Would you rather hear: CD II, or new album by new lineup?

[ice cream sand pig]

when i went to log in and respond to this, my answer must have already been in my head because i accidentally typed cd2 in the space where you type your user name.

hands down, cd2. the second half to my favorite album of all time? want. want bad. please give.

[D-GenerationX]

CD II, almost strictly for time's sake.  Axl has been putzing around for 15 years on shit he's already supposedly done.

To have him start from scratch is a doomed operation.  Of these choices, give me CD II.

Yep.

Still.

[AHUGEAxlFan]

hands down, cd2. the second half to my favorite album of all time? want. want bad. please give.

[EmilyGNR]

CD II, almost strictly for time's sake.  Axl has been putzing around for 15 years on shit he's already supposedly done.

To have him start from scratch is a doomed operation.  Of these choices, give me CD II.

Yep.

Still.

You quoted yourself?   

Why am I not surprised .

[D-GenerationX]

The topic looked familiar.

And, reply still stands up, really.  Any hope of new music is the stuff done in CD sessions 10 years ago.

[EmilyGNR]

The topic looked familiar.

And, reply still stands up, really.  Any hope of new music is the stuff done in CD sessions 10 years ago.

From Revolver Interview:
"We recorded a lot of things before 'Chinese' was out," Axl said. "We've worked more on some of those things and we've written a few new things.

Read more at http://www.blabbermouth.net/news/axl-rose-talks-about-new-guns-n-roses-music-possibility-of-more-shows-with-duff-mckagan/#qze0y4uR4vICwhd3.99

[D-GenerationX]

The topic looked familiar.

And, reply still stands up, really.  Any hope of new music is the stuff done in CD sessions 10 years ago.

From Revolver Interview:
"We recorded a lot of things before 'Chinese' was out," Axl said. "We've worked more on some of those things and we've written a few new things.

Read more at http://www.blabbermouth.net/news/axl-rose-talks-about-new-guns-n-roses-music-possibility-of-more-shows-with-duff-mckagan/#qze0y4uR4vICwhd3.99

Oh...well, there you go, then.

[jarmo]

I have a feeling you'll have to remind him of that again between now and the release of the next album. Selective memory and all....


/jarmo

[EmilyGNR]

I have a feeling you'll have to remind him of that again between now and the release of the next album. Selective memory and all....


/jarmo

I'll keep that quote handy 

[Gavgnr]

For me personally, I would really like to hear the remaining stuff from the chinese era.

I would love to hear the second half and after all, there's nothing stopping Guns releasing another album a few years later with the more recently recorded tracks - haha, now I'm just getting greedy 

[Mysteron]

I would rather hear CD II

A live reunion is fine, but I am not sure re-recording together would be a good thing.

[norway]

could be fun if 'cd2' had north-korean themes

[spgunner]

My personal hope is to have one more album with more Chinese Democracy era songs and the Chinese Democracy remixes CD as well. But whatever happens I'll be there!

[Wooody]

could be fun if 'cd2' had north-korean themes

North Korean democracy starts now?

[sofine11]

Someone mentioned that maybe releasing ALL of the unreleased material from both old Guns & new Guns and simply calling the album 'Guns N' Roses' would be cool.  It doesn't exactly seem like Axl is ready to pull the trigger on the second half of 'Chinese' as it is. Why not just put out everything in the vault, perhaps as a double, especially if this reunion thing pans out. Would also give the hybrid lineup including Axl, Slash, Duff (Izzy?) Richard, Frank, Dizzy & Chris some merit.

[Wooody]

Someone mentioned that maybe releasing ALL of the unreleased material from both old Guns & new Guns and simply calling the album 'Guns N' Roses' would be cool.  It doesn't exactly seem like Axl is ready to pull the trigger on the second half of 'Chinese' as it is. Why not just put out everything in the vault, perhaps as a double, especially if this reunion thing pans out. Would also give the hybrid lineup including Axl, Slash, Duff (Izzy?) Richard, Frank, Dizzy & Chris some merit.

A self-titled album sounds like a great idea. A double album even better ! 

[EmilyGNR]

Someone mentioned that maybe releasing ALL of the unreleased material from both old Guns & new Guns and simply calling the album 'Guns N' Roses' would be cool.  It doesn't exactly seem like Axl is ready to pull the trigger on the second half of 'Chinese' as it is. Why not just put out everything in the vault, perhaps as a double, especially if this reunion thing pans out. Would also give the hybrid lineup including Axl, Slash, Duff (Izzy?) Richard, Frank, Dizzy & Chris some merit.

LOL at trying to justify "we want it all and we want it now" mentality by saying it would give a lineup "merit" 

[sofine11]

Someone mentioned that maybe releasing ALL of the unreleased material from both old Guns & new Guns and simply calling the album 'Guns N' Roses' would be cool.  It doesn't exactly seem like Axl is ready to pull the trigger on the second half of 'Chinese' as it is. Why not just put out everything in the vault, perhaps as a double, especially if this reunion thing pans out. Would also give the hybrid lineup including Axl, Slash, Duff (Izzy?) Richard, Frank, Dizzy & Chris some merit.

LOL at trying to justify "we want it all and we want it now" mentality by saying it would give a lineup "merit" 

Emily, you are literally the worst. 

[whiny]

don't know if it's been discussed already - but isn't it possible that duff & slash will do some overdubs n' lay down bass n' guitar tracks on already existing songs (bumblefood kinda did that on "chinese")? so - as the rumoured new lineup - the second half of cd would be old & new guns?

[D-GenerationX]

don't know if it's been discussed already - but isn't it possible that duff & slash will do some overdubs n' lay down bass n' guitar tracks on already existing songs (bumblefood kinda did that on "chinese")? so - as the rumoured new lineup - the second half of cd would be old & new guns?

I would really doubt it.  But would be in favor of any sort of miracle that might get Axl off his ass and think about a release.

If this is that avenue, I say bring it on.