(Possibly) First "Review" of Chinese Democracy - Sort of!

[Neemo]

"Say what you want. If you want to say I'm full of shit, that's fine.

The people involved, band, staff, and loved ones of the band are very protective of this. I asked my friend if it was OK to post this, being vague, but still giving limited details. He said that would be fine.

You could understand if you were to create something that you loved, and was going to be very lucrative besides, and some jerk gave away all of the details making your creation not as special. You might be pretty mad.

If I gave a track listing, what would stop someone from going to a peer to peer and finding everything,? I pinpoint the artwork, then what happens? I'll tell you what, Chinese Democracy on a CDR, with artwork, $5.00 on the street on NYC. Would my friend be pissed off? yes. Would band members and record types be pissed off? yes. Would lawyers? No, but I'm sure they would sue my ass.

I can't give a track listing, I can't give artwork details. I can just tell you to be in line at midnight on relese day to buy this thing. It is a purchase that few are going to regret. "

http://www.velvetrope.com/ubbthreads/showflat.php?Cat=&Board=UBB1&Number=773321&page=0&view=collapsed&sb=5&o=2&fpart=1
-------------------------------------------------------------

he couldnt even give us a track listing...

OK step back for a sec and say this is actually legit info....It's pretty sad that people know they will be flamed for letting us know info about this band. We have no idea if this is real or not. I wonder what people around here will do when all the consspiracy is blown wide open...there won't be anything for the naysayers to talk about.

posts are coming so fast that this reply prolly won't get read anyway *edit: as i typed this 6 replies were made then i post it and nothing

[AxlGunner]

You guys and gals do know that SOME people have heard CD right? And SOME people on that board are insiders in the industry, so before too long someone over there is going to have heard it. Not sayin this guy is legit but lets see if he gets us more before we call him names.

I think the leaks came from the trunk disc, and someone who had a tape handy when Axl did one of his private listening partys...

further solidifying why you don't know ****

 

If you think CITR is from a disc.. you're an idiot, it's a tape recording. If you completely buy Wes's story that some strippers stole the disc or copied a disc of Axl's, I really feel sorry for you.

CITR didn't come from wes... it also didnt come from someone who taped a listening party... actually, i'm not even sure what you mean by "listening party", but i'm pretty sure it's wrong.

[highend88]

JUST ASK HIM ONE THING. ASK HIM TO VERIFY IF "THIS I LOVE" WILL BE ON THE ALBUM.
IF IT IS THERE, ASK IF HE CAN VERIFY THE LYRICS FROM ROSEOFVELVET.COM IS GENUINE.

[Mr.Intensity]

You guys and gals do know that SOME people have heard CD right? And SOME people on that board are insiders in the industry, so before too long someone over there is going to have heard it. Not sayin this guy is legit but lets see if he gets us more before we call him names.

I think the leaks came from the trunk disc, and someone who had a tape handy when Axl did one of his private listening partys...

further solidifying why you don't know ****

 

If you think CITR is from a disc.. you're an idiot, it's a tape recording. If you completely buy Wes's story that some strippers stole the disc or copied a disc of Axl's, I really feel sorry for you.

CITR didn't come from wes... it also didnt come from someone who taped a listening party... actually, i'm not even sure what you mean by "listening party", but i'm pretty sure it's wrong.

I know CITR didn't come from Wes, Citr somehow/someway was taped from an audio device.. whether it be a dj at one of axl's listening partys when he throws them at titty bars/ or night clubs, or whether it be from a studio tech sneaking it out, fact is CITR was from a tape. The other tracks were from a disc or discs, whether you want to believe it was the Trunk Disc+Wes's Disc or the trunk disc, wes disc, plus one other mystery disc.

[Oh My Choking Soul]

JUST ASK HIM ONE THING. ASK HIM TO VERIFY IF "THIS I LOVE" WILL BE ON THE ALBUM.
IF IT IS THERE, ASK IF HE CAN VERIFY THE LYRICS FROM ROSEOFVELVET.COM IS GENUINE.

Are you kidding? He heard the cd, I doubt he memorized it.

[Backslash]

posts are coming so fast that this reply prolly won't get read anyway

I'm with you Neemo...

The guy offered to meet someone with a CD-R in NYC??? ok... my problem with that is, he can't tell anyone the tracklist or artwork, but he's willing to copy the CD... not only that, but the person who buys it off of him could leak it anyway.

At the same time, he could be telling the truth. ?someone should take him up on the offer! ?

[Mr.Intensity]

posts are coming so fast that this reply prolly won't get read anyway

I'm with you Neemo...

The guy offered to meet someone with a CD-R in NYC??? ok... my problem with that is, he can't tell anyone the tracklist or artwork, but he's willing to copy the CD... not only that, but the person who buys it off of him could leak it anyway.

At the same time, he could be telling the truth. ?someone should take him up on the offer! ?

Give me his contact info.. it will take me 30 minutes to find out if he legitimately has a copy of CD or not.  If he has it, I'll put the money where my mouth is...

[Oh My Choking Soul]

You guys and gals do know that SOME people have heard CD right? And SOME people on that board are insiders in the industry, so before too long someone over there is going to have heard it. Not sayin this guy is legit but lets see if he gets us more before we call him names.

I think the leaks came from the trunk disc, and someone who had a tape handy when Axl did one of his private listening partys...

further solidifying why you don't know ****

 

If you think CITR is from a disc.. you're an idiot, it's a tape recording. If you completely buy Wes's story that some strippers stole the disc or copied a disc of Axl's, I really feel sorry for you.

