(Possibly) First "Review" of Chinese Democracy - Sort of!

[gigger]

The link doesn't even work! FAKE!

That's because the thread was deleted by the original poster after he got sick of being told to fuck off by stupid GnR fans.

stfu he didnt even have proof. couldnt name songs that were on the cd or annytthiinnggg.

He never said he was gonna offer proof and because you got all pissed off at him he isn't ever going to now. ?

because HE DOESNT HAVE IT.

He never claimed to "have it", he claimed he "heard it".

i ment the proof?

Ignoring the harder and less convenient questions are we? 

[Mandy.]

I'm completely baffled.

Why don't you guys believe him again?

[Steel_Angel]

One thing though, if it was fake and he made it up, why didn't he just come up with a fake tracklist when asked to keep the "lie" up?

i dont know, gigger.? figure it out.

[gigger]

One thing though, if it was fake and he made it up, why didn't he just come up with a fake tracklist when asked to keep the "lie" up?

i dont know, gigger.? figure it out.

Your logic - if there isn't proof it must be fake.
My logic - if there isn't proof then it is inconclusive.

Now whose is right? 

Do you, finally, get my argument? Or will I have to try and find another angle to explain it to my very slow friend?

[Steel_Angel]

One thing though, if it was fake and he made it up, why didn't he just come up with a fake tracklist when asked to keep the "lie" up?

i dont know, gigger.? figure it out.

Your logic - if there isn't proof it must be fake.
My logic - if there isn't proof then it is inconclusive.

Now whose is right??

Do you, finally, get my argument? Or will I have to try and find another angle to explain it to my very slow friend?

errmm why wont he name 1 track that he heard? "because people will download it off kazza"? 

let me guess what ur next post will be

"  "?

[gigger]

One thing though, if it was fake and he made it up, why didn't he just come up with a fake tracklist when asked to keep the "lie" up?

i dont know, gigger.? figure it out.

Your logic - if there isn't proof it must be fake.
My logic - if there isn't proof then it is inconclusive.

Now whose is right??

Do you, finally, get my argument? Or will I have to try and find another angle to explain it to my very slow friend?

errmm why wont he name 1 track that he heard? "because people will download it off kazza"??

let me guess what ur next post will be

"? "?

Oh, so not having a clue about how P2P networks work is evidence that he didn't get a listen to CD. Nice work, Sherlock.?

Can someone with a brain (darknemus, Pilferk possibly) help me out trying to reason with this guy?

[dave_guns]

once again the world of gnr fans jumps when any idiot says anything about CD.  after a decade plus you'd think all these people would learn, but i guess not.  there are no insiders.  there are no friends and family sharing discs.  just like always, there is nothing.

[Mandy.]

once again the world of gnr fans jumps when any idiot says anything about CD.? after a decade plus you'd think all these people would learn, but i guess not.? there are no insiders.? there are no friends and family sharing discs.? just like always, there is nothing.

You sure? 

[Steel_Angel]

once again the world of gnr fans jumps when any idiot says anything about CD.? after a decade plus you'd think all these people would learn, but i guess not.? there are no insiders.? there are no friends and family sharing discs.? just like always, there is nothing.

sadly true...

[darknemus]

A. I have no clue if the guy's telling the truth or not.  His story seems plausible, at least.  In addition - none of his other posts were even Guns related on there.  Not like a one post wonder attention whore type, anyway.

B. Just because he didn't give details does NOT mean he's lying.  Of course, it also doesn't mean he's telling the truth.. but it certainly doesn't prove or disprove the guy.

C. Pilferk really does have a brain

D. As the disc gets closer and closer to release - these stories become more and more lkely to be true.. in my opinion.  I'm telling you its only a matter of a few weeks or so until the thing's available online in its entirety.. in my opinion.

-darknemus

[gigger]

once again the world of gnr fans jumps when any idiot says anything about CD.? after a decade plus you'd think all these people would learn, but i guess not.? there are no insiders.? there are no friends and family sharing discs.? just like always, there is nothing.

sadly true...

I give up... I'd have more chance of being able teach a blind man to read then I do trying to use logic with this moron.

You keep shouting fake all over the place and me and the rest of the people with at least half a brain will keep insisting that it is "inconclusive" - not real, nor fake, but inconclusive.

You get it yet? If not, bad luck. You're boring me. ?

[Steel_Angel]

calling me a moron, an idiot, isnt going to help me believe this guy Heard CD, but why dont you go back to mygnrforum? go suck on madisons cock, you're boring me too.?
but seriously, go suck her cock.

[gigger]

calling me a moron, an idiot, isnt going to make me believe this guy Heard CD, but why dont you go back to mygnrforum? go suck on madisons cock, you're boring me too.

 

Did somebody upset you?

I suggest reading this website, you may find it useful in life.

http://www.infidels.org/news/atheism/logic.html

[jarmo]

Shut up already!

We don't care if you two don't like each other..... 



/jarmo

[Steel_Angel]

WHy dont we just take this battle to mygnrforum?

gullable bastard. peace out.

[gigger]

Shut up already!

We don't care if you two don't like each other.....?
/jarmo

Apologies Jarmo. Won't happen again. 

[Mr.Intensity]

#1 The review was way too vague and then he went to kind of trolling activity after his threads were deleted.
#2 I don't believe he could have possibly had a cd with artwork/full package, no Chinese Democracy tracks have been mastered. But yet they've produced artwork for an unmastered demo disc.
#3 He couldn't even give one tiny snippet of a discription of any unleaked song, a tracklisting, or even post a line or two of lyrics from an unleaked song.
#4 He shyed away from all private contact as well which could have possibly verified him.

I know everyone is anxious for the first official review of the cd... but this looks to be a load of crap.

 

[MR W,AXL ROSE]

A. I have no clue if the guy's telling the truth or not.? His story seems plausible, at least.? In addition - none of his other posts were even Guns related on there.? Not like a one post wonder attention whore type, anyway.

B. Just because he didn't give details does NOT mean he's lying.? Of course, it also doesn't mean he's telling the truth.. but it certainly doesn't prove or disprove the guy.

C. Pilferk really does have a brain

D. As the disc gets closer and closer to release - these stories become more and more lkely to be true.. in my opinion.? I'm telling you its only a matter of a few weeks or so until the thing's available online in its entirety.. in my opinion.

-darknemus

in regards to D. do you really think that,and in such a short space in time

[leesixxrose]

#1 The review was way too vague and then he went to kind of trolling activity after his threads were deleted.
#2 I don't believe he could have possibly had a cd with artwork/full package, no Chinese Democracy tracks have been mastered. But yet they've produced artwork for an unmastered demo disc.
#3 He couldn't even give one tiny snippet of a discription of any unleaked song, a tracklisting, or even post a line or two of lyrics from an unleaked song.
#4 He shyed away from all private contact as well which could have possibly verified him.

I know everyone is anxious for the first official review of the cd... but this looks to be a load of crap.

 

sounds about like most people who post on the internet to have heard the cd.....

[gigger]

#4 He shyed away from all private contact as well which could have possibly verified him.

I exchanged at least 5 PMs with him.?

It all depends how you approach people.