I can get him to give even the slightest detail about some stuff. If he truly only heard the disc, then there is really no way to verify him as completely false or completely true..

Hopefully, Tommy gives us some new info on that show tonight.

have you got a reply yet?

[Steel_Angel]

even if he replies he (logan5) is just going to change the subject.?
ive asked him plenty of times to name a few tracks and all he keeps saying is "i did not copy the cd" blah blah.?

[Mr.Intensity]

Anyway,  I signed up and sent Logan5 a pm, I'll see if I can get him to give even the slightest detail about some stuff. If he truly only heard the disc, then there is really no way to verify him as completely false or completely true..

Hopefully, Tommy gives us some new info on that show tonight.

have you got a reply yet?

No, I'll cease from posting in this thread until he contacts me.....

[Jonx]

Anyway,  I signed up and sent Logan5 a pm, I'll see if I can get him to give even the slightest detail about some stuff. If he truly only heard the disc, then there is really no way to verify him as completely false or completely true..

Hopefully, Tommy gives us some new info on that show tonight.

He wont!

Jonx

[SWINGTRADER]

Let me start off by saying that everything that guy said about Cd is true. I also heard the album and it is great.  you will not be disappointed. My favorite song in CD is a song called " GNR fans are suckers" .  Axl's voice is powerful in this tune, you can feel the anger in his voice when  singing this particular song.  I would also like to add that the guitar playing is magnificent.  There are some fast and slow melodic solos  in this 7.36 min track  that changes tempo like 3 times ( kind of like Coma).  This is going to be one true epic !    if you guys have any questions concerning CD  don't hesitate to ask me  I will be more than happy to reply.       LONG LIVE GNR !!!

[kaddisonmoore]

Let me start off by saying that everything that guy said about Cd is true. I also heard the album and it is great.? you will not be disappointed. My favorite song in CD is a song called " GNR fans are suckers" .? Axl's voice is powerful in this tune, you can feel the anger in his voice when? singing this particular song.? I would also like to add that the guitar playing is magnificent.? There are some fast and slow melodic solos? in this 7.36 min track? that changes tempo like 3 times ( kind of like Coma).? This is going to be one true epic !? ? if you guys have any questions concerning CD? don't hesitate to ask me? I will be more than happy to reply.? ? ? ?LONG LIVE GNR !!!

so can you post the track list? lol

[SWINGTRADER]

Let me start off by saying that everything that guy said about Cd is true. I also heard the album and it is great.? you will not be disappointed. My favorite song in CD is a song called " GNR fans are suckers" .? Axl's voice is powerful in this tune, you can feel the anger in his voice when? singing this particular song.? I would also like to add that the guitar playing is magnificent.? There are some fast and slow melodic solos? in this 7.36 min track? that changes tempo like 3 times ( kind of like Coma).? This is going to be one true epic !? ? if you guys have any questions concerning CD? don't hesitate to ask me? I will be more than happy to reply.? ? ? ?LONG LIVE GNR !!!

so can you post the track list? lol

Hold on  let me get the CD case    Be right back   

[jameslofton29]

Quick question: Why are the 1000 insiders with their 5000 sources speculating like everyone else? They should've known minutes after it was posted whether it was real or not. Instead of insulting people who say its fake, just call one of your many sources and find out.

I will be waiting patiently to see what the radio, retail, and secret sources have to say this time.

[SLCPUNK]

Quick question: Why are the 1000 insiders with their 5000 sources speculating like everyone else? They should've known minutes after it was posted whether it was real or not. Instead of insulting people who say its fake, just call one of your many sources and find out.

Oh my.............