CITR didn't come from wes... it also didnt come from someone who taped a listening party... actually, i'm not even sure what you mean by "listening party", but i'm pretty sure it's wrong.

I know CITR didn't come from Wes, Citr somehow/someway was taped from an audio device.. whether it be a dj at one of axl's listening partys when he throws them at titty bars/ or night clubs, or whether it be from a studio tech sneaking it out, fact is CITR was from a tape. The other tracks were from a disc or discs, whether you want to believe it was the Trunk Disc+Wes's Disc or the trunk disc, wes disc, plus one other mystery disc.

THIS ISN'T A CITR POST!

[GeorgeSteele]

What was on the CD that Axl played in the NYC club in Feb? ?An unmastered version of the entire album? ?Maybe that is what he heard?

[BLS-Pride]

posts are coming so fast that this reply prolly won't get read anyway

I'm with you Neemo...

The guy offered to meet someone with a CD-R in NYC??? ok... my problem with that is, he can't tell anyone the tracklist or artwork, but he's willing to copy the CD... not only that, but the person who buys it off of him could leak it anyway.

At the same time, he could be telling the truth.  someone should take him up on the offer! 

I can be in NYC in 15min. I'll meet this punk and see whats legit and what isn't.

[Jonx]

"Say what you want. If you want to say I'm full of shit, that's fine.

The people involved, band, staff, and loved ones of the band are very protective of this. I asked my friend if it was OK to post this, being vague, but still giving limited details. He said that would be fine.

You could understand if you were to create something that you loved, and was going to be very lucrative besides, and some jerk gave away all of the details making your creation not as special. You might be pretty mad.

If I gave a track listing, what would stop someone from going to a peer to peer and finding everything,? I pinpoint the artwork, then what happens? I'll tell you what, Chinese Democracy on a CDR, with artwork, $5.00 on the street on NYC. Would my friend be pissed off? yes. Would band members and record types be pissed off? yes. Would lawyers? No, but I'm sure they would sue my ass.

I can't give a track listing, I can't give artwork details. I can just tell you to be in line at midnight on relese day to buy this thing. It is a purchase that few are going to regret. "

http://www.velvetrope.com/ubbthreads/showflat.php?Cat=&Board=UBB1&Number=773321&page=0&view=collapsed&sb=5&o=2&fpart=1
-------------------------------------------------------------

he couldnt even give us a track listing...

OK step back for a sec and say this is actually legit info....It's pretty sad that people know they will be flamed for letting us know info about this band. We have no idea if this is real or not. I wonder what people around here will do when all the consspiracy is blown wide open...there won't be anything for the naysayers to talk about.

posts are coming so fast that this reply prolly won't get read anyway

Unfortunatly thats the nature of things these days, im sure there are people out there who have real info but get pissed off by the behaviour of certain people on the boards! Look at it this way, if this story is legit, then CD is done, which means its only a matter of time, this thing cant stay locked up forever, not when $$$$$$$ have been spent on it.

Have a little patience

Jonx

[Mr.Intensity]

What was on the CD that Axl played in the NYC club in Feb? ?An unmastered version of the entire album? ?Maybe that is what he heard?

Yeah, could be....

All I need with him is 5 minutes, then 30-60 minutes to verify any lyrics he might be able to give me from a song we haven't heard.

[oneway23]

There was absolutely nothing substantive in that post...If they did, in fact, hear it, I say good for them...Give me something to sink my teeth into.

[dave-gnfnr2k]

What was on the CD that Axl played in the NYC club in Feb? ?An unmastered version of the entire album? ?Maybe that is what he heard?

Yeah, could be....

All I need with him is 5 minutes, then 30-60 minutes to verify any lyrics he might be able to give me from a song we haven't heard.

how about you do that

[AxlGunner]

posts are coming so fast that this reply prolly won't get read anyway

I'm with you Neemo...

The guy offered to meet someone with a CD-R in NYC??? ok... my problem with that is, he can't tell anyone the tracklist or artwork, but he's willing to copy the CD... not only that, but the person who buys it off of him could leak it anyway.

At the same time, he could be telling the truth.? someone should take him up on the offer!?

I can be in NYC in 15min. I'll meet this punk and see whats legit and what isn't.

i live and work in NYC... i'll meet him with you dude.

[JAC185]

What was on the CD that Axl played in the NYC club in Feb? ?An unmastered version of the entire album? ?Maybe that is what he heard?

All I need with him is 5 minutes, then 30-60 minutes to verify any lyrics he might be able to give me from a song we haven't heard.

Gonna rough him up a bit?

[kaddisonmoore]

nothing to say its true or false really right now

[Oh My Choking Soul]

nothing to say its true or false really right now

...except common sen... nevermind. 

[BLS-Pride]

posts are coming so fast that this reply prolly won't get read anyway

I'm with you Neemo...

The guy offered to meet someone with a CD-R in NYC??? ok... my problem with that is, he can't tell anyone the tracklist or artwork, but he's willing to copy the CD... not only that, but the person who buys it off of him could leak it anyway.

At the same time, he could be telling the truth.  someone should take him up on the offer! 

I can be in NYC in 15min. I'll meet this punk and see whats legit and what isn't.

i live and work in NYC... i'll meet him with you dude.

Yeah seriosuly.. if he offered to meet someone else already.. Why not meet us.. No harm unless fake.

[Mandy.]

What was on the CD that Axl played in the NYC club in Feb? ?An unmastered version of the entire album? ?Maybe that is what he heard?

That's probably it.